McCormick: what farmers say
13 reports in FARM SHOW · 8 Best Buys5 Worst Buys
McCormick 105 tractor equipped
1 Best Buy1 Worst Buy“My Chinese-made Foton 824, 82 hp tractor is my worst buy. I bought it because I have owned 6 Massey tractors and 2 Massey combines with the same series Perkins engines. However, this tractor vibrates so bad that the first time we used it the 3-pt. top link fell off, and it put both my hands to sleep.
“The tractor is very noisy. My wife can hear me coming from ¾-mile away. We also had problems with the air conditioner, which kept going on and off. In summer if I loaded the tractor to capacity the radiator would get so hot that it would boil over. In winter I’d have to run the tractor 45 minutes before the cab got warm. The dealer couldn’t fix any of these problems even though he had the tractor for 5 months. We only put 300 hours on it in two years. I finally told him I didn’t want the tractor back unless they could fix it right. He eventually bought it back from me but I lost money on the deal.
“My son recently bought a McCormick 105 tractor equipped with the same engine, and it runs great.”
A 2004 McCormick 105 tractor rates as David’s “worst buy”. “The hydraulic pump had to be replaced four times after only 750 hours. The last time it happened the pump got hot enough to melt the fuel tank. My dealer was unsuccessful in getting the company to respond to the problem.”
McCormick MTX 150 front wheel assist
1 Best Buy1 Worst Buy“My 2008 McCormick MTX 150 front wheel assist tractor equipped with a McCormick L160 front-end loader has a lot of power and is fuel efficient and quiet. The loader is built heavy. I use it with a bucket-mounted bale spear and dozer blade. The joystick control is smooth and easy to use, and the shuttle shift transmission works great for loader work.”
On the negative side, he lists his White rear-fold, narrow row planter. “I had to do more work on this planter in 2 seasons than I did on my IH planters in 25 years. It has about 60 grease zerks and they’re always plugged. The row units are built too light. It’s hard to change crops and population settings, and the planter squeaks terribly going through the field, which drives us crazy. We were happy to get rid of it and go back to Case IH.”
“At work we use a McCormick MTX 150 tractor. It recently caught fire due to a leak in the tractor’s hydraulic system. I was wondering if anyone else has had this problem?”
McCormick 150 front wheel assist
0 Best Buys1 Worst BuyHe’s had problems with his 2006 McCormick 150 front wheel assist tractor. “In 2013 with about 830 hours on the tractor, I switched the pto from 540 to 1,000 rpm’s so I could use the tractor to operate my stalk chopper. However, I was able to chop stalks for only about a half day before the pto quit working. It cost $1,533.99 to repair. I was told that I had damaged a 1/4-in. pin when I switched the pto.
“Last year I again wanted to switch the pto from 540 to 1,000 rpm’s. However, I was having trouble making the change so I took the tractor back to the dealer who, with some difficulty, made the change. This time I was able to drive only about 300 ft. before the pto quit working. The dealer’s mechanic told me many other customers have had the same problem.
“I finally finished chopping stalks with my 1972 IH 1066 tractor, which has about 4,000 hrs. on it.”
McCormick 4-WD tractor equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“In 2006 I bought a new McCormick 4-WD tractor equipped with a 70 hp Perkins diesel engine. I also bought an Agmeier 150 hp Bush Hog (ph 800 446-7319; www.ag-meier.net) to use with it. Both machines work great.
“At the same time I bought a Westendorf TA 26 front-end loader, which has been nothing but trouble from day one. The bucket’s hydraulic cylinders were weak. The dealer replaced them immediately but the cylinders still leak even after they were repacked 3 times. Last year I sent the company a certified letter asking them to replace the bucket cylinders, but the letter was returned 2 months later, unclaimed. Then I sent the letter by regular mail, but I’m still waiting for a reply.
“I recently added 4 bottles of SealLube to the cylinders, which slowed down the leakage a little. One of the cylinders has always shown heavy rust streaks on it. I would’ve expected this company to stand behind its products and at least reply to a customer. On the plus side, the loader itself is built heavy.”
McCormick C100 tractor equipped
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“My 2005 McCormick C100 tractor equipped with an L750 front-end loader is my worst buy. I bought it to do cattle chores. I ordered it with the largest hydraulic pump available, yet the loader moves very slowly unless the engine rpm’s are running at about 2,000 rpm’s. This tractor’s hydraulic performance is very poor.”
McCormick C-90 tractor
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 2002 McCormick C-90 tractor is my best buy. It steers and shifts easy, runs quiet, and has more power than an IH 806 model. It’s also easy on fuel, and all the controls on it are easy to reach.”
McCormick CX100 tractor equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysA 2001 McCormick CX100 tractor equipped with a Perkins 4-cyl. turbocharged engine rates as John’s “best buy.” “It handles well with a comfortable cab, and it’s built better than Ford or New Holland tractors. It has had some problems, but my dealer quickly took care of them. When you spend $50,000 to $100,000 on a new tractor, it’s the little stuff that really makes you mad. For example, I’d like to see a more convenient place for storing coffee. And why is there never a decent-sized, waterproof toolbox mounted as standard equipment on the outside of the tractor? Also, why don’t tractors come factory equipped with tubeless tires with tire sealant already installed in them?”
McCormick CX-105 tractor
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My McCormick CX-105 tractor has had continuous mechanical breakdowns. It has 475 hrs. on it and twice left me stranded on a hillside. The air conditioner quit working, the transmission sprang a leak, and the pto clutch had to be repaired. The company refused to take care of these problems. I’ve since learned that other farmers have had multiple breakdowns with their McCormick tractors. This tractor is nice to drive when it’s working, but it isn’t much good if it’s not.”
McCormick F-90 Orchard tractor
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysTodd’s the proud owner of a 2003 McCormick F-90 Orchard tractor. “I use it for my business planting native grasses and providing ecological management services in the Chicago area. This tractor is dependable, affordable, and very nimble on rough ground and steep slopes that I work on. It has a Perkins diesel engine which delivers a surprising amount of power. Its cooling system could be better, but overall I’m happy with this tractor.”
McCormick XTX 145 front wheel assist
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysTom’s impressed with his 2010 McCormick XTX 145 front wheel assist tractor equipped with an L175 front-end loader with grapple fork. “I put 550 hrs. on this tractor moving round bales and pulling a field sprayer equipped with a 1,500-gal. tank and 100-ft. boom. This tractor is easy to operate and the controls are well placed. I especially like the finger tip shift control and how it shifts smoothly up or down. A hydraulic hose failed but was replaced under warranty. Also, there was a factory recall of a computer control. Otherwise, this tractor has worked great.”
McCormick XTX200 tractor
0 Best Buys1 Worst BuyRay’s disappointed with his 2006 McCormick XTX200 tractor. “I paid $86,000 for this piece of scrap iron. It has only about 2,250 hrs. on it and has spent more time in the shop than in the field. Seems like every time I want to use this tractor something on it goes wrong. The company won’t stand behind its product.”
Read every report in full
FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.