Scag: what farmers say
18 reports in FARM SHOW · 17 Best Buys1 Worst Buy
Scag zero-turn lawn mower
4 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“Both my Scag zero-turn lawn mower and Gravely ATV do a good job and I’ve had no trouble with either. We usually mow three acres or more twice a week.
“I also have several 2-cyl. Deere tractors and they run perfectly.”
“In 2004 I bought a used 2002 Scag mower. I’ve used it every summer to cut 6 to 8 acres of grass and have replaced only the blade clutch. These mowers are pricey but work great.
“My 2006 Jinma tractor equipped with a 35 hp., 4-cyl. diesel engine is my worst buy. The first day I tried to use it one of the tie rods fell off. The tractor leaks oil everywhere and runs hot when bush hogging. Now I can’t find parts for it, as the dealer I bought it from went out of business.”
“I’ve abused this mower but it still runs great,” says Don about his 1990 Scag 52-in. riding mower (Scag Power Equipment, Mayville, Wis.; www.scag.com).
“My 1980 Scag 48-in. walk-behind mower, which I bought used 10 years ago, is my best buy (www.scag.com). All I’ve ever had to replace was a $2 spring. This rig has reduced my mowing time by more than half. It’s really maneuverable - I can go right around a 1-in. dia. pipe - which eliminates the need for a trimming mower. I’m confident I’ll never have to buy another mower.
“My 1982 Dodge Rampage mini pickup is my worst buy. I bought it because it was made from galvanized sheet metal. However, the paint started flaking off just two weeks after I bought it. The dealer repainted it for me, but by four years later the pickup had rusted out so bad that it wasn’t even safe to drive. I had to junk it with only 42,000 miles on it. During that time I also had to replace the front brakes four times. I really like the way the new Dodge pickups look, but after this experience I’ll never buy another Dodge again.”
Scag Tiger Cub riding mower
2 Best Buys0 Worst Buys“I’ve had several best buys over the years including my 2005 Scag Tiger Cub riding mower with 48-in. cut, 19-hp. Kawasaki and flotation seat. It has 1,800 hrs. and is the best mower I’ve owned from the ages of 18 to 80. I cut yard grass, roadsides, tall fescue, and even a few corn stalks. It’s rugged and has very low maintenance costs. It burns no engine oil and has no leaks. I reset the engine governor from 3,600 rpm’s to 3,400 rpm’s to extend engine life. I use Shell Rotella 15W-40 in the engine and Amsoil in the hydraulic system. I grease the spindles per the manual and have never replaced one yet. I’ve only replaced a few drive belts and a few tension springs. Highly recommended.
“My Deere L118 42-in. cut riding mower with Briggs engine is the worst mower I’ve ever owned. It only has 400 hrs. and if you name it, it’s either broken or required a high-cost repair. It’s been to the dealer several times. It costs a fortune, and it’s never fixed. The engine intermittently or continuously misfires even though the engine has been tuned up and the entire fuel system cleaned up by the Deere dealer. The front steering was misaligned and completely wore off the tread on the front tire’s outer edges. The engine leaks oil everywhere and burns oil. The deck is too shallow and misaligned. It won’t cut tall grass; it chokes, and the deck belts slip. The engine is difficult to start. Replaced the starter windings and voltage regulator several times. It burns way too much gasoline compared to my Honda and Scag riding mowers. The spindle bearings had to be replaced. The hydrostatic drive is jerky.”
“My 2006 Scag Tiger Cub zero turn riding mower equipped with a 23 hp Briggs & Stratton engine and 61-in. deck is my best buy (Scag Power Equipment, www.scag.com). It cuts well at about 10 mph, and the blades are easy to change. It’s also built heavy. I’ve already put about 125 hours on it with no problems.”
Scag (general)
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 2002 Kubota M9000 tractor handles great and has had no mechanical problems. It’s also easy on fuel.
“My 2007 Dodge 2500 pickup equipped with a Hemi V-8 engine rides rough and gets only 11 mpg. The dealer had led me to believe it would get 17 to 18 mpg because of the new technology that shuts down four cylinders when not needed, but it never did. I traded this pickup for a Ford F-150, which gets a more reasonable 16 mpg.
“My Ferris walk-behind mower never performed right and the company wouldn’t help in any way. I think Scag and Toro make the best lawn mowers.”
Scag Freedom zero-turn riding mower
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“It cuts faster and better than anything I’ve ever owned,” says Robert about his 2016 Scag Freedom zero-turn riding mower (www.scag.com). “This mower goes up hillsides where other mowers would just slip or stall, and it has heavy-duty blades so it can cut through taller grass, too. We have locust trees on our property so I put foam-filled tires on the mower to prevent flats.”
Scag Liberty 52 zero-turn mower
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“We suffer from chronic power outages. Our Generac dual-fuel 7500-watt generator has been a lifesaver. I bought the dual-fuel because it was in stock at the time. We had an outage that necessitated using all the gas we had but luckily, I had two 20-lb. propane bottles on hand that got us through. This generator starts every time on the first attempt and is efficient. Ten gals. of gas and 20 lbs. of propane got us through 2 1/2 days.
“I used my Scag Liberty 52 zero-turn mower for 2 hrs. and sold it. It was a $5,500 mower that wouldn’t cut grass. Any grass areas higher than 4-in. and the mower would just struggle to cut it, causing the mower to stall out every time. My Deere X320 was down because I needed a part. When I put the X320 back in service it mowed the same areas with ease. Scag offers a lot of hype, but they don’t live up to it when it comes to consumer products.”
Scag Liberty Z zero-turn mower equipped
0 Best Buys1 Worst Buy“It’s built rugged and never fails to start,” says Jim about his 2015 Scag Liberty Z zero-turn mower equipped with a 22 hp. Kohler engine and 48-in. deck. “We had some minor problems with contact switches. It has about 1,000 hrs. on it, and I’ve only replaced the blades twice.”
Scag Tiger 24 hp
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I couldn’t be happier with my 2008 Scag Tiger 24 hp Cub riding mower (www.scag.com). I use it six days a week, sun up to sun down, with no problems. All I have to do is change the oil. I’ve made a living off this mower, yet it still runs like the day I bought it.”
Scag Turf Tiger zero turn riding
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“They’re simply the best mowers on the market. No problems,” says Karl, pleased with his two 2008 Scag Turf Tiger 72-in. zero turn riding mowers (www.scag.com). “We use one model to mow 8 acres every 5 or 6 days from early spring to late fall. We use the other one to mow 50 to 60 lawns on a regular basis.”
Scag V Ride stand-on lawn mower
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysDavid’s impressed with his 2013 Scag V Ride stand-on lawn mower (www.scag.com). “I bought this mower as a demonstration model with 85 hrs. on it. It’s simple and easy to operate and cuts an hour off my mowing time. I think it’s the best mower on the market.
“I think BCS America makes the best rototiller (www.bcsamerica.com; ph 800 543-1040).”
Scag walk-behind mower equipped
1 Best Buy0 Worst BuysGary’s impressed with his 2012 Scag walk-behind mower equipped with a 16 hp. Briggs & Stratton engine and 48-in. deck. “My neighbor and I start mowing our 2-plus acre fields at the same time. I walk, and he uses a riding mower. He goes faster up and down the field, but I get done a half hour sooner because of the big deck.
“With multiple passes this mower will turn a hayfield into a lawn. By adjusting the position of four pins I can easily raise or lower the deck. The mower varies in speed from 2 to 6 mph. An optional attachment allows the operator to stand on a platform and ride behind the mower, allowing you to mow at 6 mph in the right conditions.”
Scag lawnmowers
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“FARM SHOW is my favorite best buy. I share it with my neighbor.
“My two 72-in. Scag lawnmowers are also best buys. We have lots of lawn, and these mowers have worked perfectly.
“My 2021 Toyota Prius is the second I’ve owned. It has 58,000 miles and gets 20 mpg. I couldn’t be more pleased.”
Scag zero turn riding
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“My 2000 Deere 4600 utility tractor is my worst buy. The body is made of a plastic type of material that’s falling apart at the hood, grill, cowl, and fuel filler cap. All these parts are either shattered or cracking and coming apart. I tried several times to get help from the company but with no luck.”
“My Scag zero turn riding mower cuts straight and level with no problems. It’s a best buy (Scag Power Equipment, Mayville, Wis. www.scag.com).”
Scag commercial zero turn
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I like my Scag commercial zero turn riding mower (www.scag.com). We use it to mow places where we previously used a tractor, and go 12 mph. It has more than 1,000 hrs. on it so far with no problems.”
Scag hydro-drive walk-behind
1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys“I like our Scag Hydro-drive, walk-behind 52-in. cut commercial mower (ph 888 905-7623; www.scag.com) and our Italian-made Grillo all-gear-drive 2-wheel tractor tiller (ph 503 675-9800; www.grillo-america.com/grillo. htm). Both are top quality machines that have required very little downtime. I operated BCS tillers for 38 years, but I think the Grillo beats the BCS in every way. The company offers more than 30 different attachments for this tractor, from plows to hay balers. Both tools are available from Earth Tools (ph 502 484-3988; www.earthtoolsbcs.com).”
Read every report in full
FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.