Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998)

43 reports from pages 14–16 · 39 Best Buys7 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Worst Buy

John Deere 4850 MFWD tractor

Kathleen and Jim Smolinski, Andover, Ohio · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 14

Kathleen and her husband, Jim, are seeing red over problems they’re having with a green tractor.

“We bought a Deere 4850 MFWD tractor new in 1983,” Kathleen says. “It has only 2,096 hours on it now so it’s not as though we’ve been over working it. But last December, the tractor simply quit moving. We hauled it to a local Deere-trained service technician with 20 years experience. He said the clutch and separator plate had gone out, stopping the tractor and breaking the transmission oil lines.

“He was well versed on this situation, having fixed three other early model 4850’s with the same problem. Turns out, a Deere ‘fix as fail’ service bulletin (R 86-50-9) was issued to dealers in August of 1986 identifying this problem.

“We had our tractor fixed at a cost of $3,365 for parts and $621 for labor, and feel that Deere should reimburse us for the parts that the service bulletin seems to suggest are defective. Our service technician says Deere has paid for parts on the three other tractors he’s fixed and agrees with us that this should never have happened to a tractor with so few hours on it.

“However, we’ve spoken with three different Deere officials both in Ohio and company headquarters and we’ve just been getting the run-around, in part, because the tractor’s 15 years old. It’s pretty frustrating since we contend ‘fix as fail’ means exactly what it says regardless of how old the tractor is.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram pickup + 1 more

Jim Manley, Freer, Texas · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 14

Jim’s “best buy” is a 1991 1-ton Dodge pickup because of its Cummins turbocharged engine and 3:55 rear gear ratio.

“I bought it with 140,000 miles on it. It now has 170,000 and gets 20 mpg on the road. It pulls heavy loads of hay and livestock as easily as it ever did and still gets 10 mpg. One big criticism is that the rest of the truck isn’t nearly as hearty as the engine. For example, the 5-speed transmission has short bearing life and only part-time synchroniz-ers. The body is no dream, either. The top part of the driver’s side door is bent and will not close so the wind screams through it in a crosswind.”

On the negative side, Jim’s “worst buy” is a 1991 3/4-ton Ford pickup equipped with a 351 cu. in. engine with automatic overdrive transmission. “I get less than 9 mpg in overdrive. When using cruise control, it won’t hold its speed up the slightest hill or even in a 15 mph wind. The engine could best be used as a boat anchor. I must admit, however, that it has a strong, reliable body and offers a comfortable ride.

“The decision by Ford Motor Co. to eliminate the Cummins as an engine in its small trucks was not a ‘better idea’”.

Best Buy

Mobile Dimension sawmill

Rod Rhoades, North Star, Alberta · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 14

“The best new product I’ve bought in the last 10 years is a Model 128 Mobile Dimension sawmill,” says Rod (Mobile Manufacturing Co., P.O. Box 250, Troutdale, Ore. 97060; ph 503 666-5593). “It’s one of those rare products that works better than advertised. I’ve cut over 1 million board feet of lumber since I bought it. This mill is a precision machine and is likely to run virtually forever with reasonable care. Any problems I’ve had with it have been entirely my fault.”

Best Buy

John Deere 6400 tractor

George A. Reed, Louisburg, Kan. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 14

A 1995 Deere 6400 tractor with front-wheel-assist and equipped with a 640 mechanical self-leveling bucket is George’s “best buy”.

“It’s a pleasure to do chores with,” George says. “The loader’s controlled with a joystick, has a quick-tach bucket and bale spear for big round bales, and a forklift attachment for handling pallets. My wife also runs this tractor since it’s easy to operate with the quad transmission. I’ve put 1,600 hours on it with only minimal maintenance.”

Best Buy

Claas 44 Rollant round baler

Jim Kehoe, Lansdowne, Ontario · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 14

Jim’s “best buy” is a Claas 44 Rollant round baler that he bought used.

“It cost less than half the price of a new one. I’ve baled over 6,000 bales of hay, straw and silage with it and it’s been virtually trouble-free. It makes a great-shaped bale every time. They stand the weather better than bales from any other baler I’ve used.”

Worst Buy

Trojan propane stock tank

Norman Youngman, Jamesport, Mo. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 14

“My ‘worst buy’ is a Trojan propane stock tank heater I bought new last January,” says Norman (Trojan Livestock Equipment, Conrad, Iowa). “It collected so much moisture on the inside, it put the pilot light out three times. After that, I took it out of the tank because I couldn’t depend on it working.”

Best Buy

Yamaha outboard + 1 more

Dennis Ruensh, East Peoria, Ill. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 14

“If I’m not farming I’m fishing and this outboard motor has performed flawlessly,” says Dennis, pleased with his 1996 Yamaha outboard with electric start and oil injection system. “It starts in 20 degree weather, trolls at idle all day and runs great. The 2-year warranty just ran out and it’s never been back to the shop. I’ve ruined one aluminum and one stainless steel prop but nothing hurts the engine.”

On the other hand, he had bad luck with a 1997 Motor Guide 52-lb. thrust 12-volt trolling motor with electric start. “It didn’t last five minutes on the first trip out. It has constantly been in the shop during its 1-year warranty. It looks good and is priced right but it won’t perform. It’s a piece of junk.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet 2500 pickup equipped

Justin Schafer, Portland, Ind. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 14

Justin’s well satisfied with his 1998 Chevy 2500 pickup equipped with 5.7 liter engine.

“It looks good, has plenty of power, a comfortable cab, and lots of accessories. The 3.78:1 gear ratio is too low, requiring higher engine rpm’s which results in poor gas mileage - 10 to 12 1/2 mpg. Otherwise, I’m quite pleased.”

Best Buy

Ford F-150 4-WD pickup

James Bopp, Cogswell, N. Dak. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 14

“I bought it with 8,000 miles on it. Soon after, I traveled 3,300 miles through ice, snow and cold in the Rocky Mountains and averaged 16 mpg,” says James about his “best buy” 1996 Ford F-150 4-WD pickup. “It handles as well as our Lincoln Town Car.

“I also added a remote auto start, which turned out to be a real convenience. It lets me start the truck from my kitchen or motel room.” (DesignTech International Inc., 7955 Cameron Brown Court, Springfield, Va. 22153; ph 703 866-2000).

Best Buy

Matco Mig welder

Jeff Webster, West Suffield, Conn. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

One of Jeff’s “best buys” is a 1987 Matco Mig welder.

“Since I got the wire feed adjusted properly, I’ve used it on a lot of sheet metal and it really speeds up the process. It’s especially good in the field because it runs on 110 volts. The machine is very portable, but a rolling stand would be convenient. We made one of our own.”

Worst Buy

Ford F-350 4-WD diesel pickup heads

Douglas McKenzie, Stony Plain, Alberta · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

A 1996 Ford F-350 4-WD diesel pickup heads Doug’s “worst buy” list.

“It was so noisy it was unpleasant to drive. I got rid of the truck with only 20,000 miles on it. Two months later, I was contacted by the new owner to see if I’d had any problems with it. Seems the engine block cracked at one of the main bearings (a weak point in the Powerstroke engines). Ford was trying to get out of fixing it by saying that because the truck wasn’t serviced by a Ford dealer, there was no warranty.”

Best Buy

Ford tractors

George Swett, Carmel, Maine · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

Among George’s “best buys” are three Ford tractors - a 1954 NAA, a 1960 881 and a 1966 4000.

“I’ve had very good luck with all these machines,” says George. “The NAA has a Sherman transmission giving it 12 forward, three reverse and three pto speeds. Both the 881 and 4000 have Select-O-Speed transmissions, 2-spd. pto and ground drive.”

Best Buy

Ram 2500 4-WD equipped

Duane E. Haney, Chenoa, Ill. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

The “best buy” 1997 DodgeRam 2500 4-WD equipped with a V-10 engine is Duane’s second Dodge Ram.

“The new one is smoother shifting and quicker starting than my ‘94. After 25,000 miles we haven’t had to replace the thermostat, as we had to do in the ‘94. I’ve heard of two instances of weak springs in the ‘97’s, so I’m having mine replaced. I’ll probably buy another 4-WD Ram for my next truck.

“We use the Rams to haul all our grain out of fields via gooseneck trailers. During the winter, the ‘97 V-10 pulls a 31-ft. fifth wheel camper weighing five tons to Arizona. It’ll cruise 65 to 70 mph at 2,500 rpm’s no problem.”

Best Buy

Hesston square baler + 1 more

Roscoe Haase, Valentine, Neb. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

A 1993 4750Hesston square baler is one of Roscoe’s “best buys”.

“I bought it at a farm sale and had to make some repairs on it. After that, it worked great. It is a well engineered machine and lets you know if the hay is too wet for baling. It’s a simple piece of equipment to operate.”

His “worst buys” were six 36 by 48-ft. hay tarps be bought for $250 apiece from Inland Plastics Ltd. of Drumheller, Alberta. “They were OK if it didn’t get windy. But all it took was one crazy, 60 to 70 mph wind to tear them to shreds. None of the tarps lasted more than a year.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Lincoln 250 wire feed welder + 1 more

Jim Dannen, Hampton, Iowa · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

A Lincoln 250 wire feed welder purchased within the last two years is one of Jim’s “best buys”.

“It’s a quality machine with a stronger arc than many other welders I’ve used,” Jim says.

On the negative side, is a Snap-On 1/2-in. dia. air impact drive. “It never had the power it was supposed to. I finally traded it off for a Mac and am real pleased.”

Best Buy

John Deere 544B 4-WD loader

Roger Biehl, Lexington, Neb. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

“It’s extremely dependable and doesn’t cost much to operate,” says Roger, well pleased with his 1979Deere 544B 4-WD loader. “It currently has 18,000 hours on it. The engine, transmission and axles are all original. It has been back to the dealer for repairs only once in 18 years of service.”

Best Buy

Karcher HD 1050 BX power washer + 1 more

Jake Herzog, Jr., Slingerlands, N.Y. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

“The variable spray nozzle works well and the detergent additive system is extremely precise,” says Jake about his 1995 Karcher HD 1050 BX power washer (Karcher Inc., 1600 Cottontail Lane, Somerset, N.J. 08875; ph 908 356-1199). “My only criticism is that the Honda engine could start a little easier. It always takes at least three pulls when it’s cold.”

Another “best buy” is a Handy Air Lift scissors-style lift fitted with a pneumatic cylinder. It’ll lift objects up to 3 ft. off the ground (Western Mfg., Box 130, Marshalltown, Iowa 50158; ph 515 752-5446). “I bought it for servicing my motorcycles, but it works for just about anything you have to work on. It’s well-built and a real bargain.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet 1500 extended cab pickup + 1 more

Robert E. Swanson, St. James, Minn. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

“It drives great and gets excellent gas mileage,” says Robert about his 1997 Chevy 1500 extended cab pickup equipped with a 350 cu. in. engine.

“My Deere Green Star combine yield monitor is also a ‘best buy’. After two years of collecting data, we’re starting to see where yields are good and where they’re bad.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Sudenga long dia + 1 more

Loren Tucholke, La Bolt, S. Dak. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

“It’s the handiest piece of equipment I own,” says Loren about his “best buy” Sudenga 8-ft. long, 8-in. dia. incline auger equipped with an electric motor (Sudenga Industries Inc., P.O. Box 8, George, Iowa 51237; ph 712 475-3301). “If I have several big augers set up for corn or soybeans, I can wheel it around myself to wherever it’s needed.”

On the negative side, Loren is disappointed with a chrome exhaust pipe from Thomure Mfg., East Prairie, Mo. “I put one on my 1976 Case 2470 4-WD hoping to increase horsepower and reduce maintenance. All I got was noise and plugged up air filters. The pipe was apparently welded wrong and backfed exhaust through the air filter.”

Best Buy

Pro’s Choice 14.4-volt cordless drill

John Trausch, Roseland, Neb. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

John had bad luck with a Pro’s Choice 14.4-volt cordless drill he ordered from Pro’s Edge, Danvers, Mass.

“The drill bits are no good and the screw driver bits get worn down at the slightest resistance, although the drill itself works well. However, the batteries do not hold a charge after two rechargings. Also, after purchasing the drill at what the company calls an excellent price, I found what appeared to be the exact same drill with the exact same accessories in a tool catalog for $30 less.”

Worst Buy

Agco-Allis tractors

Donald Spencer, Lucerne, Ind. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

Donald’s two “worst buys” are both 6690 4-WD Agco-Allis tractors - a 1993 and a 1996 model.

“I had nothing but problems with the 1993 model until the company finally replaced it with the 1996,” says Donald. “The new one didn’t shift right. You couldn’t get it into or out of gear if it was moving at all. Then the gears locked up at 200 hours. The dealer split the tractor in the shop and found that the factory had installed the wrong clutch, throw out bearings and pilot bearing. They fixed the problems, and that helped for a short while. At about 400 hours it started to lock up again. So the dealer unhooked some kind of electrical switch on reverse. That helped get the gears unstuck but the tractor would still lock up.

“In addition, the pto never worked right. Neither did the air conditioning or heater. The hydraulics never worked on either tractor. The right front wheel on the ‘96 bent because it was built of poor materials.

“The company is going to replace this tractor with a 1998 8745, but that’s going to cost me $6,000.

“I’d like to know if any other farmers have had trouble with the 6690’s. You can contact me at: 1180 E. Co. Rd. 1000 N, Lucerne, Ind. 46950.”

Best Buy

John Deere sickle mower

Clayton Karrigan, Benson, Minn. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

“It’s still going strong after all these years,” says Clayton about his Deere 7-ft. sickle mower with castor wheel on back that he bought new in 1952.

“We’ve mowed everything imaginable with it, including CRP land filled with gopher mounds and hailed-down alfalfa. This mower was built to last.”

Best Buy

John Deere 5300 fitted

Ed Jenkins, Morris, Ala. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

“This tractor has performed flawlessly both harvesting and hay-feeding,” says Ed, pleased with his 1993 Deere 5300 fitted with a 520 loader. “The tractor and loader seem to be perfectly matched and both are very quick. Plenty of power and comfort make the 5300 a pleasure to operate.”

Best Buy

DeWalt 18-volt trim saw + 1 more

Douglas Yergens, Blanchard, Idaho · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

Douglas counts his DeWalt 18-volt trim saw and Makita 12-volt drill as two “best buys”.

“The trim saw has lots of power and is very handy to use. It definitely needs two batteries so you never have to wait on a charge.

“My Makita has been with me for six years. It has been used for everything from barn roof repair to hanging curtains. It’s hard to believe how versatile it is.”

Best Buy

Ford 4000 tractor + 1 more

John Hardage, Lockhurst, Texas · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

“My ‘best buy’ is a 1966 52 hp Ford 4000 tractor I bought used,” says John. “It’s always been dependable and rugged. It starts every time. I use it for mowing, digging post holes, and plowing and I’ve never done a thing to it except change the oil.”

John’s also pleased with his DeWalt 14-in. chop saw, which has given no problems whatsoever in the three years he’s owned it. “Cuts straight every time,” he says.

Best Buy

Ram pickup equipped

Rubin L. Teat, Jr., Rainsville, Ala. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

“I’d like to trade for a new one, but this one just keeps on giving me great service,” says Rubin about his “best buy” 1982 Dodge pickup equipped with 318 cu. in. engine with 4-speed overdrive transmission. “It has 435,000 miles on it and still runs great. The air conditioning still works.

“I have two other 1984 Dodge pickups equipped with 318 cu. in. engines and automatic transmissions. One has 275,000 miles on it and the other has 185,000. Guess you could say they’re all ‘best buys’”.

Best Buy

Snap-On Tools

Pat Kelly, Charlo, Mont. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

Pat’s “best buy” is a wire welder he bought 15 years ago from Snap-On Tools and manufactured by System Matics. “I’ve had absolutely no trouble with it in all the years I’ve used it in my farm repair and manufacturing shop,” he says. “I don’t think there’s any way it could be improved upon.”

Best Buy

Ram Caravans

Ervin Schultz, Bowbells, N. Dak. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

Ervin’s owned two Dodge Caravans and he’s been well pleased with both. “The first was a 1984 model that gave us 200,000 miles of service with only two $500 repairs,” he says. “The second is a 1994 Grand Caravan that we’ve put 94,000 miles on. The only repair it’s needed was a water pump replacement.”

Best Buy

John Deere 4430 + 1 more

Keith Russell, Cremona, Alberta · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

“My 1976 Deere 4430 has 8,000 hours on it. The only thing we’ve had problems with is the transmission. It’s a reliable tractor that puts out 144 hp on the dynometer.

“My 1989 Ford F-250 pickup equipped with a 351 cu. in. V-8 engine is my worst buy. It was always in the shop and was hard on fuel. I think the problem is that it’s geared too high.”

Best Buy

Ford Genesis 8970 front wheel assist

Warren Brown, Climax, Sask. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

“The powershift transmission makes this tractor a dream to operate,” says Warren about his 1995 Ford Genesis 8970 front wheel assist tractor. “It’s easy to operate and is easy on fuel. It had some minor hydraulic problems, but my dealer solved them immediately.”

Best Buy

AT-300 multi-purpose lathe-mill-drill

Neil Bertelsen, Caroline, Alberta · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 15

“I’m impressed with my 1996 AT-300 multi-purpose lathe-mill-drill made in China (distributed by House of Tools, 100 Mayfield Common N.W., Edmonton, Alberta T5P 4B3 ph 800 661-3987). What I like about it was the cost - $1,600. It does accurate work and is very versatile. It’s built heavy so it’s easy to use. It’s made a little crude and has no backfeed, but it didn’t cost $6,000 or $7,000 like comparable machines so I’m happy with it.”

Best Buy

Miller Bobcat 225 welder + 2 more

Ken Schultz, Chicago, Ill. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 16

“I’ve welded everything from sheet metal to 1 1/2-in. thick steel with my 1995 Miller Bobcat 225 welder and it has performed beautifully. It’s equipped with a generator that allows me to take it into the field for performing jobs such as operating a grinder, etc.

“I’m impressed with my 1997 DeWalt 9.6-volt cordless drill. I’ve used it to drive more than 200 screws without having to recharge the battery. It comes with an extra battery which is nice to have on hand.

“I have a complaint with SearsCraftsman tools, particularly their screwdrivers, breaker bars, and ratchets. Recently it seems that they’re making these tools thinner and with less steel than the original ones. I’ve had to exchange a 1/2-in. breaker bar three times in one month. The screwdriver tips break with just the slightest use, and I’ve had more than one ratchet come apart in my hand. It’s a good thing these tools are guaranteed, but it’s still a hassle to have to drive back and forth to exchange them.”

Best Buy

Nova plastic nose cone

Sidney Sellars, Newport, Nova Scotia · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 16

Sidney likes the Nova plastic nose cone that he uses for skidding logs (Nova Sylva Inc., 915 Blais St., Sherbrooke, Quebec, Canada). “It has saved me countless trips between the tractor and log. It’ll even guide a tree up over a brush pile. It’s light and easy to handle. I wondered whether it would hold up in cold weather, but durability hasn’t been a problem.”

Best Buy

Steve has been farming for 26 years and currently has 2,000 acres unde

Steve Baugher, Manila, Ark. · Vol. 22, No. 3 (1998), p. 16

Steve has been farming for 26 years and currently has 2,000 acres under cultivation. “In February, 1995, I bought a Deere 8300 4-WD tractor. I paid $90,000 for the tractor plus $2,250 for an extended warranty. From the beginning, the tractor shifted rough and would sometimes almost completely stop between gear shifts. The dealer could find nothing wrong. About a month after we bought it, while traveling at about 17 mph in high gear, the wheels locked up. The driver was thrown against the steering wheel and the engine killed. The transmission continued to lock up as the tractor was driven back to our shop. “The dealer took it to his shop and after it was returned the power steering locked, almost causing an accident. And the transmission was still not working right. The dealer picked up the tractor for repairs and requested a new transmission from the company, but Deere refused. Deere also refused to send someone out to identify a foreign material found in the valves that control the transmission. “We then had to wait while the dealer ordered stands to split the tractor and special tools to work on the transmission. Meanwhile, I was getting nervous because I needed the tractor to plant my 2,000 acres of crops. With just one 12-row planter, I have to start planting early. Neither Deere nor the local dealer offered a loaner tractor. “At one point, the mechanics removed the pto and determined that the differential was the source of the foreign material in the transmission. They replaced the entire differential and rebuilt the transmission. The tractor was in the shop for 25 days. “Five days after we got it back, the power steering locked up and the dealer’s mechanic determined that the transmission needed to be overhauled again. “At this point I went to the dealer and asked to look at the parts which had been taken from the tractor the first time. The old differential had the word ‘broken’ written on it. The shop foreman stated that it had been installed that way at the factory. “On April 14th, I bought a new Deere 8400 tractor in order to get our crops planted, paying $106,500 for it. “Deere Credit called about nine months later to demand the annual payment on the tractor, which still had not been repaired, and I declined to pay. Soon after, another Deere dealer repossessed the tractor. “Here’s where the story gets interesting. Deere shipped the tractor to a dealer in Kansas where it was sold to a nearby farmer. I’ve talked to the farmer who now owns the tractor and he was unaware of the history of the tractor when he bought it. “Deere’s warranty claim history on the Deere 8300 tractor now shows that the second and third transmission repairs were made in Kansas, and that the repairs were made after 477 hours of operation. This means either that the trasmission failed two additional times in Kansas and the two earlier failures were hidden from any prospective buyer, or that the site and hours-period were changed so it looked like the tractor had been used for a much longer period before it failed.” Baugher has filed suit against Deere & Co. in Iowa because the tractor was manufactured in Waterloo. He’s asking for compensation to cover expenses related to purchase and repair of the 8300, funds for lost cotton production due to the late planting start, a correction to his credit report, attorney fees, and punitive damages if Deere & Co. had prior knowledge of the tractor’s defects. Baugher’s attorney is Lawrence H. Crosby of St. Paul, Minn.