Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › New Holland › 489

New Holland 489 haybine

What FARM SHOW readers say · 8 Best Buys2 Worst Buys · Farm & Livestock Equipment

New Holland 489 haybine

8 Best Buys2 Worst Buys
Worst Buy
Lawrence Bannerman, Holly, Mich. · Vol. 34, No. 6 (2010), p. 15

Lawrence is disappointed with his 2008 Hesston 1120 haybine. “When the haybine was delivered it wasn’t completely put together and the dealer wouldn’t do anything about it. I used the machine to cut about five acres of hay and it shook so bad the knife broke. The dealer took it back and said he fixed it, but the next year it didn’t work any better. I took the haybine back to the dealer for repair and when I went to pick it up the dealer said the warranty had expired and I had to pay $500 to get the machine back. Since then I’ve cut only about 50 acres with it and have spent $1,000 on repairs.

“My 1979 New Holland 489 haybine was able to cut about 5,000 acres of hay before it broke down and I had to spend $900 on a new gearbox. But since I bought the Hesston model I’ve cut 600 acres of hay with the old New Holland model and only about 50 acres with the Hesston.” Goodyear Conquest TSI series tires on it. After only about 29,000 miles we’ve already had to replace three of the tires. The tires start separating in the center of the tread, and then the steel belting starts to protrude. We’ve gone to two local Goodyear dealers with no satisfaction. No more Goodyear products for us.”

Best Buy
Zenas Shildt, Mercersburg, Penn. · Vol. 20, No. 5 (1996), p. 16

“Our 1994 Martin 8-ft. silage bagger packs well and makes a smoother bag of haylage than any other bagger I’ve seen. It works great and costs only about two thirds as much as other popular baggers. “We like our 1995 Deere 930 12-ft. mower-conditioner. It mows and dries hay faster than the New Holland 489 mower-conditioner we previously owned. Works great.”

Best Buy
Ray Fiedler, St. Joseph, Minn. · Vol. 18, No. 3 (1994), p. 15

Ray Fiedler, St. Joseph, Minn.: Ray's impressed with his 1993 Ford 8630 2-WD tractor. “I really like the powershift transmission, foot throttle, and cab. It has doors on both sides. “My 1992 Case-IH 600 silage blower runs smooth and has a lot of capacity. use it with a 100 plus hp tractor.” On the negative side, Ray lists his Deere 1219 mower conditioner. “I bought it in the fall of 1992 when I traded in an 8-year-old New Holland 489 haybine and used it for the first time in 1993. didn’t like the way itcut - hay plugged up at the sickle guards.”

Best Buy
Randy Warren, Brechin, Ontario · Vol. 14, No. 5 (1990), p. 12

Randy Warren, Brechin, Ontario: A 1987 New Holland 489 9-ft. haybine is Randy’s “best buy”. “The header flotation is excellent and the intermeshing rubber rolls do a fine job of conditioning hay. The second year we owned the machine a roll driveshaft broke even though the machine was out of warranty, but the company replaced it. As the ad says, ‘If it isn’t a New Holland, it just isn’t a haybine.’””

Best Buy
Larry Shepler, Reynoldsville, Penn. · Vol. 14, No. 4 (1990), p. 13

Larry Shepler, Reynoldsville, Penn.: “It operates smoothly and runs good, but is very clumsily built compared to the 1816 model it replaced,” says Larry about his 1988 Case 1818 skid steer loader. “There's too much overhang on the back so I can’t maneuver it in small places. It also needs a fuel gauge.” Larry’s Hesston 1010 Hydra Swing mower-conditioner is another “worst buy”. “The pivot tongue is the only good feature as it makes it easy to move the rig back and forth from field to repair shop. In one 1 3/4acre field I once broke 11 knives and three guards. It knocked out the cutterbar heads on a regular basis and they cost $70 each to replace. The conditioning rolls were there only to move hay off the cutterbar - they “The pivot tongue is the only good feature. Makes it easy to move the rig back and forth from field to repair shop.” couldn’ tcrimp arotten potato, Finally, stress cracks and bad bearings made us trade it for a New Holland 489 haybine which has caused very little trouble.” On the positive side, “My 1986 White 2 110 tractor runs smooth and is easy on fuel. Gear shifting isa little on the sticky side, but the powershift is smooth and easy to operate. The cab is very quiet and has better visibility than any other tractor I've ever driven. We like the cab so much that we’re looking for one for our White 2-85 tractor.” Larry’s 1989 Deere 430 round baler is another “best buy.” “It’s so easy to operate that the first bale I made with it looked as good as the last of the season, The monitor works great, but it’s difficult to set bale size because there’s no bale size indicator.”

Best Buy
Gordon Fike, Mansfield, Ohio · Vol. 11, No. 5 (1987), p. 13

Gordon Fike, Mansfield, Ohio: He nominates his 1986 Dodge 150 pickup and 1986 Ingersoll 18-hp. lawn and garden tractor as “best buys”. “The pickup rides well, gets good mileage and is well built. The garden tractor also works well. I have the hydrotiller, snow thrower and blade attachments which all work great.” James Thompson, Thompson, Iowa: “For the past 5 yrs. I've used Bladex with my grass herbicide on corn and generally got good results, But the past 3 yrs. I’ve had to spot treat more and more broadleaf escapes with Banvel. This year was a failure due mostly to dry conditions. treated some spots twice and still had poor results, Next year I'll forget the Bladex and come back post emerge with Banvel, or Buctriland atrazine to control broadleaves.” He's happier with his New Holland 489 Haybine and Kinze 500 gal. spray cart. “I replaced a479 Haybine, which was a good machine, with the 489 and there’s no comparison. The 489 has less weight supported by the float springs. In 300 acres of mowing, I’ve only broken one guard and section, The paint job is better than on most cars and pickups I’ve owned, “The Kinze cart is very rugged and versaule. Luse it with a 3-pt. 40-ft. boom sprayer. The surprising thing is that with a disk or digger behind, it makes for a long rig butno maneuverability problems are created. The implement follows the cart like a shadow, Its 18.4 by 26 tires make it roll like it’s not even there. The only time that I notice the extra pull on my Deere 4630 is when the tank is full and going uphill.”

Worst Buy
Gary Stripe, Garden Grove, lowa · Vol. 9, No. 6 (1985), p. 13

Gary Stripe, Garden Grove, lowa: ‘“‘My New Holland 489 mower/ conditioner mows under almost any condition when it's working. However, it has been the worst lemon ever owned. In the first three years I replaced the main gearbox twice alt my own expense. Finally this year New Holland notified their dealers about the defective gearbox and they replaced mine. All the tin-work, doors and shields are falling apart and the tongue with enclosed driveshaft keeps cracking and breaking. Also, inside the tongue on the drive shaft universal joint is a grease zerk that cannot be reached without removing the tongue from the machine. I have the price of two conditioners invested into this one, and all I have to show for it is one worn-out machine.”

Best Buy
Bill Green, Wapakoneta, Ohio · Vol. 9, No. 5 (1985), p. 12

Bill Green, Wapakoneta, Ohio: ‘My worst buy ever is an A.O. Smith water heater in my milkhouse. It's a piece of junk,” says Bill. “My best farm implement ever is my New Holland 489 windrower. It's a masterpiece of perfection. “Also, my Silver King tractor built in 1946 in Plymouth, Ohio, has to be one of the best small tractors ever made. I've used it practically every day since I bought it new with very few problems."

Best Buy
Leonard Robinson, Whittemore, Mich. · Vol. 9, No. 2 (1985), p. 15

Leonard Robinson, Whittemore, Mich.: "You can travel at a good speed and it doesn't plug. It also makes good windrows," reports Leonard about his "best buy" New Holland 489 Haybine.

Best Buy
James Autry, Fayetteville, N.C. · Vol. 8, No. 3 (1984), p. 13

James Autry, Fayetteville, N.C.: "My new International 1420 Axial Flow combine has lots of capacity, plenty of power and is easy on fuel. | get excellent grain samples. Good dealer service." On the negative side, he's had trouble with his New Holland 489 mower/conditioner. "It's never done a clean job cutting. Poor factory fol- lowup."

Own a New Holland? Tell FARM SHOW how it’s held up.

Your report could appear in a future issue.

Send your Best or Worst Buy

More New Holland products

New Holland TC40 tractor 3 best · 0 worstNew Holland Workmaster 40 tractor 2 best · 0 worstNew Holland 5610S tractor 1 best · 1 worstNew Holland 570 square baler 4 best · 0 worstNew Holland Boomer 40 loader tractor 3 best · 0 worstNew Holland TN55D tractor 1 best · 1 worstNew Holland 460 round baler 1 best · 2 worstNew Holland L175 skid loader 2 best · 0 worstNew Holland BR740 round baler 1 best · 1 worstNew Holland 55 hp compact tractor 3 best · 0 worstNew Holland TC29 tractor 2 best · 0 worstNew Holland C232 skid loader 2 best · 0 worstNew Holland 565 skid loader 2 best · 0 worstNew Holland T4-100 tractor 2 best · 1 worstNew Holland TS6.110 tractor 2 best · 0 worstNew Holland 848 round baler 3 best · 0 worstNew Holland TC-40 4-WD tractor 2 best · 0 worstNew Holland L220 skid loader 1 best · 1 worstNew Holland discbines 1 best · 2 worstNew Holland TC33D tractor 2 best · 0 worst

See all New Holland reports →