Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › John Deere › 4230

John Deere 4230 tractor

What FARM SHOW readers say · 8 Best Buys2 Worst Buys · Tractors

John Deere 4230 tractor

8 Best Buys2 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Glen Grice, Beechy, Sask. · Vol. 28, No. 5 (2004), p. 13

“I’m generally satisfied with my 1994 Deere 8760 tractor.

“My 1974 Deere 4230 tractor has more than 11,000 hours on it but still works great. It has never needed a major repair.”

Best Buy
Walter Baldner, Jr., Austin, Minn. · Vol. 23, No. 2 (1999), p. 16

“Our ‘best buy’ is a Deere 4230 tractor we purchased new in 1973. We overhauled the engine at 8,640 hours and it now has about 12,400 on it. We installed 50 series pistons when we overhauled the engine so it starts easily in cold weather. We use the tractor for all our spraying and snow-plowing, and the pto works well to fill our grain dryer with our 10 by 16-in. auger.”

Best Buy
Parkes Richardson, Lawrenceburg, Tenn. · Vol. 23, No. 1 (1999), p. 16

“It’s the best tractor we’ve ever owned,” says Parkes about his Deere 4230. “We bought it used in 1972 from a Texas horse farm and have had to make only a few small repairs on it.”

Worst Buy
Rondel Murray, Carroll, Iowa · Vol. 22, No. 5 (1998), p. 15

Rondel has had few problems with his 1976 Deere 4230. “I like the power shift transmission and cab. It starts well in the coldest weather and offers good fuel economy,” he says. “I only wish I could find a new command arm, like those on the 8000 series Deeres, installed. I hope Deere or someone else comes up with a retrofit kit.”

Rondell added a Buckeye front 3-pt. hitch to his tractor for hauling hay, spraying and blading. He also installed a factory turbocharger to increase torque and improve fuel economy.

Best Buy
Elvin P. Graybill, Nottingham, Pa. · Vol. 21, No. 6 (1997), p. 16

“My best buy is my Deere 4230 tractor which I bought used six years ago. It works fine and is big enough to handle a chisel plow, yet nimble enough to handle a Haybine.” Paul and Karen Dotterer, Union

Worst Buy
Warren Wing, Newkirk, Okla · Vol. 19, No. 6 (1995), p. 16

Warren Wing, Newkirk, Okla.: “My worst buy is my Deere 4230 tractor, It worked alright for light work such as baling, swathing, planting, etc., but used a lot of fuel even on light loads. The dealer's mechanic got it up to 100 hp, barely, but it still wouldn't pull my 4-bottom plow. It always ran hot and the 3-pt. hydraulics never worked right. Also, it ate up a lot of fuel. Deere really goofed when they replaced the 4020 with this model.”

Best Buy
Gene Eckmann, Bloomfield, Neb · Vol. 19, No. 5 (1995), p. 15

Gene Eckmann, Bloomfield, Neb.: “My 1989 Deere 185-hydro lawn mower is my all-time worst buy. bought it used four years ago for $2,500. After a short period of time it started using a quart of oil every time we mowed. The 17 hp engine was completely overhauled, but then it wouldn't start. It mows the lawn unevenly, leaving strips between the blades. The front axle assembly fell off and it took an entire day to put it back on because two small bolts were located in a hard-to-reach position, The next time we used it, the engine leaked a quart of oil and started making a clanging noise like it was going to throw a rod. I'm disappointed with this product and feel that the cost of parts and repair work is too high. I plan to replace it. “My best buy is my 1973 Ford F-100 pickup equipped with a 390 cu, in. engine, It's on its second engine and runs like a charm, It’s the most reliable vehicle on our farm.” John D, Parker, Gates, N.C.; “Llike my Deere 4230 tractor. It has 10,000 hours on it and the engine has never been overhauled.”

Best Buy
Harold Nold, Oconee, Ill. · Vol. 19, No. 5 (1995), p. 15

Harold Nold, Oconee, Ill.: “My best buys are my 1975 Deere 4230 tractor, 1968 Deere 2510 tractor, and 1990 Remlinger RTC-600 M-roller tine cultivator. No down time on any of them.”

Best Buy
Glen Grice, Beechy, Sask · Vol. 19, No. 4 (1995), p. 14

Glen Grice, Beechy, Sask.: Glen has over 5,000 hours on his “best buy” 1974 Deere 4230 tractor. “It still has the original alternator which has never been repaired. I’ve never had any trouble with the engine or transmission, It’s a real workhorse.”

Best Buy
Mary Riemenapp, Dodgeville, Wis. · Vol. 15, No. 5 (1991), p. 14

Mary Riemenapp, Dodgeville, Wis.: “We can depend on our 1977 Deere 4230 tractor to perform in the field or do any job. It very seldom needs major repairs. It's handy and tough.”

Own a John Deere? Tell FARM SHOW how it’s held up.

Your report could appear in a future issue.

Send your Best or Worst Buy

More John Deere products

John Deere 1780 split-row 2 best · 1 worstJohn Deere 4240 tractor 14 best · 1 worstJohn Deere 720 diesel 3 best · 0 worstJohn Deere M tractor 2 best · 1 worstJohn Deere L110 lawn tractor 1 best · 1 worstJohn Deere 3025E tractor 2 best · 0 worstJohn Deere 3020 diesel 16 best · 0 worstJohn Deere gas tractor 46 best · 5 worstJohn Deere 4020 diesel 62 best · 3 worstJohn Deere 1023E tractor with backhoe 1 best · 2 worstJohn Deere 2025R tractor 4 best · 0 worstJohn Deere 9300 tractor 2 best · 1 worstJohn Deere 110 garden tractor 11 best · 2 worstJohn Deere Gator 6x4 2 best · 0 worstJohn Deere 6400 tractor 15 best · 0 worstJohn Deere 4320 compact tractor 6 best · 2 worstJohn Deere 8120 tractor 2 best · 0 worstJohn Deere 425 garden tractor 16 best · 5 worstJohn Deere 955 tractor 1 best · 1 worstJohn Deere lawn mower 12 best · 2 worst

See all John Deere reports →