Generac: what farmers say
17 reports in FARM SHOW · 6 Best Buys11 Worst Buys
Generac backup electric generator
3 Best Buys5 Worst Buys“My Generac backup electric generator is my worst and most disappointing buy. It had problems within the first week after being professionally installed. The starter battery would drain down to a too-low voltage and was unable to start the engine. I remedied the problem by buying and installing a low amp battery charger that was left on continually.
“The second problem was engine oil spraying out of the oil dipstick holder when the engine was running. This caused the oil spray to be sucked into the generator through the cooling fins resulting in having to replace the brushes and clean the windings. The factory installed the wrong type of O-ring, which was an incorrectly sized hydraulic one instead of just a normal one. There was no warranty for this.
“The third problem was continuous. The exhaust valve kept seating deeper into the head and needed an adjustment after every three times it ran. This eventually led to buying a brand-new head and getting a certified mechanic to install it. This wasn’t covered by warranty either.
“The final defiant act of this defective generator was when it seized up after running a short time in a temperature of -48 F. This also wasn’t covered by warranty.
“I should’ve read FARM SHOW’s ‘Best and Worst Buys’ from a previous issue where a fellow reader had similar problems with his Generac generator. I would’ve saved a lot of time, money, and aggravation. On the brighter side, since I uninstalled the Generac, I have more time to read FARM SHOW, and I have a great battery charger.”
“We suffer from chronic power outages. Our Generac dual-fuel 7500-watt generator has been a lifesaver. I bought the dual-fuel because it was in stock at the time. We had an outage that necessitated using all the gas we had but luckily, I had two 20-lb. propane bottles on hand that got us through. This generator starts every time on the first attempt and is efficient. Ten gals. of gas and 20 lbs. of propane got us through 2 1/2 days.
“I used my Scag Liberty 52 zero-turn mower for 2 hrs. and sold it. It was a $5,500 mower that wouldn’t cut grass. Any grass areas higher than 4-in. and the mower would just struggle to cut it, causing the mower to stall out every time. My Deere X320 was down because I needed a part. When I put the X320 back in service it mowed the same areas with ease. Scag offers a lot of hype, but they don’t live up to it when it comes to consumer products.”
“The 2016 Generac generator I bought at Northern Tool is my worst buy. The gas shutoff valve and settlement glass fell out of the fuel tank, and I couldn’t order a new tank.”
“I give my Stihl chainsaw a thumbs up. The gas sold in Michigan has quite a bit of ethanol in it so to make this saw run better I use REC-90 fuel in it. It’s an ethanol-free, 90-octane unleaded gasoline blend that’s mostly used in boats and snowmobiles. It costs about $1 per gal. more than regular unleaded gas, but is totally worth it. I use it in all my small engines and have never had a problem.
“I had a Generac home backup generator installed last fall and it works exactly like the company says (www.generac.com; ph 888 436-3722). Knowing we’ll always have power is a huge relief, and I like not having to drag out a generator during power outages.”
“The Generac generator that I use on my motorhome is my worst buy. It’s hard to start and won’t shut off properly. I get quite disgusted when it doesn’t run because it happens when there isn’t any electricity to plug into. I’ve had it worked on several times, but with no results.”
Freeman is disappointed with his 2004 Genamaxx portable diesel 7.5-kilowatt generator. “I use it to provide backup power for my house and also to provide power at a remote shop on my farm. I’ve had to return the generator for repair work seven times in nine months, with one motor blow-up. The rest of the problems had to do with the generator not producing enough power. At first the company made the repairs or gave me a new generator under warranty, but later I had to deliver my machine to their shop which is a 3-hour drive in one direction.
“Last April the company gave me a new generator part which I had to install myself. I was told there was no more warranty coverage on my machine even though it had less than 110 hours on it. They told me I was overloading the generator with the arc welder I was using so I haven’t used that welder since then, but four months later the power failed again. Now I have a generator that won’t produce enough kilowatts. I gave up on it and recently purchased a new Generac generator from a different supplier.”
“My 2005 Honda Odyssey EXL minivan is our best buy. When we bought it my wife talked me into getting a car-based navigation system. This is our first experience with a navigation system, and we love it. It’s very user friendly and has kept us from getting lost on numerous occasions. The van rides and handles like a car and is fuel efficient, as the engine switches from six cylinders to three cylinders during steady driving.
“My Generac generator is a best buy. We have a lot of power outages in our rural area, and after being without electricity for five days during the 2004 Christmas holidays, we knew we had to buy a larger generator with 240-volt capacity so we could at least operate our well pump. So far have been well pleased with it. It has electric start and a low oil sensor, and it will idle down whenever it’s not under load. It generates 7,500 watts and has a surge capacity of 13,500 watts. Several weeks ago our power was off for 21 hours but we were still able to power the well pump, a freezer, two refrigerators, TV, lights, and barn fans with no problem.”
On the negative side, “By far the worst buy we’ve ever made is our Water Furnace geothermal heating and cooling system (www.WaterFurnace.com). We built our house in 1987 and installed a York heat pump with a propane furnace for backup. The system was set to turn the heat pump off and the propane furnace on whenever the outside temperature dropped below 30 degrees. This system operated flawlessly for 15 years, with only one minor service call for the heat pump.
“During the summer of 2002 we decided the heat pump was probably nearing the end of its life cycle and, with propane costs rising each year, we wanted a lower cost system. We did a lot of research and decided to purchase this company’s premier 3-ton geothermal heating and cooling system. We kept our propane furnace for emergency backup and were assured by the dealer that it would rarely if ever be needed. During the first winter, the new geothermal system couldn’t heat the house and we used over 200 gallons of propane. The company said the underground loop just needed time to settle in. But the next winter the problem got even worse. I contacted the company again, was given the runaround, and finally told to work with the dealer to solve the problem. Not very good customer support.
“This summer has been warmer than the previous two, and the system runs in A/C mode all day long just to keep the house at 73 degrees. To add insult to injury, this system has required three service calls (due to a defective loop pump, defective capacitor, and defective circuit board) since it was installed. In hindsight we would have saved a lot of money by replacing our old heat pump with a new, high efficiency model that I’m told would operate without propane back-up down to 10 degrees above zero or lower.”
“In the fall of 1998 I bought a Toro leaf blower to blow down cob webs and dust in our barn. I was well pleased with it the first year, but the next year I was able to run it less than a half hour before it quit working. I took it back to the dealer who said it would probably cost more to fix it than to buy a new one, even though he never even looked at the machine. It wasn’t quite a year old and it was supposed to have a two-year warranty. I wrote to the company but they never replied.
“One of my best buys is my Case-IH 8520 in-line baler. I can’t say enough good things about it. I had a New Holland 311 model that worked fine except that it wouldn’t make two bales alike. The Case-IH model makes every bale the same regardless of field conditions.
“One of my worst buys of all time was a Generac generator. I got less than one hour of use from it even though it was in the shop for repairs three different times. I got so sick of it that I traded it for a Winco, which I like. I paid $2,300 for the Generac and got only a $900 allowance toward the Winco.
“I’m unhappy with Goodyear tires. I have a 72 hp front wheel assist tractor equipped with Goodyear tires and although we haven’t used the front wheel assist at all, the front tires have worn down to a tread thickness of only 1/4 to 1/2 inch in only 200 hours. I have another tractor equipped with Goodyear tires, but that won’t happen again.
“My Claas rotary hay rake and my Miller Pro rotary hay rake both do excellent work. However, the Miller Pro model is built much heavier. It cost a little more than the Claas, and time will tell if it lasts longer. I think hay cures faster with rotary rakes than it does with conventional wheel rakes.”
Generac 10 hp 6
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“I like my 2001 Stanley hydrostatic garden tractor equipped with a 17 1/2 hp engine and a 42-in. mower deck. It starts easy and steers easy, and it has a short 16-in. turning radius. It’s equipped with a 2.7-gal. fuel tank which results in a long running time. I really like the infinite speeds available because of the tractor’s hydrostatic pedal drive system. This mower is simple to maintain, and changing belts on it is an easy job. I can use a toll-free phone number to order parts if they’re needed.
“My 2001 Generac 10 hp, 6,000-watt generator is my worst buy. It had less than five minutes on it when the low-oil switch on the motor shut it down, even though the oil reservoir was full. I just wired around the switch and since then I’ve used the generator for a few light jobs with no more shut-downs. I just make sure that I check the oil every time I refuel. The generator has a big 5-gal. gas tank on it, which I like, and is equipped with a decompression release valve so it starts easy.”
Generac 3200 psi pressure washer
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My Generac 3200 psi pressure washer always starts on the first or second pull. I get about 4 hrs. of runtime to a tank of gas, and I have used it for about 100 hrs. to wash the house, concrete, vehicles, and about anything else that needed a deep clean. It also works great for removing loose paint.”
Generac 3500 psi pressure washer
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“My Deere 946 discbine is my best buy. It cuts close even in down hay. I flipped the knives over for the first time after cutting 500 acres. It takes only about 10 minutes to change the knives and costs $22. The cost to operate this machine is quite low.
“My Generac 3500 psi pressure washer is my worst buy. At 20 hours the pump - made by Caterpillar - blew up. Caterpillar wouldn’t warranty the pump because they said it had run out of oil. Yet I know the pump was full of oil when I started it that morning. A pair of local mechanics looked at the pieces and they both said the journals weren’t scarred and that the problem was a faulty connecting rod. Caterpillar wanted $1,200 for a new pump, yet I only paid $1,100 for the entire washer, which is equipped with a Honda engine. I ended up installing an AR pump for $500.”
Generac 8kw propane-powered standby generator
0 Best Buys1 Worst BuyJohn nominates his 2012 Generac 8kw propane-powered standby generator as his “worst buy”. “Soon after I bought this unit it started to backfire and blew off the air cleaner housing. After poor phone guidance from the company, I finally found an authorized service agent to come out. But they wanted to charge for extra mileage because the company only pays warranty for 50 miles, and I live farther away than that. A month later the parts arrived and were installed, but we ran the generator for less than 30 seconds before the same thing happened again. Now the company won’t return my phone calls or emails, and their service people won’t do any more warranty work.”
Generac Guardian 13kW generator
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My Generac Guardian 13kW generator is my best buy (www.generac.com; ph 888 436-3722). I recently came across the operator’s manual and was surprised to find my generator is already 10 years old. The only maintenance it has needed so far was for a new oil filter and battery.”
Generac Synergy 7040 22 kw home
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“No problems with my 2016 Cub Cadet Z-Force zero-turn riding mower equipped with a steering wheel and 48-in. deck. I use it to cut about one acre of grass 2 or 3 times per month. I haven’t had to replace a single belt.
“My 2016 Cub Cadet Challenger 500 utility vehicle works great.
“My worst buy is my 2018 Generac Synergy 7040 22 kw, home stand-by generator equipped with a 200-amp SE rated automatic transfer switch. I’ve spent more than $10,000 on this generator but it hasn’t produced even one minute of power for us during a power outage, and we’ve had several of them. It came with a 5-year warranty.
“We had to buy a 250-gal. propane tank. Two months after installation, our power went out and the generator wouldn’t run, showing an alarm code. I contacted the company and they told me how to reset the unit. They said if the problem happened again it would probably be due to a bad controller, and that I should have a qualified dealer fix it.
“The power went out again and the same alarm code came on, so I called a dealer. It took 4 weeks for someone to come out and check the unit, and all they did was refer me to another dealer who couldn’t fix it.
“Finally I called an electrician but they wouldn’t work on it because they’ve had problems in the past getting Generac to pay them.
“My wife and I are elderly and live alone on a small farm. Generac sends us emails explaining how much they care about their customers, but we can’t get them to repair our generator even though it’s still under warranty.”
Generac XG8000E generator
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysTroy’s pleased with his 2010 New Holland CR9070 combine. “I run it with a 40-ft. MacDon header approximately 300 hrs./year. I’ve had almost no downtime during harvest. I get a very clean sample with minimal losses. I’ll be sticking with the NH twin rotor when it’s time to upgrade.
“I haven’t been happy with my Generac XG8000E generator. The battery was dead out of the box. It also kills batteries very quickly. It’s almost impossible to start. Once it’s running, it’ll power the house but it’s just a nightmare to get started.”
Generac power washer equipped
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“My Generac power washer equipped with a Briggs & Stratton 3 1/2 hp engine is my worst buy. I used it twice and then it wouldn’t start. The carburetor is made from plastic and has no adjustments. I had to replace the gasket between the gas tank and the carburetor every time I used this machine. The dealer told me to quit using ethanol and instead to just use premium gas. He said alcohol in the ethanol would ruin the gasket. I wish I had bought an electric-powered washer instead.”
Generac electric pressure washer
0 Best Buys1 Worst BuyA 1999 GM 3/4-ton pickup equipped with a 6000 Vortec V-8 engine rates as Thomas’s “best buy”. “It has all the power I need and is the best pickup I’ve ever owned. It rides great and is reasonably fuel efficient.
“My worst buy is my Generac electric pressure washer. It couldn’t generate enough pressure, which was very disappointing. The attachments for it are flimsy and hard to put on. I called the company but it didn’t do any good.”
Read every report in full
FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.