Real farmers rate what they bought, from FARM SHOW MagazineSubscribe  ·  Free issue  ·  Send us your Best or Worst Buy
Subscribe to FARM SHOW
Home › John Deere › 5400

John Deere 5400 tractor

What FARM SHOW readers say · 2 Best Buys2 Worst Buys · Tractors

John Deere 5400 tractor

2 Best Buys2 Worst Buys
Best Buy
Sharold Shepherd, Kiowa, Colo. · Vol. 25, No. 6 (2001), p. 17

“My 1998 Deere 5400 tractor runs great. It’s a good tractor.”

Worst Buy
Phillip Knight, Louisville, Ky. · Vol. 24, No. 2 (2000), p. 15

“My worst buy ever is my Deere 5400 tractor which I bought used in 1996 with 125 hours on it. At 922 hours the B range shaft seized to the pinion shaft, and I couldn’t get the tractor out of gear. A company representative said there were problems with some of these tractors because they weren’t assembled properly at the factory, but wouldn’t recall them because there weren’t enough complaints. My total cost for repairs was $4,450. The company agreed to pay only one fourth of the cost.”

Worst Buy
Jack L. Rarig, Catawissa, Pa. · Vol. 24, No. 2 (2000), p. 16

Jack’s “worst buys” are his two 1995 Deere 5400 tractors. “The first one was returned to the factory for evaluation of the transmission only three weeks after I got it and with only 19 hours on it. The hydro reverser transmission went from 10th forward to 9th reverse one day as we returned home from baling hay. The dealer told me he had never heard of anything like that before, but then two days later he told me about another Deere 5400 with the same problem. Both tractors were sent back to the factory for repairs.

“When I asked the dealer how long the repairs would take, he said several months. Parts had to be manufactured in Japan and then shipped to Waterloo. I traded this tractor in on another new 5400 which was delivered in August of 1995. Five minutes after it was off-loaded I noticed the first of many defects. With the engine stopped, the 3-pt. lift arms dropped visibly from full-up to full-down in less than a minute. With the engine running, the lift arms would raise to full height and bounce around. After a few seconds, the lift arms would drop a couple of inches, then bounce back up. When an implement was attached to the 3-pt., the bouncing was bad enough to raise the front wheels off the ground which made steering difficult, especially on hard surfaces.

“With less than 100 hours on the tractor more problems showed up. An air induction hose between the turbocharger and air intake became saturated with oil. The horn won’t blow. The engine produces white smoke up to 1,200 rpm’s whether it’s hot or cold, and it uses about a quart of lube oil every 10 hours. The brakes chatter and clank and both rear axle seals leak. Both ends of the steering cylinder leak, there’s no breather in the front axle, at times I can’t shift into any gear, anti freeze pushes out of the over flow, and the fuel gauge doesn’t work. The link between the third remote valve and lever snapped off at the press fit end.

“This tractor has now spent more hours on back of a truck than it has in my fields. Every time they return the tractor after warranty repair work there are loose and missing nuts and bolts, missing parts, and numerous nicks and scratches in the paint.”

Best Buy
Darrell Rains, Beatrice, Neb · Vol. 19, No. 1 (1995), p. 15

Darrell Rains, Beatrice, Neb.: Darrell's best buy is his 60 hp Deere 5400 tractor equipped with front-wheel-assist and 540 Deere loader. “It’s a handy tractor with plenty of power. With front-wheel-assist it will go where big tractors can’t. We use it every day.”

Own a John Deere? Tell FARM SHOW how it’s held up.

Your report could appear in a future issue.

Send your Best or Worst Buy

More John Deere products

John Deere 1780 split-row 2 best · 1 worstJohn Deere 4240 tractor 14 best · 1 worstJohn Deere 720 diesel 3 best · 0 worstJohn Deere M tractor 2 best · 1 worstJohn Deere L110 lawn tractor 1 best · 1 worstJohn Deere 3025E tractor 2 best · 0 worstJohn Deere 3020 diesel 16 best · 0 worstJohn Deere gas tractor 46 best · 5 worstJohn Deere 4020 diesel 62 best · 3 worstJohn Deere 1023E tractor with backhoe 1 best · 2 worstJohn Deere 2025R tractor 4 best · 0 worstJohn Deere 9300 tractor 2 best · 1 worstJohn Deere 110 garden tractor 11 best · 2 worstJohn Deere Gator 6x4 2 best · 0 worstJohn Deere 6400 tractor 15 best · 0 worstJohn Deere 4320 compact tractor 6 best · 2 worstJohn Deere 8120 tractor 2 best · 0 worstJohn Deere 425 garden tractor 16 best · 5 worstJohn Deere 955 tractor 1 best · 1 worstJohn Deere lawn mower 12 best · 2 worst

See all John Deere reports →