Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Brands › AGCO

AGCO: what farmers say

18 reports in FARM SHOW · 6 Best Buys12 Worst Buys

AGCO (general)

0 Best Buys2 Worst Buys
Worst Buy
Jeffrey M. Heiser, Vesper, Wis. · Vol. 32, No. 2 (2008), p. 14

“My 2006 Maurer 34-ft. hopper bottom grain trailer pulls easy and is my best buy. It has sight windows on the side of the trailer so I can always see how much grain is left inside.

“My Classic outdoor wood burning furnace is easy to hook up and is a best buy. Burning wood sure beats buying LP gas.

“I’m disappointed with the parts distribution provided by AGCO. I ordered parts for my Massey Ferguson tractor from AGCO. They repeatedly had to be sent back or else they didn’t come at all. Our dealer tried to help. There’s no excuse for this mess.”

Worst Buy
Walnut Dale Farms, Boswell, Penn. · Vol. 21, No. 3 (1997), p. 14

“We traded a New Holland 1890 self-propelled forage harvester and a Deere 3960 forage harvester in for a 1996 Gehl 1065 pull-type harvester. Both of the old machines did a good job, but we had some expensive experiences with foreign metal objects and wanted a machine equipped with a metal detector. “We use a Deere 4630 tractor to pull the harvester and it performs quite well. We’re glad that we have the metal detector. Last year while we were harvesting silage the metal detector went off 33 different times on 26 rows of corn that bordered a fence around our property. It turned out that a month before we went into the field our neighbor had a young fellow replace the electric fence wire. He threw lengths of old wire helter-skelter into our standing corn. Without the metal detector we’d never have known about the wire.” On the negative side, he lists parts-ordering through the AGCO company. “My dealer tries his best to provide good service, but ordering parts through the AGCO system can be a real nightmare. I once ordered an oil seal for a manure spreader but instead received a shear bar designed for a loader bucket. It turned out that both items had the same part number. Recently I needed to rebuild an axle assembly for my White field cultivator. After three deliveries of parts that didn’t fit, I disassembled another axle and found the matching parts at a Deere dealership.”

Worst Buy
Adam Bowen, West Alexandria, Ohio · Vol. 25, No. 6 (2001), p. 17

“I like my AGCO White 6045 front wheel assist tractor equipped with a front-end loader. It has performed incredibly well, and it starts right up no matter how cold the weather is. I used the tractor to take out fence rows, to pull our 15-ft. Bush Hog, and to move snow. This little tractor is a ‘10’ in my book.

“My AGCO White 6810 front wheel assist tractor is my worst buy. It has a lot of power and is comfortable to drive. However, the interior cracked and broke. Mud packed up in around the fuel tank and broke the brackets. And to top it all off, the rear end went out at about 600 hours. The dealer wouldn’t stand behind the product and told me the warranty had expired seven days before I brought the tractor in, and that it wasn’t his problem. Another dealer finally fixed the tractor.”

Best Buy
Adam Bowen, West Alexandria, Ohio · Vol. 25, No. 5 (2001), p. 14

“I like my AGCO White 6045 front wheel assist tractor equipped with a front-end loader. This little tractor performs incredibly well with a loader and it starts right up no matter how cold the weather. I use the tractor to pull our 15-ft. Bush Hog and to move snow. I give it a ‘10’ in my book.

“My AGCO White 6810 front wheel assist tractor has a lot of power and is comfortable to drive. However, mud packed up in around the fuel tank and broke the brackets. And to top it all off, the rear end went out at about 600 hours. The dealer wouldn’t stand behind this product and told me the warranty had expired seven days before I brought the tractor in, and so it wasn’t his problem. AGCO finally fixed the tractor at another dealer.”

AGCO White 6810 front wheel assist

0 Best Buys2 Worst Buys
Worst Buy
Adam Bowen, West Alexandria, Ohio · Vol. 25, No. 6 (2001), p. 17

“I like my AGCO White 6045 front wheel assist tractor equipped with a front-end loader. It has performed incredibly well, and it starts right up no matter how cold the weather is. I used the tractor to take out fence rows, to pull our 15-ft. Bush Hog, and to move snow. This little tractor is a ‘10’ in my book.

“My AGCO White 6810 front wheel assist tractor is my worst buy. It has a lot of power and is comfortable to drive. However, the interior cracked and broke. Mud packed up in around the fuel tank and broke the brackets. And to top it all off, the rear end went out at about 600 hours. The dealer wouldn’t stand behind the product and told me the warranty had expired seven days before I brought the tractor in, and that it wasn’t his problem. Another dealer finally fixed the tractor.”

Worst Buy
Adam Bowen, West Alexandria, Ohio · Vol. 25, No. 5 (2001), p. 14

“I like my AGCO White 6045 front wheel assist tractor equipped with a front-end loader. This little tractor performs incredibly well with a loader and it starts right up no matter how cold the weather. I use the tractor to pull our 15-ft. Bush Hog and to move snow. I give it a ‘10’ in my book.

“My AGCO White 6810 front wheel assist tractor has a lot of power and is comfortable to drive. However, mud packed up in around the fuel tank and broke the brackets. And to top it all off, the rear end went out at about 600 hours. The dealer wouldn’t stand behind this product and told me the warranty had expired seven days before I brought the tractor in, and so it wasn’t his problem. AGCO finally fixed the tractor at another dealer.”

AGCO lawn tractor

0 Best Buys2 Worst Buys
Worst Buy
Robert and Bernardine Specht, Monmouth, Iowa · Vol. 33, No. 1 (2009), p. 15

“The 1990 Yamaha 80 cc ATV I bought used in 1997 is my best buy. It runs well and has required only one muffler repair. I use it mainly for yard work with a trailer.

“My 2000 AGCO lawn tractor is my worst buy. When it was four years old the engine had to be replaced. Recently, the transmission failed. Wire got wound up tightly around the driveshaft. Any repairs are very expensive. One redeeming feature is the deck is easy to remove for cleaning.”

Worst Buy
Charles and Roy Grona, Amarillo, Texas · Vol. 23, No. 6 (1999), p. 14

“Our worst buys are two 1999 AGCO tractors – an 8765 model and a 9745. The 8765 has been in the shop five times for transmission problems. The transmission oil overheated and melted the plugs out of it. The plugs were made of plastic and there’s no transmission temperature warning light. The dashboard ‘sweats’ so that moisture gets into the tachometer and ground speed indicator. The dashboard was replaced but two hours later the same thing happened again. The factory says there’s no way to solve the problem. The transmission seals leak so bad we have to add of transmission oil every day.

“The 9745 model has been in the shop so many times that we’ve stopped counting. None of the gauges work, and everything is made out of plastic which breaks easily. The tractor is rated at 145 horsepower, but it doesn’t have enough power to pull an 18-ft. plow without overheating. The radiator is too small and isn’t accessible for cleaning. The pto went out and the pto engagement, which is made of plastic, wore out after 250 hours. They managed to put a sun roof on this tractor, but they didn’t think to put a cup holder inside the cab.

“We’ve owned several Deutz and Allis-Chalmers tractors equipped with air-cooled engines and they were all best buys. However, the new AGCO tractors are equipped with water-cooled engines and just aren’t as good. In our opinion, both of these tractors should be sent back to the factory as examples of how not to build tractors.”

AGCO 4227 4-basket tedder

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Nate Girbach, Milan, Mich. · Vol. 44, No. 2 (2020), p. 12

“I use my 2012 Manitou MTL 735-120 telescopic handler to move hay and straw bundles as well as round bales and seed boxes, and to trim trees. The heated cab makes it enjoyable to feed cows during winter.

“My AGCO 4227 4-basket tedder was built light and didn’t hold up to use, which resulted in broken spindles and tines. Also, the U-joints on it came apart while the tedder was folded up for transport.”

AGCO 5650 Allis Chalmers tractor equipped

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Gary G. Schave, Port Hope, Mich. · Vol. 24, No. 5 (2000), p. 17

Gary nominates his AGCO 5650 Allis Chalmers tractor equipped with a Quicke 310 frontend loader as his “best buy”. It has been trouble-free and is a pleasure to drive and operate. It’s a much better tractor than the Deere 2240 it replaced.”

On the “worst buy” side, he lists his Belarus 925 tractor. “We bought it used in 1998 with only 243 hours on it. It has had a lot of minor breakdowns. It isn’t a very dependable tractor.”

AGCO 600

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Idris Hughes, Sylvan Grove, Kan. · Vol. 21, No. 3 (1997), p. 14

Idris owns a 1997 Gleaner R62 combine. “It does a good job of cleaning and separating and works well in tough threshing conditions - better than conventional combines I’ve operated. I use it to harvest winter and spring wheat, soybeans, corn, milo, sunflowers, canola, and sometimes barley and rye. It has a lot of capacity and the company provides good support. The 1996 models were underpowered but hopefully that problem has been resolved on the 1997 models. I had problems with the hydrostatic transmission but they’ve been resolved. “I wish Gleaner would quit relying on other sources for many of their parts and manufacture their own. The combine handles a 30-ft. straight header and 8-row corn header perfectly. However, I’m not satisfied with the AGCO 600 series draper header. It isn’t built heavy enough and wasn’t tested extensively enough before it went on the market.”

AGCO 8610 2-WD tractor

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Rocky Stehle, Theodosta, Mo. · Vol. 28, No. 3 (2004), p. 12

Two white silos from Star Silos (St. Geneive Ill.) rate as Rocky’s “best buys.” One silo was put up in 1977 and the other in 1990. “These silos have never needed resurfacing, although they were used every day until 2001 when we sold our milk cows. Now we use them to feed corn silage to our feeder cattle from November through April.”

A 1996 AGCO 8610 2-WD tractor rates as his “worst buy.” “I traded in an Allis Chalmers 7000 and a Deutz 6206 for this tractor and paid plenty to boot. Everything on it went wrong. All the hydraulics went out as well as the oil pump and most of the gauges. I also had problems with the fuel pump, governor, and a sensor on the flywheel. A wheel bearing went out one day while I was cutting corn silage. I had to take the tractor back to the dealer seven times, and he’s located 120 miles away. The company did pay for some of the repairs, but I had to pay for others. This winter the starter went out and had to be rebuilt. The fuel injector cracked last fall while I was cutting corn silage and fuel got in the oil. They replaced one injector, but the fuel pump cost me more than $2,300. The tractor needed other work which could’ve been done before the warranty expired, but the dealer was too busy and the warranty ran out.

“On the other hand, my 1982 Allis Chalmers 6080 tractor, which I bought used, is still going strong.”

Agco 9650 tractor equipped

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Irwin McCullough, Sharpsville, Pa. · Vol. 24, No. 4 (2000), p. 16

Irwin likes his 1995 Agco 9650 tractor equipped with a Deutz air-cooled engine. “It’s easy to operate and the 18-speed powershift transmission has a good selection of speeds. It’s also easy on fuel. My only complaint is that the starter is way too small and won’t start the engine in cold weather.

“My worst buy is my Dodge 3/4-ton 4-WD pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine. It has a lot of power and an excellent ride and starts easy in winter. However, it went through three automatic transmissions in only 62,000 miles so I traded it for a Ford pickup equipped with a Power Stroke diesel engine. It’s more fuel efficient and has more power, but it rides awfully rough and I have to get out of the cab in order to lock in the front hubs. I wish I didn’t have to do that.”

Agco 9745 tractor

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Medford, Wis. · Vol. 29, No. 5 (2005), p. 13

“We nominate our Agco 9745 tractor as our worst buy. We had a set hourly lease on this tractor, but in three years it was in the dealer’s shop for warranty work three months out of the year. Finally, when it was in the shop for the entire spring planting season, we let it go back and didn’t pay the final lease payment. We tried to trade it off, but the dealer wouldn’t take it in trade since he ‘didn’t want two angry customers’.

“Now Agco Finance says they’re not part of Agco Allis (contrary to dealer comments when the initial purchase was made) and wants financial compensation. What a joke -this tractor was useless. We were forced to rent tractors to do our fieldwork because the tractor never worked. We have a stack of warranty work orders totaling about $24,000 - from computer problems to air conditioning problems. The list was endless. The way in which the company treated us left much to be desired. I can say for certain that we’ll never purchase another piece of Agco Allis equipment.”

AGCO Allis Chalmers tractor

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Keith Wyatt, Ranger, Ga. · Vol. 26, No. 6 (2002), p. 15

Keith’s impressed with his 1996 Dodge Ram 2500 4-WD pickup. “It has more than 134,000 miles on it but still runs like new. The only repair it needed was for a fuel line problem.

“My 2000 AGCO Allis Chalmers tractor is my worst buy. Something always seems to go wrong with it, whether it’s something big like the 3-pt. lift or a smaller thing like the speedometer, etc. The synchronizers in the transmission have already gone out. I don’t work this tractor too hard, either. I use it mostly for field-type work.”

AGCO Gleaner M2 combine yet

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
George Hammond, Pittsville, Md. · Vol. 43, No. 1 (2019), p. 15

“I’ve harvested thousands of acres of corn and beans with my 1980 AGCO Gleaner M2 combine, yet over all those years it has needed only minor repairs.”

AGCO LT90 tractor equipped

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Steve Landgrebe, Albia, Iowa · Vol. 42, No. 6 (2018), p. 14

Steve’s 1991 Dodge pickup equipped with a Cummins diesel engine has more than 300,000 miles on it but is still going strong. “I replaced the transmission at about 200,000 miles. Otherwise this pickup has required only routine maintenance.

“My 2017 AGCO LT90 tractor equipped with a Cummins diesel engine just turned over 10,000 hrs. I’ve spent little money on this tractor, mainly for oil and tires.”

He’s had problems with his 2017 Sears Craftsman chainsaw equipped with an 18-in. bar. “The engine won’t idle whenever I set it down. The store where I bought the saw finally gave me a voucher card, but I used it to buy tools instead of another saw.”

AGCO discbine broke

0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Worst Buy
Harold Schmudlach, Montello, Wis. · Vol. 40, No. 4 (2016), p. 13

“I like my Mustang 2040 skid loader equipped with a Yamaha diesel engine. It has had a few electrical problems, but the engine always starts even in the coldest weather. It has more than 3,000 hours on it but still runs smooth.

“The roller on my 2009 AGCO discbine broke while I was cutting hay, and a spring that holds the header up also broke. The company failed to stand behind the machine even though I had used it for only one season.”

Read every report in full

FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.

Subscribe to FARM SHOW