Leonard Janke, Walsh, Alberta: He nominates two “best buys”. “My New Holland 114 Haybine did a great job on a heavy hay crop with absolutly no breakdowns. My Flexicoil post pounder with its hydraulic controls lets you line up your posts easily ee a ee ominate t Buys and drives them straight.” He had trouble with an intranasal [BR vaccine. "All directions for TSV2 from Norden were followed but two months after treatment, 90% of my feeder steers developed IBR. This intranasal vaccine was a waste of time.”
Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 7, No. 3 (1983)
52 reports from pages 10–12 · 46 Best Buys10 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →
Allan C. Park, Wyoming, Ontario: “Our old silo-unloader always seemed to be breaking down. It meant constant trips up into the silo to fix it. With the new Patz, the only time you have to go up is to lower it, or for maintenance.”
Ervin Chummey, Lore City, Ohio: “In 1970 we bought a 70 by 100-ft. all-steel Cuckler building with a 20year guarantee on the metal siding and roof. About six year later, the roof started to rust. We contacted the Cuckler Company and they sent outa company representative. He agreed it was a product failure and took several pictures of the building and said they would be back to repair or replace it. About a year later we called to see what happened. They said they had so many buildings to do repairs on that they had run out of good weather but that they would come back the next summer. To this day, they have never showed up,”
Roger W. Wessels, Fairbury, IIL: “I would like to nominate as “best buy” two places to buy tools and parts. They are: Kitts Industrial, 22384 Grand River, Detroit, Mich. 48219 (ph 313 538-2585 or toll free 800 5216579) and Wholesale Tool, 12155 Stepnans Drive, Box 68 Warren, Mich, 48990 (ph toll free 800 5213420 or 313 754-9270) You get the best and the fastest service have ever seen for anything from bearings for combines to drill bits. The drill bits are the best bargain have ever seen,”
Louie Van Setten, Fairfield, Mont: His ‘best buy” is his 1977 TR70 New Holland combine. ‘With 1.000 hours on it we have replaced only two $9.75 bearings. No belts have broken yet We had one injector line break on the Caterpillar engine.”
John Deere
Leo Mugan, Cascade, Wis.: Heading his ‘‘worst buy” list is his Deere 15¥%-ft. 1000 field cultivator. ‘The rock shaft is not strong enough and the cultivator actually bounces on it. The only way to stop the bouncing is to stop the tractor and start out again, ‘The company rep was not very helpful. even though offered to pay the welding costs if he would give me the needed supports, but he didn’t want to re-do the engineer's work, That might be a good idea though, if the engineers don't do their homework.”
Steve Willet, Thayer, lowa: ‘It’s real handy to check cows, get cows in, and for gettig into places a 4-WD won't go. Lets you have a little fun while you work," says Steve, pleased with his Honda ATC 3-wheeler 200E.
Robert Fellenz, Loyal, Wis.: He names his Harvestore high-moisture structure as “best buy” “After feeding dry corn and high moisture ear corn out of a conventional silo to dairy cows and having the corn become so moldy the cows refuse to eat it, it’s great to have the same consistency year-around, The cows clean it all up. “My Deere equipment is also on the plus side. The tractors I’ve owned —a 3010, 4010, 4020, 5020, 7020, and 4430 — my combines, swather, choppers, corn planters and my five 1275 wagons have all performed extremely well.”
John Frick, Morrison, Okla.: He's upset with his *Cullor automatic cattle sprayer mineral box."' This automatic device is supposed to spray the cows as they eat salt or minerals, You train them by using it as a salt feeder only at first. The problem is that every time you turn the sprayer on the cows are frightened and refuse to use the feeder. Also, it is very poorly built. The plastic parts break and the metal base bends. It's the pits.”’
John Deere
Delbert L. Kalkwarf, Parkersburg, Iowa: ‘“‘Deere's test farm must be a waste of money if they put junk like this on the market,’ says Delbert, upset with his Deere 220 disk. “It won't run level from front to back or side to side, Deere has recalled it twice for modifications.” On the plus side, he’s pleased with his Auger Dolly from Top Air Mfg., Parkersburg, Iowa. ‘For an inexpensive item, the Auger Dolly can't be beat. It makes moving and hooking up my 56 and 61 ft. grain augers very easy. Adding that third wheel sure makes it easy for one person to move an auger by hand. Truly a back anc wife saver.”
John Kastner, Yale, lowa: ‘‘My best buys are Bowerman rotating disc scrapers made in Dawson, N. Dak., for my Deere Max-Emerge planter with disc openers. They work in any ground conditions, wear longer and they cost less than original equipment scrapers,”' says John.
Robert Braver, Delavan, Wisc.: He likes his 112 Sachs-Dolmar chain saw. "This is a real tough saw. No problems — it just saws and saws. Never fails to start.”
Kelly D. Skrdlant, Bladen, Neb.: “Having baled two seasons with this baler, I've had no trouble whatsoever. The baler’s open throat design allows feeding of hard-to-handle crops. such as tall cane. Well-made product with sasy and simple maintenance,"’ says Kelly, pleased with his Hesston 5580 baler.
International Harvester
Charles R. Utter, Georgetown, Ohio: Charles has been pleased with his International 986 tractor that he bought in 1981. "It has plenty of power, a good hydraulic system, handles well with good visibility, and is easy on fuel, A real pleasure to operate,”
Chevrolet
Charles H. Keller, Chowchilla, Calif: “Mine is sitting in the barn after less than 2 hrs. use,"’ says Charles, upset with his Weed Badger from Town and Country Research, Marion, N. Dak. ‘It’s a tractormounted rotary weeder that's supposed to eliminate hand hoeing around orchard trees. It cost over $3,000, including the tractor mounting frame. The sensor is erratic and will either not retract as it moves around trees or will uproot young trees and shake them right at the tractor driver's head. Also, the teeth on the unit break right at the welds and it clogs readily, so that you have to manually reverse it at every tree. The manufacturer said a year ago that he had all the problems fixed and that he would visit me with the new sensor. I'm still waiting. This isn’t the same machine that saw demonstrated at the Tulare farm show.” On the positive side, Charles has had good luck with his Chevy S-10 pickup. “It gets 30 plus mpg. and we haven't had any problems. The first year’s operating costs are less than 40% of my other Chevy standard pickup.”
Ford
W. Scott Barnes, Monroe, Va.: He heats his 140-year-old farmhouse and a 14 by 20 ft. office building with his “This was our only source of heat last winter.” “best buy’’ Taylor outdoor wood burning 400 gal. hot water furnace. “Everything is automatic, providing uniform heat in the house without all of the dirt and dust associated with woodburners. This was our only source of heat last winter." Scott’s unhappy with his 1979 Ford % ton 4-WD pickup. ‘At 3,000 miles the valves began to rattle, and I took it to the service department. I was told that the rattling was normal. Later, took it back and got the same answer, At 18,000 miles the noise was so bad, and it burned a quart of — oil every 100 mi., that [had a valve job done, The mechanic said the valve stems and guides were the worst he had ever seen. I took the bill to the dealer but he wouldn't pay because he had no record of my having the valve noise checked during warranty. At 23,000 miles the rings and all bearings were shot. Now the transmission is about to go, the front axle is broken and the brakes are shot. This is truly a piece of junk!"
John Metzger, St. Clements, Ontario: His Renn 12-ft. self-propelled 2000 swather is his ‘worst buy”. “The hydrostatic drive motors are too small for the machine. It broke down with no parts available. The hydraulic oil lines are too light and the header is too heavy for the hydraulic capacity of the machine, It broke down with no parts available, Finally got the motors fixed in Toronto by a private motor company, which was real expensive."
Allis-Chalmers + 1 more
James O'Connor, Blooming Prairie, Minn: ‘‘My father bought an Allis Chalmers N-6 combine in 1980," says James. “It was a total disaster. Everything that could go wrong, did. Allis Chalmers convinced him to trade for an updated N-7 Gleaner but even with that machine you were lucky if you made it to the field without breaking down. He has since traded that machine, too, and happy with his new 7720 Deere. “My own worst buy was some miscellaneous foreign tools I bought with price in mind. I got my money's worth, used a 14-in, pipe wrench for the first time and broke the jaw right off. wish the U.S. would quit importing such garbage.” His “best buy” is his 1981 Mercury Capri. “It gives me an excellent ride and gets 35 to 40 mpg. under loaded conditions. Not at all like the foreign imports that are ruining the economy.”
John Deere
Edward Krizan, Harrow, Ontario: He's happy with his Deere 7720 combine with a 220 grain head outfitted with a Tiger Jaw cutterbar. ‘‘Productivity is the key word here. With the Tiger Jaws cutterbar we can increase our speed in beans without shattering the beans out of the pods. Excellent cleaning and fast unloading time. Operator comfort is above superior standards. This combine handles grain like no other, Can't see where they can make it any better in quality.”
Donald Mitchell, Versailles, Ky.: “The 370 cu. in. V-8 motor in our Ford F-600 dump bed truck has plenty of power and runs very smooth. The dump bed is handy for hauling dirt or building materials. We use it primarily to haul hay, cattle and tobacco. Our Green Machine hand-held powered garden cultivator is also a good buy and one of the handiest items on the farm.”
Massey Ferguson
Vernon Walter, Groton, S. Dak.: He lists his 1981 Versatile 835 and 2705 Massey Ferguson tractors as “best buys’’. ‘The Versatile is real economical and has plenty of power for all our needs. The 2705 has been trouble free and also has plenty of power. Both are comfortable to operate,”
Justin Schafer, Portland, Ind.: “Now it's fun to harvest corn,” says Justin, pleased with his “best buy” New Idea Uni-Harvestor 708 with a 3-row cornhead and husking bed. “The three pieces of equipment together are well-engineered to do the job they’re supposed to do, and do it efficiently. Also, I like the reliability, Not even a loose nut or bolt after three years."
James J. Farkas, New Era, Mich.: “I haven't made any purchase in the past year or so but the best investment I ever made was a Deutz 4006 tractor purchased in 1970. We use it for everything and it hasn't cost us a dime for repairs.”
John Deere
Frank J. Zieser, Walker, lowa: His “best buy” is a Keldermann manual fold hinge for his Deere 7000 Max Exerge 12-row planter from Kelderman Mfg., Inc. Oskaloosa, Iowa. ‘‘It works great because one man can be ready for road travel in about five minutes without unhitching from the planter, and the unit costs much less than the Deere hydraulic fold system. “Another good buy was our Stormor 24-ft. Ezee Dry drying bin, For the past eight seasons our Stormor has done an excellent job with very little repair.”
John Frick, Morrison, Okla.: John's happy with Eetrin Insecticide cattle ear tags. “These tags do an excellent job of keeping flies off cattle. Very pleased with them.”
Donald G. Payne, Taylorsville, N.D: “Our Knight 350 ‘“‘soup or solid’’ manure spreader is our best buy. It has hauled approximately 500 loads of manure per year without any problems for the past three years. Works well with all types of soupy and solid manure.”
John Deere
Charles Gaffney, Minneota, Minn.: “Our Sukup 4-Way II dryer, purchased in 1981, was our worst buy,” says Charles. “That season we could not dry corn for more than 24 hours without a breakdown of bearings. shafts, or augers. And, it dried unevenly. It was really a nightmare. guess they were experimenting on the farm. This past year Sukup replaced faulty parts and made some changes and the results were nonstop drying.” On the “best buy” side, he’s happy with his Deere 6620 Hydro combine, “This piece of equipment has been excellent. Workmanship and quality control are great and we harvested over 1,200 acres of corn, soybeans and wheat without a single breakdown. Dealer service is excellent. This machine has high capacity with a 6-row cornhead and a 20-ft. flex head."
Gathial W. Knight, Hopkinsville, Kty: “We like our 1587 Krause disc harrow because the frame is well constructed and we have yet to break a disc blade or axle after 2 years use. And no bearings have had to be replaced, either. It does exactly what the dealer promised.”’
Case + 1 more
Philip Wilson, Lewisburg, Tenn.: “My best buy would be my 2290 Case tractor. The tractor has more horsepower than its rating. The fuel economy is very good. The cab is comfortable and the hydraulics are superior to any tractor have ever had any experience with, ‘The dealer is also good. “Another good buy is my 605 Vermeer round baler. This machine has given six years of service with only modest repairs in key wear areas. The baler has paid for itself several times and hopefully has several more good vears left.”
Gehl
Louis Janish, Kimball, S. Dak.: He nominates his Gehl 1500 round baler as ‘worst buy”. “Talways had trouble getting a bale started, Also, the bearings on the belt rollers were not heavy enough and I spent too much time replacing bearings when conditions were right for baling. I traded it in on an 1805 Gehl last fall and, although haven't used it all that much, it sure seems to work fine. Bearings on the belt rollers are a lot heavier and I've had no problems starting a bale."’
John Deere
Art Walz, Luana, Iowa: ‘Can the same combine model be both a best and a worst buy?" asks Art, who “Everything but the engine broke or was loose on this machine.” bought both a 1979 and a 1981 Deere 6620 sidehill combine. ‘The 1979 model was built just before the strike in late 1979. Everything except the engine broke or was loose on this machine. averaged 13.7 acres per day for 51 days with a brand new machine when we should have averaged 40 or more. My dealer did all he could for me. “I traded that machine for another 6620 sidehill in 1981 and it was the opposite of the older model. Very enjoyable and has caused little trouble. Anvone who thinks the selfleveling feature is not necessary on contoured fields like we have in Northeast lowa has never run one or seen it work.”
John Deere
Bob Wroten, Jordan Valley, Ore.: “I've had terrible experiences with odd-size Deere parts, forcing me to buy from Deere, which is always priced 30 to 120% higher. During haying or feeding, we'd have to wait for a Deere part to come from the other side of the nation, I've come to hate the color green. The parts were mainly belts, bearings and hydraulic cylinder components for a 200 stack wagon and a 230 shredder feeder. “Our best buy is a 5-bale moverfeeder made by ACME Manufacturing of Filer, Ind. We used it to transport and line up 1,200 to 1.500 tons of round bales in the summer and feed them out in the winter. It's the best feeder we've used in the winter because of its simple design. Its 5-bale capacity allows us to feed large Best And Wo bunches of cows by scattering hay far enough to alIowall the cattle to eat. The company has been the best I've ever dealt with, in understanding their product and standing behind it. “Another good buy is our Hot Shot Power Mite made by Hot Shot Products, Savage, Minn. We have used many hot shots but none have lasted as long as these. They are light, compact and fit easily in your hand. After use on several thousand cattle, we haven't had one malfunction and they're powerful enough to get the animal's attention, yet mild enough not to bruise the meat."
Oliver + 1 more
Steve Thompson, Trenton, Tex.: “In 1972 I bought a 720 Oliver wire baler and it was, and still is, the amazement of everyone that knows about it,”” says Steve, who's used all kind of balers in his custom operation, baling well over 100,000 bales annually. “I baled over 600,000 bales with the Oliver, replacing ten bottoms in the bale chamber, The sides of the bale chamber even had holes in them. I have never seen another baler that has been used so much the sides wore through. I sold the baler in 1979 to another custom baler fora standby. He liked it so well he put it on full time and baled over 100,000 bales with it. I understand White has sold the patent for this Oliver baler to Hesston.”
Husqvarna
Henry A. Chapman, Dorset, Vt.: ‘I ran over it with my 8-ton truck and it still works,"’ says Henry, pleased with his Husqvarna 285 21-in. chainsaw. ‘Besides standing up to abuse, it has a lot of power, runs well and doesn't need much maintenance. It's not heavy, either.” He had trouble with his “Belsaw 550 chainsaw sharpener. Poorly designed in that you cannot readily alter the grinding angle and the chain holder has excessive play. The whole machine is cheaply made and lacks the rigidity necessary for precision work. Time consuming to set up and operate. I can doa better and faster job with a file."’
GMC
Kenneth Barger, Hardinsburg, Kty: He's pleased with his 1983 GMC diesel 6.2 liter heavy half-ton pickup. “It has about the same performance as the 1979 GMC with a 350 V-8 gas engine and gets about twice the mileage.”
International Harvester
Murray Musselman, Gowanstown, Ontario: ‘ bought an oxygen limiting sealed concrete silo from Mid-West Silo Systems Ltd., Wellesley, Ontario, in 1977 for high moisture shelled corn that is my best buy,” says Murray. “The silo works great with almost no problems and saves a lot of money on drying charges and labor to haul the corn to and from the dryer.” Garvin D, Anderson, Erskine, Alberta: “I bought this tractor new last fall. It's good on fuel, has plenty of power, is easy to drive and handles well in all situations,” reports Garvin about his “best buy” 5288 International tractor. pe )
John Deere
Dallas F. Boge, Gales Creek, Ore.: His ‘worst buy" is his Deere 317 tractor. ‘The engine seized after 20 to 30 hours. The dealer replaced it 50-50. The steering gets loose and requires constant adjustment. like the hydrostatic transmission, however, which works well mowing and rototilling 19 acres of Christmas trees.” “The steering gets loose and requires constant adjustment.” “best buy’. ‘Very useful. I read it cover to cover as soon as il arrives,”
Marvin Sutter, Waseca, Minn.: “This sprayer does a very uniform job of application and can put outa lot of material. The adjustable booms are really super and aren’t hard to fold. For the capcity, I couldn't find a better sprayer on the market,” says Marvin about his Demco 800-gal. sprayer with 60-ft, floating boom, “Another best buy is our Walinga 511 air conveyor. Twice last fall when a grain vehicle became disabled in a bad spot we were able to easily transfer the grain with the Walinga. It also enables us to fill tall grain bins that an auger couldn't reach and not have to worry about power lines overhead."
Bert Bakken, Shingle Springs, Calif: ‘It seems to be failure-proof,” says Bert, pleased with his Troy Bilt 5 hp. rototiller. “It starts on the second pull with a Briggs and Stratton engine, tears up the ground, including roots and debris, and it's easy to operate. It's also adaptable to other projects besides gardening.”
Chevrolet + 1 more
David Peterson, Dumont, Iowa: “In 160,000 miles we've replaced nothing but spark plugs and a water pump for the engine. The seat cushion has one small tear and the truck runs and drives as good as it did at 50,000 miles. Its only drawback is that it gets just 10 mpg.,"’ says David, happy with his 1973 Chevrolet % ton pickup with automatic transmission and a small V-8, His “worst buy" is an Allis Chalmers Gleaner K combine that he bought used in 1973. "I've replaced the bearings between the variable speed 13 times. The first owner replaced it at least once. I've had no help from the company. I'm satisfied with the job the combine does but now that it’s time to buy a new combine I can't see any reason to buy another machine that the company won't back.”
International Harvester
Dale Sampson, Wheeling, W. Va.: “International tractors can’t be beat for the long run,” says Dale. “I bought an 1H 656 tractor when it was 10 years old but it hasn't given me any trouble in two years. It's the best all-around tractor I've had in 30 years of farming and it should last me for many more years.”
G.W. Sawtelle, Boston, Ga.: ; ‘We couldn’t keep the engine running for two minutes — even in the repair shop," he reports, disappointed with his Homelite 550 chainsaw. “The company has discontinued this model but not soon enough for me. I have a $400 saw that has not run an hour total since it was new.”
W.L. Boutin, Valmarie, Sask.: “The end walls fit terribly, the sliding doors stick, and there is a bad bird problem. The compay is unwilling to correct these problems,” says Boutin, about his “worst buy’ Miracle Span quonset building. On the positive side, he’s happy with his 1980 Honda Accord. ‘‘It has 75,000 miles on it with absolutely no trouble. Still runs like a top and I've yet to find a grease nipple on it."’
Don Colton, Boonville, N.Y.: He lists his Oldsmobile Ciera diesel 4door sedan as ‘‘best buy"’, “It cut our fuel bill by an average of $27.50 per month. Easy driving and handling. Electric locks, windows and seats, along with climate control and cruise control, help prevent long distance fatigue.”
John Deere
Loren Fulford, Largo, Ind.: “This unit will not work for 12 hours without a malfunction of some type. We have replaced gears, augers, switches and pins but it is junk and we finally quit using it,’’ says Loren, disappointed with his Sukup heavy- uty 3-drop grain stirrer. He’s happy, however, with his Deere 140 lawn tractor, “Before the 140, had a Deere 112 which I bought new and used for 8 years with no problems. The 140 is also working out great.”
Chrysler + 1 more
Roger Lee, Franklin, Minn.: ‘‘My best buys are my 10 Schweiss elevated calf stalls with Tenderfoot pads which I purchased from Schweiss Manufacturing, Fairfax, Minn,,”’ reports Roger. “Our calves are kept in the stalls from birth to 30 days of age, at which time they're weaned, We freshen 100-plus Holsteins annually and, in the two years we've had the stalls, our death loss has been at zero, and the number of calves we'd had to treat can be counted on one hand. “Also a best buy is our Chrysler cars. We bought our 1969 Dodge station wagon with a 383 cu. in. engine and it’s still running strong after 167,000 mi. of service with no major repairs. In fact, the valve covers have never been removed. Our 1975 Chrysler Cordoba has 114,000 miles with the same results, and our son's 1970 Plymouth Barracuda has more than 80,000 miles. “My worst buy is a 1978 Honda ATC 90, It was next to impossible to keep the engine and transmission operational at the same time. Dealer service was a rip-off which would result in a several hundred dollar repair bill annually. Needless to say, the ATC has been gathering dust. The dealer must have run out of suckers because he was forced to close recently.”
White
W.C. White, St. Ansgar, lowa: “ have a 1979 Oldsmobile diesel and keeping it operating has been a big problem. The Blue Book deducts $750 for 1978 and 1979 cars with diesel motors and some dealers will not take them in trade, which leaves me and others in a very bad spot."
White + 2 more
Ben Theimer, Winfield, Kan.: “White was the only company that would offer us a demonstrator. The dealer said it would sell itself and it did,’ says Ben, pleased with his 2-155 tractor with a 478 cu. in. Hercules engine. ‘‘It has a massive cast frame with an 18-speed transmission that will shift three times in each of six gears on the go. It has unbelievable lugging power with several gears in the field working range. The cab has good visibility and the tractor is easy to maintain.” Howard L. Ross, Roseberry, Prince Edwards Island: He’s had good luck with his Massey Ferguson 245 tractor. “It does everything you'd expect and then some. Very economical to operate. Good dealer, too.”
Martin Wolters, Paul, Idaho: ‘This machine picks up and stacks 2-tie or 3-tie bales and stacks them ina neat 8 by 8 ft. stack, seven bales high. It'll double deck the stacks if desired and it'll retrieve the stack and load it ona truck. It's very well-constructed and built heavy. A great asset to the haying industry,” concludes Martin, about his “best buy" Freeman bale wagon made by Freeman Manufacturing, Portland, Ore.
Terry Bryant, Miniota, Manitoba: The Poulan chain saw I purchased was a vibrating piece of junk which would make your head ache if the saw ran long enough. I took it back to the dealer several times but he could not fix it and wouldn't take it back at any price on trade. At the time, the saw had used less than a gallon of gas. The dealer was poor but the saw was even poorer. I gave the saw toa friend to use for parts. Absolutely the worst new piece of equipment I have ever purchased. “My new Homelite XLI chain saw is a best buy, Works great and dealer service is tops. Another best buy is a Leon 10-ft. dozer blade, which is really well-made and has stood up to some real tough use.”
Allis-Chalmers
John Kiss, St. Paul, Alberta: ‘'! bought it used in 1947 and have been using it ever since,” says John, happy all these years with his 1942 Allis Chalmers WD tractor. “It still runs like a charm. There has never been a “T bought it used in 1947 and have used it ever since.” major breakdown in all the time I've owned it. It was rated at 37 and all 37 horses pull!"
John Deere
Frank Nenninger, Laurens, N.Y.: Heading his ‘best buy” list is his Deere 3960 forage harvester. "A good, capable machine that's easy to change from corn to haylage. Like the electra-hydraulic controls.”