Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Brands › Red Wing

Red Wing: what farmers say

13 reports in FARM SHOW · 7 Best Buys7 Worst Buys

Red Wing work boots

3 Best Buys4 Worst Buys
Best Buy
David Cunningham, Tazwell, Tenn. · Vol. 37, No. 2 (2013), p. 15

“I work for our county road department and really like Red Wing work boots. They wear so well that I can go six years before I have to buy a new pair. These boots cost just a little over $100 but are worth it.”

Best Buy
Ben Parks, Austin, Texas · Vol. 36, No. 5 (2012), p. 15

“I’ve purchased 4 pairs of Red Wing boots over the past 15 years. I do a lot of walking at work but find these boots are hard to wear out. The heel, soles and leather hold up well and are practically indestructible.

“I recently purchased my second set of B.F. Goodrich all-terrain TA truck tires. The first set lasted 5 years and went more than 60,000 miles with no problems. In fact, they still had tread on them. The only reason I replaced them was because of weather-cracking between the treads.”

Worst Buy
Joseph E. Bruggeman, Taberg, N.Y. · Vol. 36, No. 4 (2012), p. 15

Joseph likes the 6 1/2 hp OHV horizontal shaft motor on his Harbor Freight wood splitter, for which he paid $99.99 plus tax. “I can start the motor with no more than 2 pulls and it’ll run all day on 1 1/2 to 2 tanks of gas, depending on how fast I set the throttle. I increase the engine rpm’s on bigger blocks of wood, but normally 3/4 throttle is all it needs.

“I’m not happy with the Red Wing insulated logger boots I bought 3 1/2 years ago. I’ve worn Red Wing logger boots for 30 years, but the last 2 pairs were bad. The laces lasted only 2 to 3 months and then I had to go back to buy more. The shoe’s eyelets chew the laces up. The boots cost more than $200 a pair, which I think is too much. I recently bought a pair of Carolina logger boots at a discount for only $85.”

Worst Buy
Craig Grodman, New Hampton, N.Y. · Vol. 31, No. 5 (2007), p. 14

“My 2005 Suzuki King Quad 700 4-wheeler works great in almost any kind of terrain, from woods to desert. I highly recommend this machine.”

On the negative side, “I purchased a pair of Red Wing high top boots last December, but by April the leather stitching had torn and the boots were totally useless and had to be thrown out. It was an expensive pair of boots, considering I was able to use them for only four months.”

Best Buy
Charles N. Rogers, Jr., Raleigh, N.C. · Vol. 24, No. 5 (2000), p. 14

“I’ve purchased many pairs of Red Wing boots over the years for myself, my wife, and my friends. They’ve always been of high quality. On the one occasion when I wasn’t satisfied, my local dealer provided an

Worst Buy
Larry W. Freeman, Newalla, Okla. · Vol. 23, No. 6 (1999), p. 14

“While reading the last issue of FARM SHOW I noticed that John Landreth of Durant, Okla., is disappointed with his Red Wing boots. I, too, have a pair of Red Wing shoes that I purchased at a cost of $130 last year. The leather cracked open after only three months, the soles came off after six months, and the heels came off a month later. I contacted the company but got the runaround for so long that I no longer even want to deal with them. I’m finding out there are lots of others in my area who have had the same experience. I’m sorry there are others who will have to find out about these shoes the hard way as Mr. Landreth and I have.

“Mr. Landreth also mentioned that his best buy was a T-Post Puller manufactured by U.S. Lever Mfg. from Newalla, Okla. He stated that the company was no longer in business. I’m the president and CEO of U.S. Lever Mfg. and we are still in business. However, we now build our products under a different name for several distributors in the U.S. You can buy our post puller at local farm and ranch stores or just write me and I’ll send him one of the original T-Post Pullers for $60, which includes shipping and handling (21401 S.E. 59th St., Newalla, Okla. 74857).

“I now lease out my farm but I still hang around my farm friends. We all read FARM SHOW and pretend we’re still the biggest farmers in the state. Your magazine has such good articles on how to build things for the farm that I wish I did still farm.”

Worst Buy
John D. Landreth, Durant, Okla. · Vol. 23, No. 5 (1999), p. 17

“I believe the worst pair of work shoes I’ve ever had is a pair of Red Wing boots made in Red Wing, Minn. They cost me $130 and only lasted 3 months before they cracked open at the toes. Then the front of the sole came off at 9 months. Red Wing refuses to do anything about them. They said “They weren’t properly taken care of”. Well, I’ve had lots of other boots and I didn’t baby them and regularly get as much as 6 years out of them. I’ll never buy Red Wings again.”

“One of the best buys I ever made was a T-post puller made by a company called U.S. Lever in Newalla, Okla., that was originally featured in FARM SHOW (Vol. 17, No. 4). Unfortunately, I don’t think they’re in business anymore but they should be because this post puller is the best I’ve ever had or seen. It never bends the post and shows no wear despite a lot of use. I’ve pulled thousands of posts with it. Someone should pick up this design and run with it.”

Red Wing work shoes

2 Best Buys2 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Robert Knight, Leetonia, Ohio · Vol. 50, No. 4 (2026), p. 15

“My Red Wing work shoes are well made, and my feet and back don’t hurt after a long day. I’ve worn this brand for years and will wear nothing else.”

Best Buy
Stan McCarthy, Columbia, Mo. · Vol. 25, No. 5 (2001), p. 14

“I like the Red Wing steel-toe shoes I bought in 1999. I’ve worn them almost every day and they’ve held up better than any other shoes I’ve ever owned. I’ve read reports in FARM SHOW from other readers who are unhappy with Red Wings, but I’ll buy another pair of shoes when these wear out.”

Worst Buy
Henry C. Letellier, Greybull, Wyo. · Vol. 24, No. 6 (2000), p. 16

Henry rates Red Wing shoes as his “worst buy.” “The shoes warped in the toe area so that I couldn’t wear them. The dealer sent them back to the company, but they said it wasn’t their problem and offered no solution or service.”

Worst Buy
Keith E. Haynes, Enoree, S.C. · Vol. 24, No. 2 (2000), p. 15

“Recently there have been ‘worst buy’ reports in FARM SHOW about Red Wing shoes. I’ve always had outstanding service from these shoes. They last about three times longer than the cheaper brand I had been using. The only problem is that they’re high priced.”

Red Wing ComfortPro work shoes

1 Best Buy0 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Paul Tierney, Bloomington, Minn. · Vol. 42, No. 1 (2018), p. 13

“My Red Wing ComfortPro work shoes are the most comfortable shoes I’ve ever owned (www.redwingshoes.com). So I was bummed when the sole cracked open after several years of use. I decided to fix them myself.

“I found a piece of rubber stair tread and cut pieces to fit the sole and heel of the shoe. I used Vulkem poly sealant to attach the rubber pieces to the bottom of the shoes, placing them right over the old heel and sole. Then I let the shoes sit for a month so the Vulkem would cure.

“After the repair, the shoes are just as comfortable as ever and they have a better grip, thanks to the pattern on the stair tread. I saved some money and I’m even a little taller now.”

Red Wing boot oil

1 Best Buy1 Worst Buy
Best BuyWorst Buy
Anonymous, Pa. · Vol. 50, No. 3 (2026), p. 14

“Red Wing boot oil works great to soften stiff leather, but if you expect it to waterproof, you’ll be disappointed.”

Read every report in full

FARM SHOW has run reader Best & Worst Buys since the beginning.

Subscribe to FARM SHOW