Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022)

57 reports from pages 12–15 · 51 Best Buys9 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Worst Buy

C.H.I. Overhead Doors

Clifford Litwiller, Delavan, Ill. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 12

“One of the best investments my wife and I made was a heated workshop we built here on our farm. It has given the children somewhere to learn to work on everything from their bicycles to tractors. It’s a great place for winter projects.

“Our worst buy came from C.H.I. Overhead Doors out of Arthur, Ill. We had five overhead doors installed in our Butler building in 2013. Air leaks around the sides and top of all of them. They bow out so badly in winter that sparrows can get between the door header and the door. The C.H.I. salesperson said our door headers are underbuilt and are bowed out, but when a Butler building representative checked them, they were perfectly straight. C.H.I. hasn’t been helpful at all and informed us that’s just the nature of the doors, while also stating that this was their top-of-the-line door. I chose this company based on my neighbor’s C.H.I. overhead door that was installed about 10 years before this. But when I compare them now, the quality difference is obvious.”

Best Buy

Work Sharp Knife Tool Sharpener #WSKTS2 mk.2

Marvin R. Hershberger, Farwell, Mich. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 12

“I bought the Work Sharp Knife & Tool Sharpener MK.2 (Model #WSKTS2) to sharpen my butcher, fish filet and pocket knives (www.worksharptools.com). It has easily exceeded my expectations. You can get a razor edge on almost any knife with very little practice with its easy-to-use repeatable and adjustable guide system.”

Worst Buy

Classic Industries

John Rochester, Deerfield Beach, Fla. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 12

“I just bought a radiator for my 1984 Dodge B150 van from Classic Industries. It’s a poor fit and weakly made. It’s so fragile with thin plastic that when you touch it the fins bend. The customer service response was basically ‘too bad-closing your ticket’.”

Best Buy

Kubota L4060HSTC + 1 more

Ron Bramer, West Lafayette, Ind. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 12

“My Kubota L4060HSTC with LA805 loader always starts regardless of the weather. It’s a very handy small tractor with the 4-WD making it seem like a bigger tractor. It may be a little too light to use the loader for much weight unless it has the Bush hog mower on it for counterweight. The cab is definitely worth the extra money.

“I had a Heil AC unit installed in the early 1990’s. It was an R22 unit. In 2015, it had a leak in the ‘A’ coil and the vendor recommended replacing the AC unit with a newer unit that used R-401A refrigerant. Supposedly it was an equal 3-ton replacement unit. I haven’t been able to cool the house down in the summer and the vendor tells me it’s working as it should and by replacing the old 3-ton with the new 3-ton there should be no change. But there is. I’ll be installing a new unit this summer.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Pneu-Dart dart rifle + 1 more

Larry Tripp, Blackwell, Okla. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 12

“In 45 years of farming, the Pneu-Dart dart rifle is the only thing that has more than paid for itself the first time I used it (www.pneudart.com; ph 866-299-3278).

“Our Forest River Rockwood Travel Trailer is a great trailer, but it has a large glass window in the front which has broken twice in about three trips due to gravel coming over the top of the truck. It needs some kind of cover. It’s very expensive to replace.”

Best Buy

Toyota Prius sedans

Llewellyn Storlie, Spring Grove, Minn. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 12

“My purchase of two matching Toyota Prius sedans in 2002 has been my best buy. My wife and I have enjoyed these vehicles for 20 years and they both still drive well. Both large batteries are still working great and the only replacement parts that have been needed were tires and brakes. One has 140,000 miles and the other only 49,800. They each have constantly given us 42 to 45 miles per gallon. They’ve been very much appreciated vehicles.”

Best Buy

LS Tractor

Dean Bovee, Ashtabula, Ohio · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 12

“My 2021 MT122 LS Tractor came with a front-end loader and backhoe (www.lstractorusa.com). It has plenty of power and the hydraulics are good. It’s a nice tractor.”

Best Buy

Central Boiler Classic CL 6048 + 2 more

Donald Ouillette, Dayville, Conn. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 12

“My Central Boiler Classic CL 6048 is a best buy. I use this boiler to heat two houses. We keep our homes at 70 degrees all winter long and it heats our hot water as well. We use dry seasoned wood including whole stumps and pine in the fall and spring. We’ve had it for 13 years and it’s still going strong thanks to proper maintenance and care.

“I have two Deere tractors, a 2000 40-hp. 990 and 2004 30-hp. 790. Both are easy starting, fuel sipping, and good running Yanmar diesels with gear shift transmissions. These simple tractors plow snow, haul wood, snow blow, move dirt, mow, till the garden, chip wood, leaf blow, and grade my 1/2-mile dirt road. I also use a subframe BH80X Woods backhoe with a mechanical thumb to move and hold logs as well as stumping, rock removal, and trenching.”

Best Buy

Belleville boots

Dennis Strahle, Eagle, Mich. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 12

“My Belleville boots (www.bellevilleboot.com; 800-376-6978) have been my best buy in recent years. They’re extremely comfortable right out of the box. I wear them whenever I’m outside. I have big, wide feet (12EEEE) and Belleville has no issue fitting me. I like that they come with extra-long, super durable shoelaces and closed loops all the way to the top. I used to think that hooks were so handy but no more. The hooks get banged closed or pulled open so that I’m always adjusting the hook gap. The closed loops are smooth and fast because, with the extra-long laces, I tie a small knot on the very end of the laces so that they do not pull through the top loop when I remove my boots. When I put my boots back on, I just pull the smooth-sliding laces tight and tie them, no lacing. I had an issue with one once and customer service was top-notch. And, best of all, they are made in the USA. When I first install new shoelaces, I find the middle of the shoelace length, tie a small knot and then put the knot between the bottom two eyelets. My laces are forever the same length.”

Best Buy

SealLube

Robert A. Knickel, Camden, S.C. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 13

“After reading about SealLube for years, I finally tried it. It’s one of the best products I’ve ever used. It fixed a seal in a 40-year-old jack, a power steering seal on a tractor, and the lift cylinder on my loader. I would tell anyone that has a leaking seal to try it.”

Best Buy

John Deere GT245 + 1 more

Kevin Sheehy, Algoma, Wis. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 13

“My 2004 Deere GT245 is my best buy. I’ve been cutting grass with the 48-in. deck and blowing snow with the 42-in. snowblower for 18 years and haven’t had one serious issue. I’ve only done regular maintenance.

“I haven’t had the same experience with my Yard-Man 2-cycle weedeater. It’s impossible to start. After one summer, I tossed it in the dumpster.”

Best Buy

Grasshopper 623T lawn mower + 1 more

Gene Bontrager, Kalona, Iowa · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 13

“My best buy is my Grasshopper 623T lawn mower. Between my three sons and myself, we put around 150 hrs. per year on it. It’s low maintenance and I’ve had excellent dealer service. The deck lift actuator went out and was promptly replaced by the dealer under warranty.

“I haven’t been pleased with Goodyear automotive tires. I purchased a new car with a 60,000-mile warranty on tires. At around 15,000 miles all four tires were almost bald so I contacted the local dealer. He communicated with Goodyear who told him they would not warrant replacement or adjustment on tires. No more Goodyear tires on anything I own.”

Best Buy

JCB 270T telehandler + 1 more

Glenn Allen, Mt. Vernon, Ohio · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 13

“My 2020 JCB 270T telehandler is a best buy. With the one-arm boom, you can raise something up to work on and get out of the cab. Dealer support has been good. One thing I would have them change is the cab height – it could be 2 to 3-in. lower.

“Deere’s tech policy is a real problem as is their one dealer per region. There’s no competition. How much market share do they have to lose before they change? I put an ACU on my tractor and they had to program it. It was bad and they put four on before they got one that worked. I got charged for programming them because I had put the first one on myself. They also put numerous other parts on that weren’t needed because they could. Guess who paid for them? My next tractor won’t be a Deere.”

Worst Buy

Kia Sorento

Dennis Hegg, Mitchell, S.D. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 13

“My worst buy was a 2015 Kia Sorento. It took Kia 2 mos. to fix the tailgate so it would open. I had to replace about a dozen headlamps at about $50 each because they kept burning out. I didn’t like driving it at night because the high beams just weren’t high enough. We complained but the dealer quit answering the phone. The door to the gas cap didn’t work most of the time. I traded that junker off.”

Best Buy

PJ Trailers

Gary Swensen, Yankton, S.D. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 13

“I finally found a great spare tire carrier for trailers from PJ Trailers (www.pjtrailers.com; ph 903-785-6879). It was about $50 and fits into a stake pocket and holds the spare tire off to the side of the trailer so it doesn’t take up cargo space.”

Best Buy

Predator generators

Allan Von Werder, Morgan City, La. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 13

Allan bought two Predator generators in 2021 from Harbor Freight – one a 3500-watt and the other 9500-watt. “These generators are whisper-quiet and run for half a day or more on a tank of gas. They’ve got electric start and are easy to maintain.”

Best Buy

Yamaha XT250 motorcycle

Ed Doucette, Fort Ripley, Minn. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 13

“My 2008 Yamaha XT250 motorcycle has never given me an ounce of grief. I bought it with 500 miles on it in 2008 from a friend who was hot to buy a Gold Wing. I now have almost 8,000 miles and get from 65 to 80 mpg. It’ll go 65 to 80 mph but likes 50 to 55 mph better.”

Best Buy

About 10 years ago my car was rear-ended and ever since I can’t have a

Gary Sampson, Freedom, N.Y. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 13

“About 10 years ago my car was rear-ended and ever since I can’t have anything tight around my waist while sitting. It was embarrassing turnaround. to always have to loosen my belt before sitting down, especially when we were in a restaurant. Then I came across an ad for a ratchet belt. Instead of a pin that you have to get into the right hole, it has a ratchet-style buckle in 1/4-in. increments so you can get it set exactly where you need it. When you sit down, you just push on a release knob and let the belt go enough so you’re completely comfortable. Very easy to use. The one I bought fits waists from 28 to 56 in. by simply cutting off what you don’t need. It’s not available any more but there are many different brands out there – just do a Google search for ‘ratchet belts’.”

Worst Buy

Willmar 800 fertilizer spreader

Grant Blenz, Springport, Mich. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 14

“One of my worst buys is a Willmar 800 fertilizer spreader. I bought it 3 years ago. It had paint coming off the first year. The dealer said I should get it sand-blasted and repainted at my own expense. I don’t have any alternative as Willmar is now out of business.”

Best Buy

Vermeer 8040 rotary mower

Martin Heller, Berthold, N.D. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 14

“My Vermeer 8040 rotary mower is well-built and performs well. But it’s a real pain in the rear to hook up or unhook from the tractor. For some unknown reason, instead of the 3-pt. hitch attaching in a normal way, the sick, twisted engineer who designed it decided it should be slid in from one side. This means that instead of spreading the 3-pt. arms and backing up to the machine, I have to back up to the machine a bit off center and then use my skid steer to move the mower over to fit onto the pins as they both have to attach from the same direction. I believe the engineer was dropped on his head as a child since this procedure is almost impossible to perform alone. It sometimes literally takes hours to attach/detach from the tractor when working alone. Once attached, the machine performs flawlessly.”

Best Buy

Echo chainsaw

Gary Swensen, Yankton, S.D. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 14

“I’ve cut wood and old railroad ties for about 20 years with my 650EVL Echo chainsaw. During that time, I’ve worn out two cutting bars, one drive chain engine sprocket, and lots of chain. One trick I use is that when the saw gets hot – even though I set the auto chain oiler to the max – I stick the saw into a bucket of waste engine oil so it can cool off while I take a break.

“I’ve never done anything to the saw other than a few sparkplugs and replacing the worn parts. I used to work maintenance on an oil pipeline and one of the chemists told me to always use premium gas in small engines. It gives extra power and will store for up to 3 years as compared to regular gas, which starts turning into turpentine after a year. This saw still starts on the second or third pull today, just as it always did.”

Worst Buy

Jari sickle mower

John Franklin, Sidney, Mont. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 14

“My worst buy is a walk-behind Jari sickle mower. The three most important considerations when buying a piece of equipment are service, service, and service. Unfortunately, after buying this sickle mower in 2015, the Jari mower facility in Mankato, Minn., closed. The machine worked well when new – and I previously used a 1992 Jari mower for years – but now I need two new rubber, horizontal grooved tires. Does anyone know where to buy Jari parts?”

Best Buy

Kawasaki Mule side-by-side

Richard Ladner, Seale, Ala. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 14

“I bought a new Kawasaki Mule side-by-side in 2019. This little Mule has been outstanding as I’ve hauled dirt, cinder blocks, railroad ties, T-posts and thousands of feet of wire through woods, up and down hills, and across wet bottoms. It takes all I throw at it and just keeps chugging along.

“I can’t say I’ve had the same experience with any type of mole or vole repellent whether it’s thumpers, electronic buzzers or traps. It’s like opening a disco for them – they seem to come from far and wide.”

Best Buy

Yanmar 2310D

Buzz Heuchan, Crystal River, Fla. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 14

“Our Yanmar 2310D is a great compact tractor with a loader. We use it regularly on our farm to mow pasture, maintain a gravel roadway, lift heavy stuff, bore holes for posts, etc. We’ve only performed routine maintenance and have had no issues with it.”

Best Buy

Honda self-propelled lawnmower

Doug Schafer, Mobridge, S.D. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 14

“This is my 10th season using my Honda self-propelled lawnmower. With fresh gas, it starts on the first pull. I’m 74 and it starts very easily for me. The self-propel is variable, so I can adjust it to my pace. Overall, it’s a fantastic mower. My one complaint is that the whole machine has to be tilted to change the oil.”

Best Buy

John Deere D125 twin hydro mower

David Doherty, Lebanon, Ore. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 14

“My 2017 Deere D125 twin hydro mower is an impressive machine. I’ve treated this mower as rough as others I’ve owned but only burned off one belt and that was my fault. I haven’t bent a blade even when hitting rocks and tree limbs. On other mowers I’ve owned, I’ve bent blades, burned belts and broken towers. This one has over 500 hrs. and still no problems.”

Best Buy

Honda Civic DX

Bill McKeeman, Calgary, Alberta · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 14

“I bought a used 2004 Honda Civic DX in 2009. I’ve only replaced a timing belt, one ball joint, and disc brake pads. The car has had regular maintenance and is going to turn 300,000 km (186,411 miles) soon. It still uses no oil between oil changes and gets 50 plus on the highway and a bit better than 40 in town. It still has the battery I installed in 2009 but I have a new one for this winter.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford F350 4x4 SuperCab xlt 6.7 + 1 more

Alex G. Somerville, Lincoln, Mich. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 14

“I’ve owned several trucks over the years. My 2018 Ford F350 4x4 SuperCab XLT 6.7 Power Stroke has been the most impressive. The towing capacity, fuel mileage, and ease of maintenance have all been ahead of any truck I’ve owned in the past. The steel in the frame is thicker and has a higher tensile strength than a GM or Dodge.

“My worst truck ever was a 2006 GMC 3500 6.6 Duramax. The frame and front end were built for paved highways. The Allison transmission was just a label. It was a real money pit.”

Best Buy

Drill Doctor

Don McLaskey, Anacortes, Wash. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 14

“Years ago I bought a Drill Doctor because it’s so difficult to properly sharpen drill bits. I purchased it even though it seemed expensive. It’s an amazing tool and worth far more than I paid. I do a lot of metal fabricating and whenever one of my drills has a hard time cutting, a few seconds on the Drill Doctor makes it cut like a dream (www.drilldoctor.com).”

Best Buy

Blue Devil Hydraulic Stop Leak

Bradley Bruhn, Palermo, N.D. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 15

“Someone in FARM SHOW recommended Blue Devil Hydraulic Stop Leak (www.gobdp.com; ph 888-863-0426). I ordered some just to see if it worked. I was a firm believer that they don’t make ‘fix-it in a can’. I was proven wrong. The power steering on my van was leaking so I added some Blue Devil, and it hasn’t leaked since. The hydraulic cylinder was leaking on the Bobcat, so I added Blue Devil, and it hasn’t leaked to this day. Thanks to the gentleman who recommended it and also to FARM SHOW for the great information.”

Best Buy

Ford F-150 FX4

Linda Nooner, McAlester, Okla. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 15

“My 2019 Ford F-150 FX4 is a great all-around truck. It pulls anything and is easy on fuel.

“I like buying American-made but it’s sure hard to find anything made here. Saw blades, nuts and bolts, wire fencing, screws, and even nails are all foreign-made. Tools, electrical equipment, welding rods, and household appliances are all junk unless made in the good old USA.”

Best Buy

John Deere 6200 tractors + 1 more

Jim Dilday, Rockwood, Ill. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 15

“We bought two Deere 6200 tractors (one with a cab and one without) and they are the best investments we’ve ever made. They are reliable workhorses and if they were still available, we’d buy two new ones tomorrow, even if we had to borrow every penny to do it.

“We haven’t been happy with our 2015 Deere 6105M tractor. It’s a shame that Deere made a tractor with such a good engine and transmission yet is still a total lemon due to electrical and radiator design issues. There is a different warning flashing on the dash of this tractor every time we get in it and only one ever turned out to be legitimate. The owner’s manual doesn’t even list a majority of the codes so we can’t even check on what it’s reporting.”

Best Buy

Cub Cadet walk-behind string trimmer

James Tilson, Peoria, Ill. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 15

“I bought a Cub Cadet walk-behind string trimmer about 3 years ago. I used this trimmer to knock down overgrowth on about 1 acre. I also use it to trim around the pond and clean up fence lines on about five acres. It’s great to use on steep hills. It takes one or two pulls to start.”

Best Buy

Generac dual-fuel 7500-watt generator + 1 more

Del Griffith, Rockwall, Texas · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 15

“We suffer from chronic power outages. Our Generac dual-fuel 7500-watt generator has been a lifesaver. I bought the dual-fuel because it was in stock at the time. We had an outage that necessitated using all the gas we had but luckily, I had two 20-lb. propane bottles on hand that got us through. This generator starts every time on the first attempt and is efficient. Ten gals. of gas and 20 lbs. of propane got us through 2 1/2 days.

“I used my Scag Liberty 52 zero-turn mower for 2 hrs. and sold it. It was a $5,500 mower that wouldn’t cut grass. Any grass areas higher than 4-in. and the mower would just struggle to cut it, causing the mower to stall out every time. My Deere X320 was down because I needed a part. When I put the X320 back in service it mowed the same areas with ease. Scag offers a lot of hype, but they don’t live up to it when it comes to consumer products.”

Best Buy

John Deere 2038R compact utility tractor

Howard Uiterdyk, Belding, Mich. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 15

“My best buy is a Deere 2038R compact utility tractor I purchased new in late 2017. It has plenty of power and is large enough to be able to safely do many different tasks yet is small enough to be very maneuverable with the auto-connect mower, loader or 3-pt. attachments. It’s fun and comfortable to operate and has many neat features. I highly recommend this tractor.”

Best Buy

Nissan LEAF electric cars

Dave Arko, Fort Collins, Colo. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 15

“Our two Nissan LEAF electric cars are wonderful, especially with the high gas prices. Our 2015 has enough range (70 miles) for daily trips to work. Our 2022 model has a 220-mile range and a lot of power. They are maintenance-free other than tires. We’ve had no problems with either car.”

Best Buy

GMC Sierra X31 4x4 pickup truck + 1 more

Kevin V. Cox, Tioga, La. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 15

“Since June 2021, I’ve been driving a 2021 GMC Sierra X31 4x4 pickup truck with the Duramax diesel engine. It’s a 3.0 liter, straight 6-cylinder engine. I have 50,000 miles on it and have had zero issues with it. It has plenty of power and pep. Plus, I regularly get over 30 mpg on it. With a good tailwind and driving at 55 mph, I averaged 54.9 mpg over a 25-mile period. That’s my best mileage to date. I recommend it to anyone.

“I recently bought a walk-behind, rear-wheel drive Craftsman 21-in. lawn mower. I average close to 5 hrs. a week pushing a lawn mower. My previous mowers were very similar to the one I recently bought, but they were front-wheel drive. I like the rear-wheel drive version much better.”

Worst Buy

Braxton Creek camper

Jim Holt, Cincinnati, Ohio · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 15

“My worst buy was a brand-new Braxton Creek camper. We got it in September 2021, towed it home and parked it next to my basement garage. Less than a month later, I discovered the roof leaking into the living space. I towed it back to the dealer and left it there for a couple of months while they ‘fixed’ it. I got it back and checked for leaks during the first heavy rain or two and it was dry inside. I let it sit there until May 2022 when I found yellow puddle stains on the floor and walls. I towed it back to the dealer and they insisted I leave it with them for more work. It’s been months since I dropped it off. Soon the camper will be a full year old, and we are yet to have an opportunity to use it and the dealer won’t buy it back. I think we deserve a new camper, or our money refunded.”

Best Buy

Kubota BX23 compact tractor

Richard “Olly” Larson, Fayetteville, Ga. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 15

“I bought a Kubota BX23 compact tractor with quick-attach loader and backhoe. It’s the ‘Swiss Army Knife’ of tractors. I’m always amazed at what I can do with it, and it only burns about a gal./hour. It’s been very dependable and only been in the shop for basic maintenance.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere mower-conditioner + 1 more

Paul Holbert, Dandridge, Tenn. · Vol. 46, No. 5 (2022), p. 15

“My 2020 Deere mower-conditioner was a good purchase. I bought it new, and it had a cracked gearbox when it was delivered. Deere put a new one on with no questions asked. The mower performs really well.

“My worst buy has to be a Claas Lexion 760 combine. These machines are generally great, but the dealer misrepresented the machine and then wouldn’t make it right. The machine was sold as being field-ready. When it was delivered, it had oil running out of it and loose parts that had fallen into the machine. The computer was throwing many error codes.”