Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Brands › New Idea

New Idea: what farmers say

22 reports in FARM SHOW · 18 Best Buys4 Worst Buys

New Idea 5209 disc mower

5 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Best Buy
Walter Pinkowski, Jr., Argyle, N.Y. · Vol. 43, No. 6 (2019), p. 14

“Our Massey Ferguson 283 tractor equipped with a Massey Ferguson A10 loader is easy to service. We use this little ‘bulldozer’ to push and pack silage in our trench silos.

“I bought a used 2004 Dodge 3/4-ton diesel pickup with about 185,000 miles and it hasn’t had any problems.

“I use my 1988 New Idea 5209 disc mower to cut about 250 acres of hay per year. The hitch on this mower isn’t pretty, but the mower cuts great.”

Best Buy
Walter Pinkowski, Jr., Argyle, N.Y. · Vol. 28, No. 6 (2004), p. 15

“My New Idea 5209 disc mower is my best buy. The machine I have was the company’s first prototype and was used for demonstrations. I use it to cut about 450 acres of hay every year. I replaced a long shaft that drives the discs, and I replaced the turtles and shields once. My only complaint is that the hitch should be built heavier.

“Our 1998 Massey Ferguson 283 tractor equipped with an Alo front-end loader is a best buy.”

Best Buy
Donald A. Schremp, Ste. Genevieve, Mo. · Vol. 25, No. 5 (2001), p. 15

“My 1991 New Idea 5209 discbine has been trouble-free and is my best buy. I’ve used it to cut 3,000 to 4,000 acres of hay in hilly ground with some rocks in the fields. The only reason I would get rid of it would be to buy a new one just like it.

“The windshield wipers on my 1995 Chevrolet 1500 pickup don’t work and the and the dealer can’t seem to fix them.

“One of my worst buys is a 1981 International Harvester 986 tractor which has only about 3,200 hours on it. I’ve had problems with the cab mounts, transmission, clutch, two hydraulic pumps, injection pump, pto shaft, air conditioner, and front wheel spindle.”

Worst Buy
Victor Miller, Halfway, Mo. · Vol. 23, No. 5 (1999), p. 15

Victor’s impressed with his 1998 Deere round baler. “It’s an outstanding baler that needs very little maintenance. I used it to make more than 4,000 bales the first year, including 1,000 silage bales. I never had a problem with it plugging up or with starting a bale, whether I was making wet or dry bales.

“My worst buy is my New Idea 5209 disc mower-conditioner. It’s a high maintenance mower that isn’t designed for custom haying. The pods on it have to be greased about every two weeks. Another problem is that it rides on little shoes that don’t last even a year. It should have adjustable skids.”

Best Buy
Dick Gardner, Roscommon, Mich. · Vol. 21, No. 4 (1997), p. 16

Dick’s impressed with his 1994 New Idea 5209 disc mower. “The thicker the hay the better it seems to cut. It does a great job on down and tangled hay and has never plugged up. I can mow with it as fast as I can stay in the tractor seat. The cut hay dries faster than it does with a sickle mower. It takes only three minutes to change a broken knife.”

Best Buy
Dick Gardner, Roscommon, Mich. · Vol. 21, No. 3 (1997), p. 12

Dick’s impressed with his 1994 New Idea 5209 disc mower. “The thicker the hay the better it seems to cut. It does a great job on down and tangled hay and has never plugged up. I can mow with it as fast as I can stay in the tractor seat. The cut hay dries considerably faster than it does with a sickle mower. It takes only three minutes to change a broken knife.”

New Idea 4844 round baler

2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Robert M. Corbin, Finksburg, Md. · Vol. 23, No. 2 (1999), p. 14

Robert’s much happier with his 1998 New Idea 4844 round baler than he was with the Deere 430 baler he had before.

“The hydraulic pump on the Deere wouldn’t operate at anything less than maximum rpm’s. It was such a heavy machine it required a 70 hp tractor to pull it to make a 4 by 4-ft. bale. It wouldn’t work properly in dry or damp conditions. The ‘Bale Command’ electronics also didn’t work well.

“On the other hand, the New Idea requires little horsepower. The bales it produces are consistently the same size and weight. It’s a lightweight, compact machine and the electronic bale wrap feature works well.”

Best Buy
Michael Leary, Wallkill, N.Y. · Vol. 22, No. 6 (1998), p. 16

Michael nominates his 1998 New Idea 5408 disc mower as his “best buy”. “It’s well built and has blades that can be replaced quickly. No problems and no downtime.

“My 1997 New Idea 4844 round baler is a best buy. It takes less than 10 minutes for routine service, and it has never failed to make bales whether the grass is very short or long. The only condition is that the crop must be dry. I haven’t had to repair anything. I really like the simplicity of design and quiet operation.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 1995 Ford F-250 4-WD pickup equipped with a turbocharged engine. “I’ve had to replace three fan belts, a belt tension pulley, and a water pump, and I’ve had problems with the clutch. I traded it in for a new 1997 model.”

New Idea disc mower

1 Best Buy1 Worst Buy
Best Buy
James McGowan, Russell Springs, Ky. · Vol. 31, No. 3 (2007), p. 13

James likes his 1991 New Idea disc mower. “I’ve always kept up a regular maintenance schedule. Recently we used it during the fall to cut hay that was down and very thick, and with all the hours on this mower I thought it would fail to cut. But it did a great job.”

Worst Buy
Bennie Eugene Street, Lynnville, Tenn. · Vol. 22, No. 2 (1998), p. 16

Bennie nominates his 1994 Kubota 5030 4-WD tractor equipped with a front-end loader as his “best buy”. “I use it just about every day. It’s the handiest piece of equipment I have. It works good on hills. I use the loader to do everything from stacking hay to hauling, digging, and loading dirt and rocks, etc.

“My worst buy is my New Idea disc mower. One or more of the shafts that drive the line of discs ‘rounds off’ about every 20 to 30 acres. I told the dealer and the company rep about this problem but got no help at all. One mechanic said something was out of line, but no one will do anything about it so I have to tear it down and replace one or more of the shafts myself. I plan to get rid of this mower as soon as I can. I’d never buy another one like it.”

New Idea (general)

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
David Allmendinger, Shippenville, Penn. · Vol. 21, No. 1 (1997), p. 16

New Idea “My 1996 272 ‘Cutditioner’ is my best buy. Last year I used it to cut 80 acres with no problems. I’m well pleased with it.”

New Idea 3222

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Nelson Howell, Jerseyville, Ontario · Vol. 21, No. 4 (1997), p. 16

“My Case-IH 7210 Magnum tractor starts well in cold weather, and the remote control for the 3-pt. hitch makes it easy to hook up implements. My only complaint is that the quadrant for third and fourth reverse gears is not in a straight line from the quadrant for the first and second reverse gears, which makes it awkward to use.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his New Idea 3222 side slinger manure spreader. “It does a reasonably good job of spreading all types of manure. However, the beaters have to be cleaned out thoroughly in freezing weather to prevent problems. My main complaint, however, is that the walking beam tandem axles aren’t built nearly heavy enough. I had to have a machine shop reinforce them. I looked at a similar spreader and the owner had the same problem. A company representative agreed with me that the axles should be built heavier.”

New Idea 484 round baler

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Marcian Tarnowski, Bruno, Sask. · Vol. 21, No. 4 (1997), p. 15

“My best buy is my 1990 New Idea 484 round baler. It makes 4 by 5-ft. soft core bales and has an electric tie system. I’ve used it to make hundreds of bales every year without ever having to stop. The only repair has been replacement of a few bolts that came loose on a bearing holder. The dealer provided them free of charge. I also had to replace a roller bearing which turned out to be a very easy job and cost only a few dollars.”

New Idea 485 4

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
George C. Wissinger, Huntington, Ind. · Vol. 28, No. 3 (2004), p. 14

“My 1997 New Holland 4835 4-WD tractor equipped with a left hand reverser and an ALO 720 front-end loader is my best buy. I use it to pull a New Idea 485 4 by 6 hydraulic-tie round baler, which is also a best buy. I can’t say enough good things about these two machines.”

New Idea 4865 round baler

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
William Clark, Isabella, Manitoba · Vol. 27, No. 4 (2003), p. 12

“I’m happy with my 1992 Deere 9600 combine which I use on our 2,300 acres. This machine has a lot of capacity and is well built. Very little downtime. It’s a pleasure to operate.

“I was disappointed with my 1996 New Idea 4865 round baler. The company used splined bearings on all the rollers, which caused nothing but trouble and usually ruined the rollers as well. I finally traded the baler in for a New Holland 688.”

New Idea 5112 disc mower

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
John Lau, Soda Springs, Idaho · Vol. 21, No. 1 (1997), p. 14

“Our New Idea 5112 disc mower is our best buy ever. It’s had very few breakdowns and can mow almost any kind of crop including meadow hay, barley, CRP cover crops, etc. It makes great hay.”

New Idea 5200 disc mower conditioner

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
James L. Evans, Hammond, N.Y. · Vol. 25, No. 2 (2001), p. 15

“My 2000 New Idea 5200 9-ft. 3-in. disc mower conditioner is my best buy. It’ll mow through any kind of grass whether it’s wet or dry, and at a fast speed - maybe faster than I should be driving the tractor. All I have to do is hook up, grease it, and go.”

“My 1999 Hesston 9-ft. 3-in. windrower is my worst buy. Every time I use it I seemed to have down time. The main problem is that the mower sections keep breaking and they’re hard to change even though they are the bolt-on type. I adjusted everything as recommended in the owner’s manual.”

New Idea 5212 disc mower-conditioner

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Kenneth J. Hunter, Hayti, S. Dak. · Vol. 21, No. 2 (1997), p. 14

“After four years of use in rocky soil it has held up exceptionally well,” says Kenneth about his New Idea 5212 disc mower-conditioner. On the “worst buy” side, “My Deere 7800 MFWD tractor equipped with a powershift transmission is the most disgusting piece of equipment I’ve bought in 40 years of farming. Whoever dubbed the transmission as the ‘Jerk-o-matic’ was 100 percent right.”

New Idea 5408 disc mower

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Michael Leary, Wallkill, N.Y. · Vol. 22, No. 6 (1998), p. 16

Michael nominates his 1998 New Idea 5408 disc mower as his “best buy”. “It’s well built and has blades that can be replaced quickly. No problems and no downtime.

“My 1997 New Idea 4844 round baler is a best buy. It takes less than 10 minutes for routine service, and it has never failed to make bales whether the grass is very short or long. The only condition is that the crop must be dry. I haven’t had to repair anything. I really like the simplicity of design and quiet operation.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his 1995 Ford F-250 4-WD pickup equipped with a turbocharged engine. “I’ve had to replace three fan belts, a belt tension pulley, and a water pump, and I’ve had problems with the clutch. I traded it in for a new 1997 model.”

New Idea 5410 disc mower

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Herman Thomason, Collinsville, Okla. · Vol. 26, No. 1 (2002), p. 16

Herman’s impressed with his New Idea 5410 disc mower. “It’ll cut right through grass so rank and thick that I can hardly tell where to drive, even when the grass is damp from dew. It has no trouble cutting through Bermudagrass. I haven’t had any problems with it.”

New Idea 9600 6-row no-till corn planter

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
George R. Thomas, Radnor, Ohio · Vol. 20, No. 5 (1996), p. 16

“Our best buy is a 1994 New Idea 9600 6-row no-till corn planter equipped with a 5-row soybean splitter. It’s a heavy, well-built planter. It spaces seed more accurately than any other planter I’ve ever owned. “Our Salzsieder 300-bu. “no stick”

New Idea Side Kick 3222 manure spreader although

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Nelson Howell, Jerseyville, Ontario · Vol. 21, No. 3 (1997), p. 15

I’m generally pleased with my 1994 New Idea Side Kick 3222 manure spreader although I have to keep the beaters free of manure in freezing weather. My biggest complaint is that the tandem axle is built far too light and can’t withstand heavy loads. Last winter the axle broke completely away from the walking beam. Also, there’s almost no clearance between the tires and walking beam axle so in wet conditions the tires just ball up with mud. I told company representatives about the problem but they didn’t seem interested.”

Read every report in full

FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.

Subscribe to FARM SHOW