Montana: what farmers say
15 reports in FARM SHOW · 12 Best Buys3 Worst Buys
Montana 4-WD model 4357 loader
1 Best Buy1 Worst Buy“My 2005 Montana 4-WD model 4357 loader tractor outworks all Case backhoes, and it cost about $15,000 less than a comparable Deere model. It has the best-matched, perfectly ratioed gearing ever. It also has a lot of power; a good steering system, air conditioner, and heater; and enough power and torque to get out of any situation. The only limitation is that the lights on the cab and hood are light duty.”
He’s disappointed with his 2005 Montana 4-WD, 38 hp loader tractor. “The support brackets for the bolts that secure the front-end loader sheared off. Then, with less than 100 hours on the tractor, the clutch assembly went out. It has a dry disc-type clutch system. Now the engine rpm indicator has failed.
“I’ve used this tractor to bush hog my property, but because of problems with the clutch system this tractor should be used only on flat ground. I paid $18,000 for it. No more off-brand tractors for me.”
Montana R3644 tractor
1 Best Buy1 Worst Buy“The shuttle synchronizer gear on my Montana R3644 tractor has failed twice with less than 1,000 hrs. of use. We don’t have any tractor repair shops in our area and the company doesn’t publish repair manuals, so it’ll take some reverse engineering to self-repair the damage.”
“My 2009 Montana R3644 is a great little tractor. The diesel engine on it starts easily even at 11 degrees below zero, and it’ll plow 30-in. deep snow without tire chains. I use this tractor with a 7-ft. bush hog and with a 6-ft. box blade equipped with ripper shanks. I’ve also used it with a loader bucket to dig out a septic system. No problems.”
Montana 3840 tractor
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I bought a 2005 Montana 3840 tractor in 2006. I have used it since then without any problem and it has always worked when needed. The hydraulic system seems to be stronger than other tractors my neighbors own with the same horsepower. I have, however, broken the 3-pt. lift arms when trying to lift too much. The battery lasted 11 years. I wish I could buy more batteries from the same company.”
Montana 3940 4-WD tractor
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysWilliam nominates his Montana 3940 4-WD tractor as his “best buy”. “This tractor is built tough like a small Army tank and has a transmission made by Eaton Corp. A mechanic friend sold it to me, but he hasn’t had a chance to fix it because it just won’t break down.”
Montana 4045 tractor
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 2005 Montana 4045 tractor works as good as a Kubota but cost a lot less. It’s an excellent tractor.
“I think all electric tools from Harbor Freight are worst buys. I’ve had problems with my 18-volt drill-drivers, 4-in. grinder, and sawzall. They have no bearings - only bushings that fail quickly.”
Montana 4344 utility tractor
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysA 2009 Montana 4344 utility tractor rates as Darry’s “best buy”. “I’ve always been skeptical of low-cost imports, but so far this imported tractor has been terrific. It’s made in South Korea and powered by a Mitsubishi 4-cyl., 41 hp diesel engine. It has a lot of nice features including a beefy front-end loader, front wheel assist, a 16-speed transmission, tilt steering, shuttle shift transmission, live pto, and differential lock. It also has ag tires, a tight turning radius, smooth hydraulics, and the operator’s platform is obstruction-free with well-located controls.”
Montana 45 hp diesel tractor
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysAlice is the satisfied owner of a 2010 Montana 45 hp diesel tractor with cab, air conditioner and heater. “This tractor is great in every way. It handles really nice and is easy on fuel, and the cab is comfortable enough to work all day long.”
Montana 4540 compact tractor
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“It’s one of my best buys ever,” says Greg about his 2004 Montana 4540 compact tractor. “We use it with a 72-in. mower, box blade, front-end loader, and to pull an 18-ft. trailer. It has far surpassed my expectations for quality and price. It was well worth the trip I made to Texas to buy it.
“My 1986 Ford F-250 4-WD extended cab diesel pickup equipped with an 8-ft. bed is a best buy. We’ve used it to haul firewood in our commercial business, to tow a 24-ft. camping trailer, and to make many trips into town. I installed a Banks Sidewinder Turbo on the engine about 10 years ago. The turbo really helps when towing up steep grades and also got rid of the ‘smoking like a locomotive’ problem it was having. This pickup now has about 120,000 miles on it, and I’m looking forward to another 120,000 miles and 20 more years of service. When I bought it 20 years ago I thought the $18,000 price tag was steep, but now I wouldn’t sell it or trade it for a new truck costing $25,000 to $30,000.”
Montana 4540 4-WD tractor
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 2005 Montana 4540 4-WD tractor does everything I ask it to and is easy on fuel.”
Montana 5740 C tractor
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 2008 Montana 5740 C tractor starts and runs well and has controls that are easy to operate. I use this tractor to plow, plant, cut and bale hay, and to load and feed round bales. I also plow snow with it using an oversized snow bucket.
“I’ve put more than 800 hours on my 2007 Kubota RTV 900 utility vehicle with only routine maintenance. I use it to pull a water wagon and to haul wood and hay, and to do numerous other hauling chores around our farm and garden. It works great with a front hitch for backing 4-wheel wagons into place.
“My 2008 Vermeer Rebel round baler has performed as advertised. No problems.”
Montana T-Rex 350E post driver
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysJohn is pleased with his Montana T-Rex 350E post driver (www.montanapostdriver.com; ph 800-330-1937). “We mounted it on our used Deere 35D compact excavator (also a best buy) for ranch fence work.
“My worst buy is my Klein Tools ET450 Advanced Circuit Breaker Finder. It wouldn’t come on and never did.”
Montana post driver
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysRoy gave his old Stihl 029 chainsaw a little more than it could handle. “First I accidentally rolled a log on top of the saw, which broke the gas tank. I had the tank fixed and was back in business. Then I accidentally felled a big 24-in. dia. tree on it, and broke off some parts. The recoil was only cracked, though, so I pulled the starter rope and the saw fired right up and kept cutting, although it didn’t sound at all like a chainsaw any more. Totally awesome. This saw is gone, but not forgotten.
“I hired 2 men to build fence and found the Montana post driver they used to be a totally awesome machine (www.montanapostdriver.com; ph 800 330-1937). The only negative is that it’s very loud - ear plugs are a must.”
Montana tractor
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“My 2005 Montana tractor is my worst buy. I’ve reported on the problems with this tractor before but failed to mention two other defects. The square towbar holder on the underside split out while carrying a load of hay. Also, the adjuster for keeping a piece of equipment level has got to be tied off or it will unadjust itself.”
Read every report in full
FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.