Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010)

74 reports from pages 12–15 · 63 Best Buys23 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Best Buy

Massey Ferguson 451 tractor

Mike Brockway, Corfu, N.Y. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 12

“I’m pleased with my 2005 Massey Ferguson 451 tractor which is equipped with a front-end loader and backhoe. I’ve used this tractor to dig out a lot of tree stumps and to clean out ditches and dig ponds. I do have issues with the pto switch – I’ve gone through two of them. The first switch went out right after I bought the tractor, and I bypassed it for 2 years before I bought a new switch. This tractor has had other minor electrical problems. Overall, though, I’ve worked it hard and it has held up well.”

Best Buy

Honda HR214 riding mowers

Albert Patterson, Taft, Tenn. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 12

“I own three Honda HR214 riding mowers and haven’t had a minute of trouble from any of them. They’re all at least 20 years old. These mowers are easy to maintain and fun to operate. Honda would do well to start making these mowers again.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

DeWalt 18-volt cordless impact wrench + 1 more

Greg Meyer, Grove City, Minn. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 12

Greg’s impressed with his DeWalt 18-volt cordless impact wrench equipped with a 1/2-in. drive. “I can’t believe how much torque this tool has. I use it everywhere, including installing dual wheels on my tractor. It’s an amazing tool.”

He’s disappointed with his Polaris 400 Sportsman 4-wheeler. “The day we picked this ATV up it overheated and we had to take it back to the dealer. The problem turned out to be a bad sensor. Since then, the machine has been back to the dealer about every three months. I bought a Polaris because everyone said they were indestructible. But this is the last one I’ll ever own.”

Worst Buy

Kubota L3400 tractor

Mike Fitchett, Westminster, Md. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 12

“I haven’t had any problems with my 2007 Kubota L3400 tractor, which is equipped with an LA463 front-end loader. This tractor always starts, even in the coldest weather, and it steers and handles well. It’ll handle a 5-ft. Bush Hog mower with no problem. We use it mainly for handling manure and mulch.”

Best Buy

Timber King B-20 band sawmill equipped + 1 more

Jeff Daugherty, Oak Harbor, Wash. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 12

“It’s built to last, and a lot of thought and craftsmanship went into it,” says Jeff about his 2006 Timber King B-20 band sawmill equipped with a Kohler 30 hp engine. “The hydraulic features on this sawmill make it basically a one-man operation. It’ll handle everything from a 36-in. dia., 20-ft. log to a piece of firewood.

“My 2009 Omni Dual saw – a handheld tool with 2 circular blades – started out working fine, but now the motor has given up and the blades are dull after minimal use. It’s not an easy tool to handle and has some potential hazards. For example, the cut metal material discharges in front of the cut and will fly up to 100 ft. away. Dogs take off every time they see me coming with this saw.”

Worst Buy

Ford F-350 4-WD pickup equipped

Kay Foster, Freer, Texas · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 12

A 2004 Ford F-350 4-WD pickup equipped with a 6-liter diesel engine rates as Kay’s “worst buy”. “The circuit board went out at about 40,000 miles. At about 80,000 miles the intake manifold failed, and the EGR valve went out. The fuel injectors also failed. It cost more than $3,000 to fix. We have a 1995 diesel-powered Ford F-350 with about 280,000 miles, and a 1996 diesel Ford F-350 with about 320,000 miles, so we were pleased with our first two Ford pickups. But after this problem with the 2004 model, we’re done buying Fords.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Melroe Spra Coupe 4640 self-propelled sprayer + 1 more

William Taylor, New Madrid, Mo. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 12

William likes his 2004 Melroe Spra Coupe 4640 self-propelled sprayer, which he bought used. “This sprayer is a huge step up from my Deere 6500 model. I used to dread every day that I had to spray with the Deere because my back, head, shoulders and everything hurt by the end of the day. This machine makes spraying fun.

“My 2009 Powermate 6800W generator is my worst buy. I used this generator to provide power at home during an ice storm, but it worked for only a couple of hours before it broke down. The next time I used the generator it quit after only 20 minutes.”

Best Buy

Ram 3500 trucks equipped

Dale Duke, Grand Saline, Texas · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 12

“My son and I both have 2007 Dodge Ram 3500 trucks equipped with flat beds and the Cummins 6.7-liter diesel engine. My son’s truck got some water in the fuel so we took it to the local Dodge dealer, who estimated repair costs for six fuel injectors plus some other lines, at $12,600. Instead, I had the truck handled to a local fuel injection repair shop, and they replaced the injectors and lines at a cost of $4,925, installing new Bosch injectors.

“I was told this truck model was factory supplied with an 8-micron filter, even though the fuel injection system has 2-micron clearance. I believe this is still the case when you buy the Dodge filter. I believe it’s the same for the 2008 and 2009 models, too.

“The fuel injection repair shop installed a Racor brand (Parker) filter/coalescer in-line on the inside of the left frame rail, just behind the cab, which protects down to two microns. It also has water absorption capabilities as well as a clear bowl on the bottom, so I can visually check on it. It cost $198 installed.

“In the midst of this situation I found out that some insurance companies will cover damage caused by contaminated fuel. Unfortunately, when our insurance investigator came to the repair shop, I’m told he pulled a sample from fuel that had been pulled days earlier. Water is heavier than diesel so, guess what? The insurance sample tested insignificant for water content.

“To summarize, if you own a similar truck, consider getting an in-line filter that will actually protect your engine. Buy your fuel from a reputable source. Know exactly where and when you took on fuel. Find out what your insurance covers and how to preserve the evidence.”

Best Buy

Mahindra 2615 tractor equipped

Ken Wilkes, Rosalia, Wash. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 12

Ken nominates his 2006 Mahindra 2615 tractor equipped with a front-end loader as his “best buy”. “We bought this small tractor to mow, till, and move dirt around our 3-acre property. We use multiple attachments on it including a backhoe. The tractor runs well and does a nice job handling the attachments. We’re well pleased with it.”

Worst Buy

John Deere 4110 tractor

James L. Laster, Kathleen, Ga. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 12

James has had problems with his 2000 Deere 4110 tractor. “The electronic dash control indicator has gone out twice. The park position gave out, which required work on the transmission, and the brakes locked up. A 1-way valve had to be installed in the fuel line to make the tractor start. All this happened with less than 600 hours on the tractor. The company wouldn’t help pay for the repairs.”

Worst Buy

Massey Ferguson tractors

Steven W. Lambright, Union Grove, N.C. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 13

“My father-in-law has 3 of the 300 series Massey tractors and they’re all kind of doggish, but the worst part is the transmission and dry clutch. The transmission on the 383 model stripped out second gear at about 2,500 hours, and the 399 model had something go through it which chipped one of the gears. But the 393 model was the worst because the reverse gear ground off at less than 2,000 hours. Also, it seems like all these tractors need to have the clutch changed every 2,000 to 2,500 hours.”

Best Buy

Kwik Whip cart

Fred Wheaton, Montour Falls, N.Y. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 13

“I like the Kwik Whip cart (lukeo@tds. net), which I purchased after reading about it in FARM SHOW. The idea is to clamp a weedeater to the cart and roll it around on wheels.”

Best Buy

Husqvarna 4817 zero turn riding + 1 more

Jerry Mathison, Astoria, S. Dak. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 13

“I’m well pleased with my Husqvarna 4817 zero turn riding mower equipped with a 17 hp Kohler Command engine. It does a super job of mowing.

“I like my Empire mower deck washer which was previously in FARM SHOW (ph 715 635-8197; www.empirewasher.com). It does a great job of cleaning the deck. It consists of a plastic tube with 3 nozzles and a hose coupler at one end. You connect the washer to a garden hose and slide it all the way under the deck. Then you turn on the water and also turn on the mower. It uses the vortex created by the mower’s rotating blades to clean the mower deck.”

Best Buy

Conklin

Leon Beiler, Narvon, Penn. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 13

Leon likes a caulking product from Conklin called 360-S urethane sealant (ph 800 888-8838; www.conklin.com). “I was having problems with our skylights leaking water in our home. Finally I contacted a local Conklin dealer and he recommended this sealant. Since then, no more leaks. Works great.”

Best Buy

New Holland 1525 tractor + 1 more

Derrick Caisse, Chaplin, Ct. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 13

Derrick likes his New Holland 1525 tractor. “It’s a smaller unit at 35 hp and has performed flawlessly. We have two other tractors that sit idle because this one outperforms both of them. It’s our go-to tractor now.

“My Ryobi 4-stroke weed trimmer developed an oil leak almost immediately after I bought it. The company replaced it with a factory refurbished unit, but it doesn’t run as good as the original model and now I’m stuck with it.”

Best Buy

Case IH 2394 tractor

Richard Schmid, Rankin, Ill. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 13

“I’ve had this tractor for a long time and it has done some heavy pulling,” says Richard about his 1986 Case IH 2394 tractor. “This tractor still has enough hydraulic power to run some of the latest model planters. Very few problems.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Deutz 4506 tractor + 1 more

William Peters, Coldwater, Mich. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 13

“My 1972 Deutz 4506 tractor has more than 5,500 hours on it but still runs great and has required only routine maintenance. We use it to pull our finishing mower and also to pull a 6-row corn planter. It’s easy on fuel.

“My 2007 Troy Bilt riding mower equipped with a 22 hp engine was one of my worst buys ever. I had two of these mowers and both had problems. I had the first one for 6 weeks and it wouldn’t shut off even after the key was turned off so we had to disconnect the battery. We sent it back twice for repairs but the problem was never fixed. They gave me a new mower but by then it was late fall so we couldn’t use it, and then by the time we could use it the warranty had expired.

“The machine only has 35 hours on it and already I’ve had to replace the variable speed pulley and belt. After that we could only get half the speed out of it, even when we held the accelerator pedal down to the floor. The machine’s front end is shot, and the wheels flop in the breeze. When the belt pulley was replaced we almost had to take the engine out. This machine should have been painted lemon yellow. We’ll never buy a Troy Bilt again.”

Worst Buy

Ram 2500 4-WD pickup

Robert Mahaney, Dansville, N.Y. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 13

“My 2004 Dodge 2500 4-WD pickup was my worst buy. It had a death wobble to it every time I hit a bump. I bought it new along with 10 other new Dodge pickups and 5 Dodge minivans, over a 20-year period. Neither the dealer nor the company would do anything to fix the problem even though the pickup was still under warranty. Now I own a 2008 Ford F-350 pickup, and my wife has a 2007 Toyota van. Problem solved.”

Best Buy

Ram 2500 pickup equipped

Del Bigelow, Sandy, Utah · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 13

Del’s had good luck with his 2001 Dodge 2500 pickup equipped with a 5.9-liter Cummins diesel and a 5-speed manual transmission. “It has 125,000 miles on it with absolutely no problems and still has the original battery. I recently made a 1,100-mile trip to Arizona and averaged 23 mpg going 60 to 65 mph. It averages 17 to 18 mpg around town. This pickup has never failed to start, even in temperatures down to 10 degrees below zero.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Chevrolet S-10 Blazer 2 + 1 more

Blane Cornell, Malta, Mont. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 13

“I bought a 1993 Chevrolet S-10 Blazer 2 years ago with about 105,000 miles on it. I’ve since put on another 60,000 miles with only routine maintenance. I’ve replaced the batteries and unplugged the EGR valve a couple of times. It has a 2-battery system with an inverter.

“My Cummins 6827 electric impact wrench is my worst buy. I tried using it to remove a harmonic balancer bolt on a Toyota, but the bolt wouldn’t budge. I had to remove it by hand with a 1/2-in. breaker bar. Then I tried using it to change a tire on a Deere tractor, but it wouldn’t work on that either. It’s supposed to have 240 ft. lbs. of torque, but it’s not even close to that.”

Best Buy

John Deere 4960 tractors + 1 more

Bibb Mims, Uriah, Ala. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 13

“We own three Deere 4960 tractors with a total of 8,000 hrs. on them, with very few repairs. These tractors are economical to maintain, and they don’t have any electronic controls to go wrong as on the newer tractors.

“I also own two Deere 8420 tractors and two 8520’s. They all have push button electronic controls, which I think was a big mistake. We’ve had lots of trouble with them. Someone needs to make a good manually-controlled big tractor.”

Worst Buy

Husqvarna chainsaw never fails + 1 more

Steve Hafelein, Beaverton, Mich. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 13

“My Husqvarna chainsaw never fails to start and has a lot of power.

“My Big Buddy propane heater is my worst buy. I bought it to provide temporary heat in my RV. Unfortunately, the heater scorched the inlay floor in front of the heater, and the floor started to smoke. I contacted the company several times about the problem and they finally sent a new heater, but it did the same thing. They said they’d take care of the damage to the floor, but they never did.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 1070 tractor + 1 more

Richard Redinger, Dallas, Ore. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 13

“My Deere 1070 tractor has done everything I’ve asked it to do, and more.

“My Poulan chainsaw equipped with a 14-in. bar is my worst buy. I bought it because I wanted to finish clearing brush in my pasture. I pulled on it several times but couldn’t get it started. When I read the instructions I found there’s a series of events that must happen before the saw will start. So I took it back and bought a Husqvarna.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ram 2500 + 1 more

Elmer Hoover, Bethel, Penn. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 13

“It’s a dependable pickup with few problems,” says Elmer about his 2002 Dodge 2500. “I put a new pump in it at about 40,000 miles, which was covered by the warranty.

“Cooper tires are my worst buy. The tread peeled off, which resulted in damage to my vehicle. I thought maybe it was just my bad luck. But a friend also put new Cooper tires on his van, and it wasn’t long before two of them started coming apart.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

John Deere 5045E 4-WD tractor equipped + 2 more

Rick Baker, Cullman, Ala. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 13

“My 2010 Deere 5045E 4-WD tractor equipped with a front-end loader is easy to operate, dependable, and has a good selection of ground speeds. It’s also easy on fuel.”

On the negative side, he lists his Shindaiwa chainsaw. “The bolts on the bar clamp are soft and strip the threads easily, and replacing them requires separating the engine block. I threw away a saw with less than 5 hrs. on it, as the dealer I bought it from went out of business shortly after I bought it. I went back to using my 25-year-old Poulan Pro 395, which is a heavy but dependable chainsaw.”

Best Buy

Toyota pickup equipped

John Kaelin, LaGrange, Ky. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 14

“Three years ago I paid $1,800 for a used 1988 Toyota pickup equipped with a 22R engine and 4-speed transmission. It had about 58,000 miles when I bought it but now has more than 130,000 miles, and I haven’t done anything to it. It gets 29 mpg. Over the years, I could have sold this pickup several times for more than what I paid for it. I’m 60 years old now and I want to see which lasts longer, me or the pickup.”

Best Buy

747 ultra welding rods + 2 more

Titus H. Zimmerman, Shippensburg, Penn. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 14

Titus likes the 747 ultra welding rods he bought from United Alloy Research and Development (ph 800 356-9353; www.unitedalloysrd.com). “These rods are designed for high strain welds and make an amazingly strong welds. We’ve been using them for a number of years now and have hardly ever broken a weld. The rods are too expensive to use on just anything, so we keep a box or 2 on hand and only use them where we really need them. Applications for these rods include: spring steel, tool steel, castings, manganese steel, stainless steel, dissimilar metals, and structural steel.

“Also on the best buy side, our Drill Doctor drill bit sharpener has been trouble-free and does a great job.”

Best Buy

Dynamark riding mower

Lee Shepherd, Wabash, Ind. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 14

“My best buy ever was a 1990’s Dynamark riding mower, which I bought used at a garage sale with a blown Tecumseh engine. The guy who owned it was asking $50 for it. Luckily, I had a good 12 hp Briggs & Stratton engine in my garage so I asked him if he would take $20 for it. Long story short, I was driving this mower around the very next day.”

Best Buy

New Holland TJ 325 4-WD tractor + 2 more

Jerry Webb, Harrold, S. Dak. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 14

“I really like the 16-speed powershift transmission on my 2006 New Holland TJ 325 4-WD tractor.

“My 2006 Komatsu 146 WB backhoe is a joy to operate and uses little fuel. Both machines are real workhorses.

“My 2009 Speedway series 125 amp wire welder never worked right from day one. I talked to the company’s customer service people 6 different times and heard a dozen different reasons why they wouldn’t honor the warranty. They even told me they would send a replacement unit, but they never did.”

Best Buy

Kubota L185D tractor

Harold McKee, Athens, Ala. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 14

“We use our 1980 Kubota L185D tractor to handle big loads, such as pulling a 5-ft. Bush Hog and a 90-in. finish mower. It’s no problem for this fine, small tractor. We also use it with a box scraper and rotary tiller in our garden. My granddaughter now lays claim to this tractor.”

Best Buy

Kubota 18 hp tractor

Roger Blum, York, Neb. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 14

“My 1978 Kubota 18 hp tractor is a best buy. I replaced the fuel injectors and a U-joint and went through about 5 sets of tires. In 2006 I bought a Kubota 4610 tractor equipped with a frontend loader and use it with a roto-tiller and shredder. I use this tractor every day to take care of a large garden and some cattle.”

Best Buy

Toyota Tercel equipped + 1 more

Gary Alford, Edwardsburg, Mich. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 14

Gary’s impressed with his 1992 Toyota Tercel equipped with a 1.5-liter engine and 5-speed manual transmission. “I paid $250 for this car, which had a rod out and 130,000 miles when I bought it. I spent $1,100 rebuilding the engine, which gets 35 to 45 mpg, depending on the weather. The car now has about 165,000 miles on it.

“My Ford Ranger pickup equipped with a 4.0-liter engine gets 16 to 20 mpg, which I think is pretty good. It has saved me a lot of money on fuel. I like not being tied to the gas pump whenever I go somewhere.

“Years ago we bought 4 Deere HPX 4-WD Gators equipped with Kawasaki gas engines where I work. The engines are very cold blooded, even when it’s 90 degrees outside. Deere tried to fix the problem but couldn’t. Their new Gators are now equipped with electronic fuel injection, which solves the problem. However, anyone who has the old carburetor-style engine is out of luck.”

Best Buy

Honda 4-Trax 300 4-wheeler + 2 more

J.D. Lyall, Tonkawa, Okla. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 14

“My 1987 Honda 4-Trax 300 4-wheeler always starts and has been trouble-free. I’ve replaced just the tires. I use this machine to check 10 miles of electric fence. I mounted a 25-gal. sprayer on the rear rack so I can spray fence rows and corners and along roadsides. It has been a perfect vehicle for all these years.”

On the “worst buy” side, “My 18-volt Black & Decker ‘Fire Storm’ cordless drill works well on small jobs. However, the batteries don’t last long enough to get much done. Also, it’s hard to find new batteries and they’re expensive. Another problem is the chuck falls off if I even barely touch the release, which is poorly placed. I plan to throw this unit away and go back to DeWalt. Their cordless drills cost more, but they last.”

Best Buy

Cub Cadet model 1904 riding

Robert Frommeyer, New London, Ohio · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 14

“I haven’t had one minute of trouble with it,” reports Robert about his Cub Cadet model 1904 riding mower equipped with a 46-in. deck. “I use it to mow 5 acres of American Legion property, plus my own. I’m 72 years young and have had a lot of riding mowers over the years. This Cub Cadet is almost as good as my old Bolens 1220. That tractor was so strong it could have pulled a house down if it had enough traction.”

Worst Buy

Northern Tool

Patricia Peacock, Sulphur Springs, Texas · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 14

“The dual head turbo propane torch I bought from Northern Tool is my worst buy. I couldn’t get the torch to work so I kept sending it back for a new one. They made me pay to send it back after the first one. Now I’m on my third model, which if I sent it back in exchange for another, will have cost me $69. That’s way more than the $39.99 I paid for the original tool. But the company won’t refund my money unless I pay to ship this model back. I won’t buy anything from them again.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Tracfone cell phone + 1 more

Robert A. Smalley, Colon, Mich. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 14

“I like my Tracfone cell phone (www.tracfone.com). I tried 3 other ‘major’ cell phone services, but none of them worked as well as this one. It has fewer dropped calls and no monthly charges. I’m well pleased with it.

“My 2008 Cleary pole barn was comparatively expensive but the workmanship very poor. The doors don’t close tight, condensation drips from the ceiling, and the steel roof lets all the snow slide off at once. The company did come out and repair whatever they could.”

Best Buy

Leatherman Wave pocket multitool

Chriss Stutzman, Port Washington, Ohio · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 14

“My Leatherman Wave pocket multitool has a lot of useful features and is built with quality. It’s made from stainless steel and provides access to 4 locking blades without opening the tool. The tool has 18 features in all and comes with a 25-year guarantee. It lives in my pocket and goes everywhere with me. Excellent company service.”

Best Buy

John Deere 5205 tractor equipped + 1 more

Gary E. Havens, Frankfort, Ohio · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 14

“This is one tough little tractor. No problems,” says Gary about his 2005 Deere 5205 tractor equipped with a 522 front-end loader.

“My 2009 Deere 5093E Limited tractor has had two problems in the first 100 hrs. First, the cab doors don’t fit right. The dealer tried to adjust the doors but they’re still cracked at the bottom. Second, a throttle linkage problem made the engine surge up and down. The dealer installed a new throttle linkage, which helped.”

Best Buy

Gerard steel roofing

Jerry Berdell, Odin, Minn. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 14

Two years ago Jerry had Gerard steel roofing installed on his house and says he’s well pleased with it (www.gerardusa.com). “No more asphalt shingles to replace ever again. I rate this product a 10 out of 10.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Kubota L-3400 tractor + 1 more

Thomas Gould, Bigfoot, Texas · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 14

“My 2007 Kubota L-3400 tractor is quiet, fuel efficient, easy to operate, and well-built. It has incredible power for such a small tractor.

“My Cub Cadet riding mower is my worst buy. Replacing the battery is a difficult job. Also, the paint falls off, the wiring system is a nightmare, and I had to redesign the drive belt guards on the deck. Another problem is I can’t change the engine oil without making a mess.”

Best Buy

Ford Model T Roadster car + 1 more

Glenn Fisher, Homer, Ga. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 14

“My 1924 Ford Model T Roadster car is a best buy. My dad bought it for me in 1952 when I was beginning to learn to drive. I was going to soup up the engine and make a hot rod out of it, but I grew to like this car so much that I decided not to. Dad paid $30 cash for the car. If Ford ever makes another vehicle as good as this one, I’ll buy it.

“My 1984 Nissan extended cab 4-WD pickup runs great. It’s equipped with a 4-cyl. engine and 5-speed transmission, and has plenty of power to pull a 22-ft. livestock trailer. I’d probably buy another Nissan if the company ever brings its 4-WD diesel pickups into the U.S.”

Best Buy

Uni Hydro 42-14 ironworker

Dale Martin, Cosmos, Minn. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 14

“It’s the most versatile shop tool I’ve ever owned,” says Dale about his Uni Hydro 42-14 ironworker (www.unihydro.com). “I use it to cut, punch, and bend metal and to do many other jobs. It cuts my repair time in half and works great. After 20 years of use it’s still worth within about $500 of a new one.”

Best Buy

Sears 8 hp tree branch

Carl Goetz, Woodland, Wash. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 14

“My Sears 8 hp tree branch chipper works great for shredding aluminum pop cans. I just tie a porous 50-lb. feed bag over the chipper’s outlet chute and then drop the cans into the hopper. Hundreds of shredded cans will fit into a single feed bag, which I then haul to a local recycler. There’s no mess at all. It’s a handy way to get rid of cans and is a lot easier than crushing them by hand.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

McCullough 12-volt cordless drill + 1 more

Charles Nevills, Worthington, Ind. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 14

“My McCullough 12-volt cordless drill didn’t work well when I bought it, but a factory rep replaced it free of charge. The new drill works great.

“My Crosley refrigerator is my worst buy. It caused nothing but trouble so I traded it back to the dealer for a used Whirlpool model.

“My Crosley front load washer and dryer are also worst buys. The washer is poorly designed. For example, I have to leave the door open or the washer will activate by itself in stormy weather. Also, mold and mildew are constant problems.”

Best Buy

Cracked Heel

Joseph Smyly, Duchesne, Utah · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 15

Joseph likes to use a skin softener called Cracked Heel by Blue Goo that’s sold at WalMart. “My hands crack badly in winter or whenever I wash them a lot,” says Smyly. “I’m especially prone to multiple cracks on my fingertips. I’ve tried everything to heal or prevent the cracks, but Cracked Heel is by far the best product I’ve used. It’s made from emu oil, of all things. If my hands start feeling like they’re going to develop cracks, I just rub on a little lotion and the cracks never show up. If I forget to apply the salve and they get cracked, it quickly heals them.”

Best Buy

Whirlwind knife 8 + 1 more

Tommy Scott, Goldthwaite, Texas · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 15

“My cousin gave me his used Whirlwind knife 8 years ago and I really like it. Since then, I’ve purchased 3 more Whirlwind knives. I even had to buy my wife one so I could keep mine! Last June an assist spring broke on the knife my cousin gave me, but the company is sending me a new spring free of charge. Great customer service.

“We bought a new Henry Golden Boy .22 rifle and noticed the dovetail for the rear sight was milled wrong. I called the company and they sent a prepaid box for me to mail the rifle to them. Then they fixed the rifle and sent it back – all at no charge to me. It’s a great rifle – our kid’s favorite – and is accurate. I installed a large-loop lever on the rifle to fit my big hands. Another company with great customer service.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Tom Tom XL GPS car navigation device + 2 more

Dan L. Edens, Ogema, Wis. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 15

“I like my 2010 Tom Tom XL GPS car navigation device sold by Dell (www.tomtom.com). Not only does it provide exact directions, but also when I called the company for help I was able to speak to an American who spoke good English, not someone in India that I couldn’t understand.

“My Harmon PF 100 pellet burning furnace is a worst buy. Sometimes it ‘forgets’ to ignite so my house gets cold. When that happens I have to go into the basement, turn the power off and on, and then it remembers its job. It’s poorly designed for clean-out which is a lengthy, messy job. I wrote to the company and told them I could redesign the furnace so it worked better, but they never replied.

“My idea is to install a second ash pan below the heat exchangers, then cut the back end off the pans so they become an ash scoop. Then install a Y-shaped pipe and use a Venturi system for the combustion blower. This would eliminate having to remove the combustion blower and clean the blades with a toothbrush. It would cut cleaning time from 2 hours down to 15 minutes or so.

“My Whirpool Ultimate Care II washing machine is a worst buy. We have to fill the machine manually from a hose in order to get the right water temperature. The machine hasn’t worked right since I bought it.”

Best Buy

Montana 4344 utility tractor

Darry Markle, Peace River, Alta. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 15

A 2009 Montana 4344 utility tractor rates as Darry’s “best buy”. “I’ve always been skeptical of low-cost imports, but so far this imported tractor has been terrific. It’s made in South Korea and powered by a Mitsubishi 4-cyl., 41 hp diesel engine. It has a lot of nice features including a beefy front-end loader, front wheel assist, a 16-speed transmission, tilt steering, shuttle shift transmission, live pto, and differential lock. It also has ag tires, a tight turning radius, smooth hydraulics, and the operator’s platform is obstruction-free with well-located controls.”

Best Buy

Just For Copper

Bob Kohrs, Frontenac, Minn. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 15

Bob’s impressed with Just For Copper, a solderless copper bonding agent for copper tubing (ph 866 304-5335; www.justforcopper.com). The product permits the bonding of copper-to-copper and copper-to-brass, without having to use solder or heat.

The company says it’s a fast and easy way to plumb with copper as there’s no risk of fire and no special skill is needed. They claim the product results in a “100 percent perfect bond” every time.

“I bought Just For Copper at my local farm store. It sure beats using a torch and solder,” says Kohrs. “It sets up in 10 seconds and cures in just 1 minute. No leaks yet.”

Worst Buy

John Deere L110 riding mower

Ron Hall, Colville, Wash. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 15

Ron’s unhappy with his Deere L110 riding mower and dump-style yard cart. “After cutting grass for years with a Yardman riding mower, I decided to upgrade to Deere. What a joke. I bought the mower with a mulching kit, but it just makes a big mess. I bought a bagger to use with it, but it plugs up something awful. I had to use my $50 Big R sweeper to clean up the mess. I put the bagged material in the dump cart, and the cart works great until I try to dump it. It won’t tip back far enough to dump. I don’t think it could dump a load of water!

“The engine on this machine runs fine, but it gets so hot under the hood that the headlight brackets and wiring melted.”

Worst Buy

Poulan Wild

Jeff Rhinehart, Eldred, Pa. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 15

“My Poulan ‘Wild Thing’ chainsaw is my worst buy. I wanted to give my father a great 75th birthday present by buying him a new chainsaw. Home Depot had the Poulan model on sale so I bought it. In hindsight, a double-bladed ax and a crosscut saw would have been less work for him and caused him less frustration. Poulan tried to shift the blame to everyone, including my father for ‘misusing’ the saw, and they also blamed the suppliers of the plastic gears, the repairman and the repair shop.

“The whole process just reinforces the wisdom of buying from a company that services its products and not from the big box stores. Now my father is back to using his old chainsaw. Maybe I can try for a nice Christmas gift this year by getting a Stihl.”

Best Buy

McCormick 4-WD tractor equipped + 3 more

Elmer R. Carter, Harleton, Texas · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 15

“In 2006 I bought a new McCormick 4-WD tractor equipped with a 70 hp Perkins diesel engine. I also bought an Agmeier 150 hp Bush Hog (ph 800 446-7319; www.ag-meier.net) to use with it. Both machines work great.

“At the same time I bought a Westendorf TA 26 front-end loader, which has been nothing but trouble from day one. The bucket’s hydraulic cylinders were weak. The dealer replaced them immediately but the cylinders still leak even after they were repacked 3 times. Last year I sent the company a certified letter asking them to replace the bucket cylinders, but the letter was returned 2 months later, unclaimed. Then I sent the letter by regular mail, but I’m still waiting for a reply.

“I recently added 4 bottles of SealLube to the cylinders, which slowed down the leakage a little. One of the cylinders has always shown heavy rust streaks on it. I would’ve expected this company to stand behind its products and at least reply to a customer. On the plus side, the loader itself is built heavy.”

Best Buy

John Deere 4440 tractor

Lynn Kidwell, Bloomington, Ill. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 15

“I bought a used 1980 Deere 4440 tractor with about 7,000 hrs. on it, and the first year I had to replace both wheel rims. Also, the hydraulic pump leaked, and the top of the radiator expanded. At 8,200 hrs., a bearing on the transmission’s low range went out, and the transmission wouldn’t shift into any gear. To fix these problems I had to spend $4,400 worth on parts and $3,800 on labor. Also, the lines on the air conditioner rusted out, and I had to rebuild all three of the tractor’s hydraulic couplers.”

Worst Buy

John Deere L130 riding mower

Dale Schmidt, Standish, Mich. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 15

Dale’s disappointed with his 2003 Deere L130 riding mower. “I bought this mower thinking it would work better than others in its price range, but I was wrong. From day one, it wouldn’t cut without plugging up. I replaced self-tapping screws in the deck so now I can mow my yard and only have to clean off the deck 2 or 3 times. This machine isn’t even worth looking at.

“I’m disappointed with Deere as a company. For example, I was in the market for a new brush cutter this year. Deere’s MX6 model is made in Spain. Instead, I bought a Great Plains model that’s made in Kansas and is built much better. Too bad this great American company is selling out.”

Best Buy

Geo Prizm

Jimmy Stewart, Albany, Ohio · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 15

Jimmy nominates his 1995 Geo Prizm as his “best buy”. “I bought this car new in July 1995. This summer it hit 500,000 miles. I’m a state senator in southeast Ohio, and this car has survived 7 election campaigns plus 3 1/2 years selling Caterpillar equipment, with trips to Omaha, New Orleans, Key West, Florida, and Washington, D.C. It gets about 34 mpg and I still drive it every day.

“I replaced the car’s original engine at 468,200 miles. I found a low mileage engine that cost less than the valve job the original engine would have needed. Even so, that engine was still running and had compression nearly as good as the factory specs. I plan to keep the car a while longer – I just put new 80,000-mile warranty tires on it.”

Best Buy

Jet equipment manufactured

Nick Neuburger, Gait, Calif. · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 15

“I’ve had great success with two pieces of Jet equipment manufactured in Taiwan (ph 615 793-8900; www.jettools.com). One is a 10-in. table saw, and the other a metal lathe. Both machines are accurate, easy to use, built sturdy, and easy to clean. The parts are made of cast steel and aluminum, not plastic.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Ford tractors + 1 more

Charlie Brattan, Albuquerque, New Mexico · Vol. 34, No. 5 (2010), p. 15

“Over the years I’ve owned 3 Ford tractors that were best buys, all equipped with 4-cyl. diesel engines. They included a 1959 model 601, a 1962 model 801, and a 1986 model 5900.

“My worst buy ever was a 1990 Massey Ferguson 231 tractor. It had electrical problems. Also, the valve stems on the tires rotted off after 2 years, and the 3-pt. hydraulics were slow and jerky. After 200 hrs. of misery I finally sold it.”