Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › Issues › Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006)

Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006)

64 reports from pages 12–15 · 53 Best Buys16 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →

Worst Buy

Ford 1-ton pickup equipped

Wayne & Gail Hopkins, Overbrook, Kan. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 12

“Our 2005 Ford 1-ton pickup equipped with a Powerstroke 6.0 diesel has been a disaster,” says Wayne, who called recently to tell us his story. “We bought it new last August and had to replace the head gasket at 800, 1,200, and 1,800 miles. It spent 40 days in the shop during the first 15,000 miles. We haul hay for a living so that was a real problem for us. In fact, since buying this truck we figure we’ve lost about $40,000 in business.

“We’ve been in touch with the Kansas attorney general and he said the 6.0 diesel is the worst case of product failure he’s ever seen. The engine was made by International, but Ford has been spending millions trying to keep them running.

“Our dealer was good to us, but it was when we started working with the next level up of Ford customer service that we had problems. They made lots of excuses and wouldn’t call us back. As time went on and we continued to work on this engine, we discovered that some of the portholes in the head for cooling fluid were not open. That’s apparently why it runs so hot. For example, you can’t keep your feet on the floor of the passenger side because it’s so hot.

“We finally got the name of the national head of customer service for Ford. My wife, Gail, called Detroit and was actually put through to his voice mail. She left a long message about the pickup and the poor customer service we were receiving from his regional managers. We figured that would be the end of it, but three hours later we got a call from Ford saying they’d buy the pickup back from us. It took 6 weeks to work out the final details but in the end they finally wrote us a check for the full retail price of $35,000, even though we had only paid $28,000. They also paid for the flatbed we had put on it, and some other accessories, for a total of $38,246. During the time we were working out the deal, they fixed the pickup one more time and asked us to give it another try. They guaranteed we’d be happy this time. We said we’d do it if it wouldn’t void our buy-back deal. We didn’t get 50 miles out of town before the fuel pump went out. We think the fuel pump, and other parts, had been damaged by the high heat put out by this engine.

“Ford spent a lot to remedy this situation, especially if you add up all the hotel and travel expenses they had to pick up over the past year for us. They did everything they could to make us go away but we kept working away at them.

“My wife and I would be happy to help anyone else who’d like advice on how to handle a bad situation with Ford. Write us at 51 E 550th Rd., Overbrook, Kan. 66524 or call at 785 255-4579.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet Crew Cab

Robert E. Bakki, Republic, Wash. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 12

“I’m very proud of my rebuilt 1985 Chevy Crew Cab. I’ve worked on it for years and now it’s almost done. The interior is new and I came up with my own design for the paint job. I repowered it with a Cummins 5.9 cu. in. diesel with a new Venture 4500 5-speed manual overdrive. It has a Detroit rear end (4:10 gears) and I’m planning on installing either a 3-speed browning box or a dual drive transmission. The only modification I had to make to the truck to install the Cummins engine was to install different motor mounts. However, I had to lift the body 2 in. to clear the Venture 4500. I also had to add one leaf to the front springs to handle the additional weight.”

Best Buy

In response to the report by the British Columbia reader in the last i

Richard Vega, Lake George, N.Y. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 12

“In response to the report by the British Columbia reader in the last issue who had trouble with his Classic outside wood furnace from Central Boiler, I have also had my share of misadventures. I had problems with it choking for air at startup for about 7 min. The air supply damper door is just about useless. With no adjustments, it lets in maximum air or next to none at all. When the fire settles to below the drop curtain, it runs correctly.

“To help solve the problem, I put a 6-in. stainless steel elbow in the ash door to provide more fresh air. Hardly any ash builds up in the chimney now.

“My stove must be a couple sizes bigger than that other reader since I can load it with 5-ft. oak logs. If the door were wider, I could put a 6-ft. pallet into it.

“At times the flames come out the door. I can’t let my wife or son run it at all and I’ve singed my hair and beard several times.”

Best Buy

New Holland CR940 combine

Marvion Reichert, Elm Creek, Neb. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 12

“I bought a New Holland CR940 combine two years ago and this machine has been nothing but trouble. Between myself and the dealer, we’ve put more than $34,000 into it,” says Marvion. “We’ve had a tremendous amount of downtime. It just won’t keep running. Every time we get something fixed, something else goes wrong. We’re in the second year of the warranty so every service visit costs $500. When I bought this machine, I figured the factory was just 50 miles away so they would be able to fix it. But the factory might as well be overseas for all the good it has done us.

“I’ve owned five New Holland combines and I have three tractors, a half dozen skid steer loaders, and other company equipment. So I’m a good customer but you could never tell that from the way they’ve treated me.

“The company wanted me to pay $65,000 with a trade-in to get a replacement machine. I offered the equivalent of $41,000 but they said no. We dickered around for 6 months with no result. Company officials kept saying they’d call me back but they didn’t. I finally looked up the name of the CEO and sent him a letter at his home address, explaining my situation. That really got the ball rolling and we settled on my original offer.

“Here’s how this company treated me: Lots of sympathy but no action. A very frustrating experience.”

Best Buy

County Line Welding

Kevin Ihm, Barneveld, Wis. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 12

“I’m extremely happy with the 20 custom-built gates we put in our new 300-stall dairy heifer barn a few months ago from Andy Tilleraas of County Line Welding in San Pierre, Ind.

“The heavy-duty gates come with a 5-year warranty and also have heavy, custom-made hinges. The hinge pins are 1 1/8-in. round steel bar. They’re strong enough that I think they’ll be lifetime gates. With the commercial gates we’ve had in the past, we’ve needed to replace hinges after a few years and the gates get bent. These gates are strong enough, that if you stand on the side of the gate where the chain is, it doesn’t move – but other types of gates sag. I also like the custom widths that these gates offer. I also bought some bi-fold gates from County Line that make it much easier when moving animals around. The chain latches are 1/4-in. log chains with a large steel gusset, and a 12-ft. gate weighs around 200 lbs. County Line Welding installed them, too, and price-wise, I don’t think these gates were much different than other gates.”

Best Buy

Buhler loader

Gerald Wanderi, Perham, Minn. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 13

Gerald says his best buy is the 595 Buhler loader he uses on his 6610 Ford FWA tractor. “It’s really built well. I got it when I replaced my Ford 777 loader, which was breaking up and not built as strong. I especially like the Buhler because of the quick-tach part of it. Most of the framework comes off, so it’s much easier to work on the tractor when you need to.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Milwaukee metal cold + 1 more

Terry Whitney, Delavan, Minn. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 13

“It’ll cut any kind of mild steel, from 28 ga. roofing steel to 1-in. bar stock,” reports Terry about his portable Milwaukee 8-in. metal cold cut saw. “The thicker the metal you’re cutting, the slower you go to keep the motor from overheating. Cutting with this saw creates very few sparks and a burr-free cutting edge.

“My Deere LX277 riding mower is my worst buy. The tractor itself works fine, but not the mower deck. The deck is suspended from the tractor which creates a very uneven job of cutting. I tried using new blades and adjusting the gauge wheels according to the owner’s manual, but nothing helped. Putting the correct air pressure in the tires didn’t help, either.”

Best Buy

Kawasaki Mule 610 4-WD utility vehicle

Ronald Mantila, Pelkie, Mich. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 13

“It’s rugged and well built,” says Ronald, pleased with his Kawasaki Mule 610 4-WD utility vehicle. “It’s equipped with a 401 cc single cylinder engine and has a lot of power in both low and high range. It has selectable 2 or 4-WD with rear differential lock. I’ve used this machine for making firewood and have even used it to skid some trees. The dump box on back comes in handy for hauling wood and other material.”

Best Buy

Ford Jubilee

John Wenner, Atkinson, Neb. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 13

“My 1953 Ford Jubilee is the most reliable tractor I’ve ever owned. I use it to mow, rake, doze, plow, disk, and harrow. This year I mounted Bombardier half-tracks on it, which makes the tractor work even better.”

Best Buy

John Deere 185 riding mower equipped

E. Clinton Williams, Jr., Sumerduck, Va. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 13

He’s impressed with his 1986 Deere 185 riding mower equipped with a 38-in. deck, Kawasaki 17 hp engine, and hydrostatic transmission. “Mowing grass is a job that interferes with other, more fun activities, and I have little patience for working on mowers. So I was willing to pay a premium price for what I hoped was a premium machine that I could haul in my compact pickup. The engine has never missed a beat and still doesn’t use any oil, and the deck is in great shape. The few parts that I’ve needed, such as belts and bearings, are always available from my local dealer. This mower has required only routine maintenance and has outlasted four of my friend’s discount store brands. It’s definitely a best buy.”

Best Buy

John Deere 4010 tractor + 1 more

Bud Ahlaman, Wallace, Kansas · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 13

A 1963 Deere 4010 tractor, which he bought used 15 years ago, rates as Bud’s “best buy”. “I’ve used this tractor to mow, do loader work, and to feed cattle during the winter. I haven’t spent a penny on it other than batteries and other routine stuff. The amazing thing is that it’s worth more today than it was when it was new.

“I put about 190,000 miles on my 1992 Chevrolet Suburban and never touched the engine. The bad news was that I had to replace the transmission four times.”

Best Buy

Arctic Cat 400 ATV equipped

Gerald H. Covell, Lombardy, Ontario · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 13

“It has exceeded all my expectations,” says Gerald about his 2005 Arctic Cat 400 ATV equipped with an automatic transmission, locking differential, and 2 or 4-WD. “It has enough power to perform all our chores, and more. I use it with a blade to clean out my horse stalls and paddock. No problems.”

Best Buy

Ford Ranger quad door 4-wd

Burnell Gaskins, Nisland, S. Dak. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 13

“I like my 2000 Ford Ranger quad door 4-WD pickup, which I bought used about 1 1/2 years ago. I really like Ford Rangers. I’ve owned three of them since 1988 and all have been dependable. They’re all equipped with V-6 engines and 5-speed transmissions, and they all average about 19 mpg, which I think is pretty good. We live out in the country so most of the time we drive on dirt and paved roads, not freeways.”

Best Buy

Kubota

Ralph Petersen, Sardis, Ohio · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 13

Ralph’s had problems with the quick hitch on his Kubota tractor’s loader bucket. “The first time I used it, it bent. The second time, it broke. The dealer replaced it but it bent again. I had to use a sledge hammer to remove the bucket that time. The dealer wouldn’t replace it or refund my money. I ended up cutting it apart and rewelding it.”

Best Buy

Briggs & Stratton Intek Series small gas engines

James Morey, Middle Brook, Mo. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 13

“Over the last two years, I’ve had excellent results with a pair of Briggs & Stratton Intek Series small gas engines. I use a 5 1/2 hp on my Oscar 28 sawmill and an 8 hp model on a Brave log splitter. I use both the sawmill and the log splitter intermittently, sometimes going three or four months without starting them. These engines always start easy and run smooth.”

Best Buy

Kawasaki Mule 500 utility vehicle

D.F. Raube, Ceres, Calif. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 13

“Without a doubt our best buy is our Kawasaki Mule 500 utility vehicle. It has a bench seat that’s easy to get on and off. The bench seats two people side by side. It’s far superior to other utility vehicles where you have to climb over to get onto the seat, like getting on a horse or motorcycle. It’s also much more convenient to use for small jobs and errands than a full-sized pickup or tractor and trailer.”

Best Buy

Ram 3500 1-ton dually pickup equipped

Ken Larson, Baudette, Minn. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 13

“I like my 1998 Dodge 3500 1-ton dually pickup equipped with an extended cab. When empty it gets about 20 mpg, which I think is pretty good in these times of high fuel prices. Pulling a large camper it gets 13 to 14 mpg. For a 1-ton pickup it has a very comfortable ride and is stable, with plenty of power. The newer pickup models are definitely quieter, but I already have a car.”

Best Buy

Case IH 7120 tractor

Brad Rip, Sunnyside, Wash. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 13

“My 1994 Case IH 7120 tractor was my best buy ever. We put more than 16,000 hours on the original engine and transmission. Although this tractor did have its share of oil leaks over the years, it required no major repairs. The Cummins diesel engine worked great. It had a lot of power and was fuel efficient.”

Best Buy

M.E. Miller Tire Co

John R. Johnson, Paradise, Montana · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 13

John bought front tires for his 1948 tractor from M.E. Miller Tire Co. and is happy with them (Wauseon, Ohio ph 419 335-7010). “These tires are a hard-to-find size. They’re quality-built Firestones, and they’re reasonably priced. I really like the way this company does business.”

Worst Buy

Holly Park mobile home

Allen Gillespie, Audubon, Minn. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 13

Allen nominates his 28 by 40-ft. double wide Holly Park mobile home as his “worst buy”. “The workmanship on this building is a disaster. The floor isn’t fastened down - they missed the joists by as much as six inches. Instead of using nails, they used light wire staples. The wiring in the house isn’t heavy enough to operate a window air conditioner, and the inside doors are too small for the frames. The dealer was supposed to set the building up, but they didn’t put all the supports under the house. Now some of the inside walls are moving.

“The company sent out repair people, but they don’t seem to know how to fix anything. All the molding and trim, including what’s on the kitchen cabinets, is made of particle board covered by wood grain shelf paper. If this mobile home lasts for 10 years, it’ll be a miracle.”

Best Buy

Quick Bayt fly control bait

Brad Bergan, Strawberry Point, Iowa · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 14

Brad’s happy with Quick Bayt fly control bait (www.quickbayt.com; ph 800 633-3796). “A 5-lb. pail of this product will last an entire season on my farm. All I have to do is sprinkle a small amount around the milk barn and freestalls, and flies die instantly. When I check the bait a few hours later, the ground will be black with dead flies.”

Best Buy

Case New Holland 8010 combine

Lloyd Crowe, Picton, Ontario · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 14

“Our best buy was our Case New Holland 8010 combine. We had some electric and hydraulic problems with it initially, but the company completely updated the combine and gave one more year of warranty. Last year we used the combine to harvest 6,000 acres of corn, wheat, and soybeans. It was trouble-free except for a bad solenoid on the header tracking system during corn harvest. However, that problem didn’t stop us at all. We just replaced the defective part as soon as the new part came in.”

Best Buy

A-maize-ing Heat corn furnace + 1 more

Steve Rodgers, Wellman, Iowa · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 14

Steve’s happy with his 2004 A-maize-ing Heat corn furnace (LDJ Mfg., Pella, Iowa ph 641 620-9412; www.ldj-products.com). “This furnace is well built and easy to understand and operate. It’ll easily heat our drafty old 2-story farm house for about one third the cost of propane. The large bulk hopper and lack of complicated controls and electronics were deciding factors when we bought it. The only trouble we’ve had is that it smelled pretty bad the first day or so as some paint burned off. Also, the auger motor failed twice and was replaced - once under warranty and the second time at our expense. Overall, though, we’re glad we bought this corn furnace.

“Our 1990 Honda Accord has more than 212,000 miles on it but it’s still going strong. We use it every day.”

Worst Buy

Rem Bale Max 3600 r bale shredder

Clifton White, Jima, Alberta · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 14

“My worst buy was a Rem Bale Max 3600 R bale shredder. The flails and rotor on this machine seem to be made of poor quality material, because the flails break easily and pull the holder off the rotor. The company has replaced the rotor and flails once, but I haven’t seen any improvement.”

Best Buy

Zout stain remover spray + 1 more

Jim Halliwill, St. Augustine, Fla. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 14

“Anyone with tough laundry stains should try Zout stain remover spray. It’s amazing stuff (Dial Corp., Scottsdale, Ariz. ph 800 548-9770; www.zout.com).” The product is water-based, non-corrosive, non-flammable, and biodegradable. It removes stains, without chlorine or bleach. It’s also available in a squeeze bottle.

Jim also likes his Staber washing machine bought in 2001 (www.Staber.com; ph 800 848-6200. “There aren’t enough words to describe how great this water-saving machine works. It has a side-mounted drum but still loads from the top. Laundry is tumbled through a pool of water at the bottom of the drum, creating a water pumping action that forces soapy water through the clothes for better cleaning. Larger items like comforters and blankets that would never get clean in a traditional washer come out exceptionally clean, even though you only use about half as much detergent in this machine.

“A problem developed with the washing cycle right after the warranty expired. I called the company’s toll-free number and talked to a service rep, who said the problem was probably due to a computer board. They sent me another board free of charge, asking only that I send the old one back. I was able to easily install the computer board by myself. Problem solved.”

Best Buy

John Deere 925 mower conditioner + 5 more

Greg Kropf, Westphalia, Kansas · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 14

“My 1999 Deere 925 mower conditioner is my best buy. I especially like the flail conditioner, which can pass objects through without damaging the machine. This machine just mows and mows without problems. It has held up well over thousands of acres.

“My 1966 Deere 4020 tractor is a best buy. It rarely has problems and is worth exactly what I paid for it six years ago.

“My 1999 Deere 6310 tractor is comfortable, quiet, and does a good job of handling our mower and round baler. The power quad transmission lets us work fast in the field. It lets me mow our field 30 minutes quicker than with my 4020, just because of its ability to easily and constantly change gears.

“My 2003 Vermeer 605XL baler makes a good bale and the pickup gets all the hay. However, it has had a lot of problems.

“My 2004 Vermeer WRX rake does a good job and is easy to adjust. However, it’s four real tires, a good paint job, and some better-grade bolts away from being a best buy.

“My Deere 1600 hydraswing mower conditioner never made it through a field without breaking down. The final blow came when we couldn’t get it unhooked from the tractor’s pto shaft, and we ended up having to take the pto shaft out of the tractor.”

Worst Buy

Cub Cadet ZTR riding mower equipped

Joe Kelich, Frankton, Ind. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 14

Joe nominates his 2003 Cub Cadet ZTR riding mower equipped with a 44-in. deck as his “worst buy”. “The second day after we bought it, it wouldn’t start. The dealer said he would come to our place and check it out, but he couldn’t say when. We called our old IHC dealer, who picked it up and installed a new choke on it right away. The second time we used it, a belt idler bent but the metal was so soft we were able to bend it. After we spent a couple weeks putting up with the idler, the center blade assembly fell out.

“We called the dealer, and when he came out he noticed that the deck and mounting frame were also bent. He claimed that we must have accidentally run into something, but we didn’t. The metal was just too weak. Finally a district rep came out to look at the machine. They replaced the mower deck. They had the mower from June 20 to November 20 - it took them that long to decide to put on a new deck.”

Best Buy

Honda 350 Fourtrax 4-wheeler + 1 more

Clint Hain, Vandalia, Mich. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 14

“My 1986 Honda 350 Fourtrax 4-wheeler is a hard working ATV. I recently sold it. It pulled like a mule and could handle a hay wagon loaded with 110 small square bales with no problem.

“My 1996 Polaris Sportsman 500 ATV was two years old when it started running rough, so I traded it in for a 1999 model. However, the new machine started doing the same thing. The dealer told me these machines have a bad cam. The cam was replaced in the 1999 model, but after putting only 500 miles on it we’re already finding metal shavings in the oil.”

Worst Buy

Ford F-350 Super Duty 4-wd crew cab

Neal B. Neidig, Madison, Neb. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 14

Neal’s “worst buy” is his 2005 Ford F-350 Super Duty 4-WD crew cab pickup equipped with a 6.0-liter Power Stroke engine. “At about 15,000 miles the fuel pump went out (not the injector pump). The company paid for the pump and labor but wouldn’t pay for the filter kit, even though there were brass filings in it. The filter kit retails for $70. The transmission had a recall for a bad snap ring deep inside, which was covered under warranty. The pickup now has about 23,000 miles on it, and now the limited slip differential isn’t working. Also, there’s a problem with the turbo variable vane and with the EGR.

“I’m currently waiting for a qualified mechanic to do the warranty work on it, as some Ford mechanics aren’t certified to work on 6.0-liter Power Stroke engines. I’ve been a Ford man for most of my life, but I’m disappointed. I don’t think it was adequately tested.

“This is a $45,000 pickup that gets only 8 1/2 to 11 mpg. It has never made the 16 mpg they said it would, even on the open road not towing anything. I traded off a 2001 F-250 Super Duty 4-WD crew cab with 102,000 miles, and its 7.3-liter Power Stroke engine was still getting 16 to 20 mpg.”

Worst Buy

Cleary Building Corp

Jon Braun, Mina, S. Dak. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 14

Jon’s disappointed with a building he had put up by Cleary Building Corp. “The salesman promised a starting date of November, but the materials didn’t even show up until the middle of December. Then I was told they had no crews to do the construction until February. The rafters froze in ice and warped. The company sent out a small crew to put up the walls, but they patched broken boards with small chunks of wood to hold them together. I’ll never buy from this company again.”

Worst Buy

I had my DR trimmer, with the Beaver blade only a short time before I

Jack Nachamkin, Glen Mills, Penn. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 14

“I had my DR trimmer, with the Beaver blade only a short time before I discovered that the blade becomes dull after only a few hours of use. The company’s cutting blade consists of a piece of chainsaw chain wrapped around a disc.

“It became an expensive proposition to continually re-sharpen and/or replace the chain every 8 hours or so of use. I decided to replace the blade with a carborundum-tipped sawmill blade. I bought a 14-in. blade and a friend, George Jones, precision machined a washer needed to fit the blade snugly onto the shaft of the DR machine.

“The modification was a complete success, and the DR went from a worst buy to a joy to use. It cuts through woody brush, thick vines, and weed saplings up to 4 in. thick, without any degradation of the blade.

“Although this upgrade might invalidate the DR warranty, the machine was useless for my purposes without the conversion. I suspect the DR company might argue with me.”

Best Buy

Ford 4000 low profile + 3 more

Ronald Martin, Cookeville, Tenn. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 14

“My 1972 Ford 4000 low profile SU tractor has almost 8,000 hours on it but still has the original brakes and clutch. I bought it used when it was one year old, equipped with an industrial loader. It has its own hydraulic pump on front that’s belt-driven off the engine driveshaft, with the hydraulic reservoir built into the loader frame. It’s a lot stronger and quicker than loaders that run off tractor hydraulics. This tractor doesn’t use any oil between changes.

“My four Stihl chain saws are all best buys. They include a model 011, two 034’s, and model 036.

“My 1979 Ford F-250 3/4-ton pickup has about 150,000 miles on it and still runs great. It’s equipped with a 400 cu. in. engine and a 4-speed transmission. About 15 years ago I mounted dual wheels and a flatbed on it so I can use it like a 1-ton pickup. I use a 12,000-lb. Warn electric winch with this pickup, which is also a best buy.”

Best Buy

Last fall we wanted to protect our garage floor

Dorothy Reynolds, Evans Mills, N.Y. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 14

“Last fall we wanted to protect our garage floor. The paint man at a local independent lumber yard warned us against using latex-epoxy paint. ‘They haven’t perfected it yet,’ he said.

“We thought his advice was just sour grapes, since the big home improvement stores sell the products. Well, he was right. Salt-laden snow melting from the undersides of our vehicles blistered the paint. We used the same paint on a cellar floor, and it worked out no better. It was painted just before the holidays, and by March there were bare streaks on the floor anywhere there was foot traffic or furniture movement.”

Worst Buy

Massey Ferguson 1250 tractor

Tom Kearns, Redmond, Wash. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 15

Tom nominates his 1997 Massey Ferguson 1250 tractor as his “worst buy”. “With less than 1,000 hours on the tractor, the entire wiring harness had to be replaced because the wires kept breaking. The electrical system on this tractor is a mess - I used the tractor for another 300 hours and had to replace the alternator twice. Now the wiring harness has failed again. The dealer can’t help and said that since I live in a rainy climate I can expect the wires to corrode, which I think is nonsense. This tractor has always broken down and is almost like having a toy. It’s very undependable.”

Best Buy

Farm Drainage Plows, Inc

Don Zeller, Bode, Iowa · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 15

“I like the tile plow I bought from Don Wurdinger at Farm Drainage Plows, Inc. (Waverly, Iowa ph 319 352-3911). “It’s a 3-pt. mounted model which I use to install 4-in. plastic tile. I use it for short runs as well as long runs. My ground has a gradual slope and this machine works nice on it. I bought this tile plow because commercial tile contractors don’t want to bother putting in small tile. I space the 4-in. tile closer together than you would with larger tile and use a 150 hp tractor to pre-rip the ground.”

Best Buy

Cub Cadet 8454 45 hp tractor equipped

Steve Floyd, Eustace, Texas · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 15

“I really like this tractor’s shuttle transmission - it makes loader work a lot easier,” says Steve, impressed with his 2004 Cub Cadet 8454 45 hp tractor equipped with a front-end loader. “The loader has a quick-change bucket on it, which I really like because I switch from the bucket to a bale fork quite often. The bucket is 72 in. wide - the same width as the tractor’s rear wheels.”

Worst Buy

Zartman cow mattresses

Harlan Burkholder, Charles City, Iowa · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 15

“My Zartman cow mattresses are my worst buys. The dealer told me these mattresses would last eight years with no problems. Yet I was able to use them only one month before holes started developing. Now after 15 months about 30 percent of the mattresses have holes in them.”

Best Buy

Satoh AD 370 4-WD tractor equipped

Myron Patrick, Winder, Ga. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 15

A 1978 Satoh AD 370 4-WD tractor equipped with a 15 hp, 2-cyl. diesel engine rates as Myron’s “best buy”. “This tractor has been trouble-free. It still runs like new and has required only routine maintenance. I use it almost every week. It’s a great little tractor.”

Best Buy

John Deere 7800 tractor

Ron Stoen, Lowry, Minn. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 15

“I leased a Deere 7800 tractor for one year and then bought it the next year. The third year I sold it to my son, and that’s when the problems started. The tractor required several overhauls and had transmission problems and more. I guess this tractor was just a lemon that some other poor soul will end up with now, as my son traded it off. I’ve been a Deere man since the days of the old G model. I used to think Deere made the best tractors, but now I’m not so sure.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Plymouth Voyager van + 1 more

Tim Estling · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 15

A 1988 Plymouth Voyager van rates as Tim’s “best buy”. “I bought this vehicle in 1989 from my brother-in-law. Now it has about 233,000 miles on it and has required only routine maintenance.”

On the negative side, he lists his Husqvarna 350 chain saw. “I’ve cut firewood for 30 years using two old Homelite saws, one 25 years old and the other 35. I thought it was time to upgrade so I bought this saw two years ago. Right out of the box the chain oiler didn’t work, so the first year I didn’t use this saw much and had to rely on my old models. The next year, the Husqvarna was only involved in making five loads of wood when the piston seized up in the cylinder. The company wouldn’t stand behind its product. I tried to buy a repair kit, but the parts are so overpriced I think I’m just going to discard this saw. I learned my lesson.”

Best Buy

The two AA batteries in my indoor-outdoor thermometer kept wearing out

Bill Allin, Chilliwack, B.C. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 15

“The two AA batteries in my indoor-outdoor thermometer kept wearing out so I converted it to run off a 110-volt adapter. I cut two lengths of 9/16-in. doweling the same length as the batteries and put a thumb tack on the end of each one. Then, I soldered wires from an AC adapter to the tacks. If I ever want to go back to batteries, I can just take out the dowels.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

New Holland TG210 tractor + 2 more

Francis Henderson, Brinston, Ontario · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 15

“My 2004 New Holland TG210 tractor is a pleasure to operate. No problems.

“My 2005 New Holland big square baler works like a dream and has been trouble-free.

“My 2004 J-Star Van Dale 53-bu. feed cart is my worst buy. It has a bad paint job, a very loud muffler, and the 9 hp Honda engine has caused nothing but trouble. Gas keeps getting into the oil, but the dealer told me I had to go to the company for help. I’ve had to change the needle and carburetor, all at my own expense. The company gave me every excuse in the book why the problem was my fault. They also said that I have to turn the gas off whenever the machine is not in use. I have six other Honda engines, and I don’t have to shut the fuel off on any of them.”

Best Buy

Chevrolet 5500 pickup equipped + 1 more

Ray Whatley, Bastrop, Texas · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 15

A 2000 Chevrolet 5500 pickup equipped with a 210 hp Caterpillar diesel engine and Allison transmission and dually wheels rates as Ray’s “best buy”. “This pickup is heavy enough to haul anything and to pull any trailer. It sat without a bed on the dealer’s lot for a couple of years before I bought it. I asked the dealer if he would take the bed off another 2003 model that was on the lot and put it on this model, and he did.

“My 1990 Dodge 3/4-ton pickup equipped with a diesel engine has always run well but initially it had head gasket and transmission problems. It took 15 years to get the bugs worked out. Now this pickup has more than 300,000 miles on it.”

Best Buy

Ram 4-WD pickup equipped

Larry Tripp, Nardin, Okla. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 15

“I’m generally pleased with my 2004 Dodge 4-WD pickup equipped with a diesel engine. However, the oil in the front and rear differentials is supposed to be changed every 15,000 miles or else you risk voiding the warranty. Manufacturers have been using 90-weight oil for years with little or no failure during the life of a vehicle. This oil change requirement isn’t improving the pickups - it’s a scam.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Chevrolet 3500 pickup equipped + 1 more

David H. Chadbourne, Harmony, Maine · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 15

David likes his 2003 Chevrolet 3500 pickup equipped with a Duramax diesel engine and 6-speed transmission. “It has a comfortable ride and exceptional power.

“My 2003 Fisher Minute Mount snowplow is my worst buy. This snowplow is difficult to mount unless it’s on a cement floor in a heated garage. I’ve had to take it back for wiring problems, because the plow wouldn’t lift or change angles and the lights didn’t work. I changed the wiring harness and the lights, but they still don’t work unless I wiggle the connectors. I’m very disappointed with this snowplow.”

Worst Buy

Gehl Scavenger II model 309 manure

Fritz Groszkruger, Dumont, Iowa · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 15

“Our Gehl Scavenger II model 309 manure spreader is our worst buy. The only manure that comes out is whatever the auger touches. I have to push the load into the auger by hand about three times per load. The company gave me some ideas, but basically said that conditions must be perfect or it won’t work. In my opinion, that doesn’t cut it for a spreader that was advertised as a machine that can handle all types of manure. I offered the company rep $50 per load to haul out the last three loads from our manure pile, but I never heard back from him.

“If anyone knows how to solve this problem, I’d like to hear from them. I wouldn’t sell this spreader to my worst enemy. I’d rather find a way to make it work.”

Best BuyWorst Buy

Husky 41 chain saw + 1 more

William Lukinich, Ninilchik, Alaska · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 15

“Our Husky 41 chain saw is our worst buy. More gas has leaked out of the gas cap than has gone through the engine. This chain saw was hard to start when we got it, and the problem has only become worse. Some days this saw starts and some days it doesn’t, so we haven’t used it a lot. It wouldn’t even make a good boat anchor. It’s the last Husky I’ll buy.

“Our 1997 Honda Foreman has been trouble-free and is our best buy. It’s a real workhorse. We use it to harrow our field and to drag in logs to our mill or for firewood. We use it both summer and winter.”

Worst Buy

Hummer H2

Richard “Red” Guthrie, Early, Tenn. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 15

“My 2003 Hummer H2 is my worst buy. I bought it equipped with all the options, from a 9,000-lb. winch on front to a combination gun safe on back. I paid $72,600 for what I thought was the toughest and best vehicle General Motors had to offer. However, I immediately noticed the wiring for the rear camera system had heat damage because it was located too close to the exhaust system. My lawyer had to threaten to sue before the dealer would replace it.

“All the optional equipment was factory or dealer-installed when I bought this vehicle. To date, the overhead lights have had to be sealed where rain leaked through. The rear door weather stripping continuously fell off until it was reglued.

“While I was on a trip to Virginia in 2004 the dealer fixed the exhaust leaks, repaired the shift handle on the transmission, replaced the volume control on the steering wheel which had shorted out, and replaced a defective carrier latch for the spare tire. The exhaust system was repaired two more times before the warranty expired. The cruise control double or triple downshifted on hills and used 25 percent more fuel whenever it was in use. Also, the big chrome Hummer letters fell off and had to be replaced.

“Three batteries also had to be replaced before the warranty expired.

“I notified Hummer’s general manager several times but never got an answer. When the batteries go out this vehicle is locked down and the driver is totally helpless, with no way to get in or out, no OnStar, and no phone. This is dangerous for a disabled person like myself.”

Best Buy

M&W 5506 round baler

Richard Gribbins, Bradfordsville, Ky. · Vol. 30, No. 3 (2006), p. 15

“I like my 2003 M&W 5506 round baler which makes a 5 by 5-ft. bale. It calls for a 55 hp tractor, but a Ford 3950 45 hp tractor can easily pull it. I’ve made about 2,050 bales with no problems. This baler doesn’t have many moving parts to wear out, and it seems like it would be easy to work on.”