Gene P. Williams, Sioux Falls, S. Dak: “I'm ready to chalk it all up to experience,”’ says Gene after what he says was “‘a costly experience with a new grain cleaner from Grain King Corporation. It took weeks to get a cleaner delivered after I first ordered and paid for it last summer. After had contacted the Better Business Bureau, and the state attorney general’s office, they finally delivered a cleaner. To my surprise, instead of delivering the 2,500 bu. per hour, $3,200 machine I had ordered, they substituted a 5,000 bu. per hour unit that sells for $5,000. That looked good but the cleaner doesn't do the job. “The problem is that it lets too much corn go through with the heavier material. lose about 1 to 1% bu. per every 150 bu. of grain. Even at that rate, I can only run the machine at about 750 bu. per hour. Also, they told me they had screens for wheat and oats, but they apparently don’t. The nice thing about the design is that it would never wear out. think linate in a ad they could fix the cleaning problem but the company doesn't respond. I'd like to get my money back and look for another cleaner.”
Best & Worst Buys: FARM SHOW Vol. 5, No. 1 (1981)
41 reports from pages 10–12 · 39 Best Buys2 Worst Buys · See everything in this issue at FARM SHOW →
Joe Vaessen, Sublette, Ill: “This is supposed to be the best car on the market but I think you could make a better deal at a junkyard,” says Joe, upset with his 1978 Mercedes diesel which he says has been ‘plagued with problems from the beginning. At about 9,000 miles, it began pinging and knocking. It sounded like a gas engine running on cheap gas. The dealer and company blamed it on poor fuel. After several wasted days with the factory mechanic and several repair bills, the car ran the same. “The dealer finally admitted that it might need a new injection pump which the warranty wouldn't cover. ended up buying a new engine. “At 18,000 miles the tires started to come apart. Mercedes said they were high-speed tires and weren't designed to last any longer than that. Several voltage regulators burned out, along with a lot of headlights. The air conditioner didn’t work until an update kit was installed. Door locks went bad and the windows scratched themselves when raised and lowered. The windshield wipers worked so poorly we had to go to K-Mart to find some that worked. After six months, I tried to trade the car for another new Mercedes and found it was worth just half what I'd paid. > “Besides contacting dealers, I've called Mercedes’ regional headquarters in Chicago, written to Germany and contacted government safety officials in Washington. I understand problems can be expected with any machine, but I feel Mercedes should back up their product. They say they havea limited warranty and they do,” Joe concludes. “On the plus side, have an 850 Versatile tractor that runs great, anda Behlen dryer that does a nice job for us,” he adds.
Massey Ferguson
Charles Buckland, Carey, Ohio: “I've had Massey Ferguson combines since 1965 and they have never been down more than a few hours, even when the transmission went out of a new 550. They fixed it in the field in six hours,"’ reports Charles, happy with Massey combines. “Our IH 1586 is also a good buy. No major problems.” He's had problems, however, with his Massey Ferguson.1135 tractor. “I had it overhauled at 1,000 hrs. Have replaced the bearings in the rear end twice, the turbo charger three times, the torque converter twice, and the clutch twice. It never had the power it was supposed to have. Service was good but the tractor was not what we expected.”
Ford
David Nelson, Evansville, Minn: “I don't have a carsol use this pickup as my transportation and workhorse,”’ says David, pleased with his 1978 F250 3/4-ton Ford, “It has a 300 cu. in., 6-cyl. engine and a four-speed transmission. had overload springs installed by the dealer. Mileage and performance are excellent. “The dealer is not just a fast talker looking for a quick sale. When you walk into his place six months later. he knows you.”
Earl Penner, Kola, Manitoba: “My worst buy recently was a 39-ft. Bush Hog Interceptor chisel plow. The trip system has had to be redesigned about six times. We've had the entire machine rewelded and are still finding new cracks all the time. Maybe if you didn't have a single rock in your fields you would be alright but isn’t that what trip systems are designed for?”
Allis-Chalmers + 1 more
Paul Rauh, New Weston, Ohio: “We can't get it to cut level.” says Paul about his 2300 Allis Chalmers 16-ft. disk harrow. ‘‘The dealer came out to adjust it, but couldn't do any good. He sent for a field serviceman who spent a full day in the field and was unable to help. We ordered a new frame but that did no good.” Paul's happy, though, with his New Holland L775 skid steer loader. “It performs great. It's a heavier machine and won't tip as easy as competitive models. No trouble learning to operate it. It's simple to drive.”
John Deere + 1 more
Russell Hunink, Clymer, N.Y: “It's possible to kill a few flies with it but you have to drown them with it. Very ineffective,” says Russell, disappointed with “Whitmire Flys-Off dairy aerosol insecticide.” On the plus side, Russell has three nominations for “best buy”. The first is his WIC 30 bu., battery-operated silage cart. ‘‘We've used it for over a vear, unloading eight hours a day, with almost no problems. It's a much simpler cart than a previous one of a different make. “Another good buy is our Deere 4240 tractor with power assist front wheels. The cab is both comfortable and quiet. The large cubic inch engine responds at all speeds and the power front-wheel assist has worked well in pulling through soft spots in the fields. It's easy to handle, making it an ideal tractor for my wife and daughter to drive. “We're also happy with New Holland's 2438 tandem axle running gears,” he adds. “They're well-built and travel well on the road, besides carrying loads well on soft ground.”
Wayne Mininger, Eaton, Colo: “Our ‘best buy’ is a 1979 Ford TW-30 tractor. It came to us in better condition than any major purchase we've made in a long time, In its first 1,100 hours it’s been virtually trouble-free, Well-balanced and easy to handle. The tractor dyno checks at about 15% over the advertised horsepower and “The company turned a deaf ear. We got rid of it.” the cab is about the best I’ve been in Controls are tops.” Wayne's unhappy with ehis “Chatanooga Line culti-maulcher, We were constantly breaking springteeth and the company turned us a deaf ear. We got rid of it.”
Dean Nielsen, Comanche, lowa: *'It doesn't take a lot of babysitting,” says Dean about his “best buy” Shivvers Circulator and Dri-Flo grain system. “We test samples every couple hours to see if grain is at the correct moisture, It has 10,000 bu. wet storage and dries up to 7,000 bu. in a 24-hour day, Dry corn is automatically transferred to two 13,000 bu. bins.”
John Deere
John Barendregt, Union, Ontario: He's disappointed with his Forest City Do-All 26-ft. cultivator. “It does a fair job but wears out too fast. If we wanted to put it back in the field, we'd be looking at a large cost to get it back in shape. The reels kick stones that stop the reels and make the field a mess. Distributor and dealer were no help at all.” On the positive side, John says, “Our A & L grain cart with 425 bu. capacity is the best investment we've made for harvest in some time, It increases the capacity of our 7700 Deere combine by one third to a half. The cart was well-engineered before putting iton the market, with a hydraulic shut-off valve that works super and is built extra heavy on the stress points.”
John Deere
William Menold, Dunlap, IIL: "I'm impressed with the tremendous capacity of this machine. Because of the spring-loaded belts and chain tighteners, grease banks, and the sealed bearings, the time spent to service it is small. There have been no breakdowns in 1,100 acres, Easy to operate and drive comfort is excellent,’’ William told FARM SHOW about his ‘best buy" John Deere 7720 combine.
New Holland
Thomas A. Votipka, Belvidere, Neb: "Il keep asking myself why I didn’t buy one earlier,” says Thomas about his new 16-ft. Hale stock trailer. “Within the last four months, we have transported milk cows, calves. furniture, firewood. and hay, The best feature is its low profile and capacity, We pull it behind our 3/4ton. pickup, but have also pulled it with a 1/2-ton. “ have another recent purchase which I think will prove to be a ‘best buy’, adds Thomas. "I boughta New Holland 1038 Stackliner but haven't had a chance to use it because I purchased it in the off season. The bale wagon has a capacity of 104 bales. It picks up. loads, hauls, stacks, retrieves and unloads one bale ata time. I feel it will be a great asset to my operation and plan on doing custom work with it next summer.”
Richard Weiler, Athens, Wis: He's disappointed with his “Badger 207 manure spreader, One corner sagged from the first two weeks. Also, the apron tore. The spreader was built too flimsy for its size. The dealer had my money and had his junk. I'll never buy another piece of Badger equipment,”
John Deere
Joe Kalvoda, Mandan, N. Dak: Joe nominates three “best buys’’ — John Deere 4630 and 4430 tractors, and a 1979 Ford Fiesta. “In 2,500 hrs., the 4630 has never lost an hour of time. The 4430 has been in the shop only once for minor repairs. Both are a pleasure to drive. We've found the Fiesta to be an economical car, getting 30 to 35 mpg on short runs and 40 to 45 on the road.”
Lee Phelps, Schoolcraft, Mich: ‘ have a Wil-Rich 20 ft. field cultivator that has been great. but the spring coil mounted at the rear must have been made out of coat hangers,” says Lee. He adds that, “I've always driven 3/4 ton pickups with big V-8 engines and automatic transmission. Recently, went to a 1/2-ton, 6 cylinder with 4speed transmission. Wouldn't go back to a 3/4 ton,”
Massey Ferguson
Richard Walther, Waverly, lowa: Heading his ‘best buy” list are two Massey Ferguson products, ‘Our 2675 Massey tractor with 105 hp. seems to have as much power as most 120 to 130 hp. tractors. With its 27speed transmission, there’s no problem matching pto power with ground speed for almost all implements. All minor problems have been easily fixed. Massey's 880 spring reset plow, with five 18-in. bottoms, pulls easily and works smoothly. No problems in 300 acres of fairly rocky ground. “Our Allis Chalmers 501 power washer has needed no maintenance in five years other than periodic lubrication and a semi-annual check-up" Richard points out, “It’s used for cleaning tractors and equipmentand we've also used itas a water blaster before painting three buildings. With decent care, the washer should last for several more years. “One of the best tillage tools on the market is the Brillion 18-ft. cultimulcher. One pass and you have a prepared seedbed on spring or fallplowed ground. No breakdowns in six years. Neighbors have also used the mulcher on part of their ground,”
John Deere
Dennis Slattery, Hicksville, Ohio: purchased a John Deere 4420 combine last spring for wheat and then used it in corn and soybeans. This machine has had unending trouble with V-belts. Then, in the feederhouse, it started back-feeding under the sprockets and feeder chain. It did this even in wheat straw but “T feel John Deere owes me a new machine and should take this one back.” was terrible in soybeans. Would plug up about every hour and bend the adjusting bolts, plugging at the head so badly you had to chop the straw out with an axe. The dealer worked on it many times to no avail. It also uses a quart of oil a day and the water pump went out. “The machine has 240 hours on it now and is still in warranty. Dealer wants $10,000,10,trade for anewoned feel John Déere owes me a new machine and should take this one back.”
Ralph Miller, Wellington, Kan: “My nomination for ‘worst buy’ is a couple of Ray-Mac Auto-Mac NH3 control valves,’’ says Ralph. “'I bought two of these valves in December 1976 and used them first in the fall of 1977. They worked fairly well the-first season. In May, 1978, the company told me they were replacing the slides, as they were not properly designed. received no replacements. In August, 1978, when one of my slides broke, I called the factory and was told replacements would be sent. This call was followed up with six more phone calls and three letters. The letters were never acknowledged, and the calls were nothing but broken promises of ‘shipment will be made next week’. The last time called was July 21, 1980, Now have two units that have been welded several times and work only part time.”
Roger Fick, Hardwick, Minn: ‘I'd like to nominate my Crysteel truck grain box and Lo-Boy hoist from Crysteel Manufacturing, Lake Crystal, Minn., as best buy,”’ says Roger. “Both box and hoist are wellconstructed of heavy gauge steel. The hoist is designed for maximum lift with no notching of box crossmembers."
New Holland
Earnest Sorensen, Ceylon, Sask: This baler made 1,560 bales last year with only minor adjustments and regular servicing,” reports Earnest, pleased with his New Holland 845 auto-wrap, 800-lb. round baler. “The baler trips and ties in one simple op eration, saving time while shifting and backing to drop the bale. The ‘super sweep’ pick-up on the baler is one of the best. It enables the operator to getall of the finer hay and the chaff when baling straw. Because this machine is chain type, believe it will wear longer than a belt-type baler.” Ed and
Marg Tetreault, Merlin, Ontario: ‘‘We've had excellent quality in our machines purchased recently but the service from some dealerships is poor. Others bend over backwards for their customers. A good dealer usually pre-services the machine. In most cases, we feel the service received from the dealer dictates the satisfaction.”
International Harvester
Wayne F. Lubeski, Bad Axe, Mich: “We ran about 1,000 acres through it last fall without a bit of trouble except for a malfunction in the monitor system,”’ reports Wayne, pleased with his International 1480 Axial-Flow combine. “We harvested corn with moisture content in the 30's with very little kernel damage.” On the negative side, Wayne’s had trouble with his International 250 loader. ‘The frame was bent, or wasn't properly aligned when welded at the factory. We informed the dealer and were assured we would receive a new frame. Six months later we still had no frame. IH said they would send out a field rep but, after another six months, still no rep and the loader remains bent.”
International Harvester + 1 more
Reinhold Schmidt, Robinson, N. Dak: “Seven years ago I bought a 560 International equipped with an F-10 Farmhand loader, The tractor runs fine in summer but, when winter comes, look out. If it's damp, foggy, or cold, the carburetor ices up and for some reason, runs on four out of six cylinders. We recently had it overhauled and, as-it still did the same thing, had to take it back to the shop for more work. We finally purchased an 830 Case with loader.”
Duane Swenson, River Falls, Wis: He's unhappy with his Hesston PT-10 mower-conditioner, purchased in 1978. ‘I hadn't cut more than 10 acres of hay with it when it broke down. I returned it to the dealer who gave me another Hesston to finish cutting with while he fixed mine. “The following spring started out with the fixed PT-10, and I hadn't cut 20 acres before it stopped working. The dealer took it back and brought me outa Hesston 1090, which I used all summer. The dealer returned my PT-10 in the fall. “I started out last summer with the fixed PT-10 and cut 90 acres of hay and the steel started coming off the roller. The company will only make a $300 adjustment on a Hesston that has only cut 120 acres of hay, The price of a roller alone is $600, not including freight or labor.”
Ford + 1 more
Cyril Schank, Fallon, Nev: Cyril's happy with the Ford 6600 tractor he bought last year to work alongside three other Fords in his “tractor stable’. ‘We have a Ford 4000, 5000 and 9600, besides the new 6600, Maintenance is much easier on the Fords and many parts interchange. We especially like the way the 6600 runs our 466 John Deere pto baler. It turns out 100-Ib. or better two-wire bales that are uniform and just what the hay truckers and buyers want. “We average about 600 hrs. per tractor per year, using the 6600 and 4000 daily to feed cattle. The 5000 has a cab and is turbo charged. With about 7000 hrs. on it, it’s never been overhauled and does all our plowing. The 9600 was pur- chased used and does all our disking, ripping, haychopping, and pulls a 14-ft. Towner scraper.” On the negative side, Cyril's disappointed with his Long 460 42-hp. diesel tractor. ‘‘We had purchased our second hand Ford 4000 the year before and used it to do the same work as the new Long 460, which cost nearly twice as much as the Ford with 4,000 hrs. on it. Today, the Ford is still going strong without having had a fraction of the maintenance needed on the Long. “When we could get the Long started it was fine, but half the time it wouldn't start. The first year, while it was under warranty, several things failed, including the pto clutch, electrical system, and battery. They were good at fixing it up for us but the down time was costly. After the guarantee ran out, it lost still another clutch and had more breakdowns that always cost $500 or more to fix. Getting parts was slow. It doesn't pay to buy foreign equipment.”
John Deere
James Neuhaefer, Lacon, Ill: “It's tops in my opinion,” says James, pleased with his new John Deere 4840 tractor. “It replaces a Deere 6030. There's less power, but you get more work done because it's one of the best handling and riding tractors available. You're willing to put in longer hours.”
International Harvester
Ray Brunker, Olathe, Kan: ‘Our Kinze 400 auger wagon has done everything the company said it would do and more,” Ray reports. “We bought it just to ‘hold’ grain while our tandem wagon was in town but have found we use it to catch grain on the go whenever we get the chance. With the auger wagon, we can have our tandem headed back to town with 600 bu. 15 min. after it gets to the field. Ray’s also happy with his International 1460 rotary combine. “Buying the 1460 was one of the best moves we ever made. We've had it for two years now and would never think of going back to a conventional combine. It puts a much better product in the grain tank and has fewer moving parts than other combines.”
John Deere
Clifford Osthus, Sioux Falls, S. Dak: “These tires were on a 4240 John Deere tractor I bought one year ago," says Clifford, upset with his Goodyear tires. ''Cornstalks punctured the two rear tires and nage) both had to be repaired at different times. The front tires had flaws in them and, after 300 hrs. of use, they began to show where they had been spliced together, so I replaced them." Clifford's had good luck, though, with his John Deere grain cart. “It’s great at getting corn out of the field when ground conditions make it impossible to drive a truck in the field, such as in snow or mud. Ordinary wagons are much harder to maneuver under these conditions. In fact, a good truck and this grain cart are all that is needed to harvest corn, beans or small grain.”
Norman Reinhart, Cambridge, Minn: Norman's best buy nomination is his ‘‘Dahlman 20-ft, potato bulk box with extensions from Dahlman Inc., Braham, Minn. use the box for grain hauling, not for potatoes. We hauled more than 50,000 bu. of corn last year with “T use this 20 ft. potato bulk box to haul grain. Works great.” not a bit of trouble. The hydraulic drive on the belt conveyor lets you control the speed of unloading. I'd recommend this product to anyone for moving grain.”
Richard C. Pierce, Stratton, Neb: “We-feel the errors at the factory were the cause of most of our problems during the last two harvests,’’ says Richard, disappointed with his 1979 model 550 MasseyFergtison combine, “It's been nothing but trouble since the day it was delivered. Defective wiring and malfunctioning hydraulics were the first problems. Then, during the two harvests, at least a dozen unloading auger belts had to be replaced. The bearing on the main drive shaft was not properly packed, causing heat to travel down the shaft and making the belts shrink. Also, the tube connecting the separator clutch bearing to the grease bank wasn't hooked up at the factory.”
Yamaha
Terry Kastens, Herndon, Kan: “This three-wheeler has saved us more hours of labor than we ever imagined,"' says Terry about his Yamaha 125 Tri-moto’ threewheeler. '‘We use it mostly for doing chores on our dairy farm, toting buckets of grain and milk from one location to another, It's also handy for checking or herding livestock, checking pasture fences, and just plain getting around when it's muddy. It's been quite trouble-free except for the drive chain, But Yamaha made available a totally enclosed drive chain case which completely eliminated the drive chain problems. “We're upset with our Eagle Eye flowmeter for measuring gallons per minute from irrigation wells by means of measuring differential water pressure,” says Terry. “This meter is grossly inaccurate if the well pumps any air. It's slow, cumbersome and we find it hard to get air removed from the meter. Also, the tube that is placed inside the irrigation pipe to deliver the differential water pressure to the meter is ridiculously expensive for as simple as it looks. I think a rotating-fan type water meter is cheaper, simpler, and more dependable for measuring irrigation flow rates.”
John Deere
Dale K. Moore, Stromsburg, Neb: “I'm very unhappy with the way this planter plants milo seed,” reports Dale, upset with his John Deere Max Emerge 7000 planter. “We continually get 10 to 15-ft. skips unless we go to small seeds. have contacted dealers and district men and always get the same story, that an improvement is on the way. But it never comes." Dale's pleased with another product that he first read about in Bo-Bar wick applicator for applying Roundup to shattercane and volunteer corn in 500 acres of milo and beans. We got good control of both weeds in both crops. We're also pleased with the use of Bicep at planting for control of shattercane in milo," Joseph Dugan, Jr., Roblin, Manitoba: ‘'The teeth are poor and bend very easily,” reports Joseph about his “Crown reel-type stone picker. The company hasn't been of any help in solving the problem,”’
Don Stellpflug, Trempealeau, Wis: ‘It's been my most oulstanding buy in nearly 20 years,” says Don, happy with his Balzer truckmounted manure spreader from Balzer Manufacturing, Mountain Lake, Minn, “I bought it new in 1961. It has spread every kind of manure possible and outlasted two trucks. After over 18 years, it still performs like new.”
Al Denecky, Stirling, Alberta: “We depend on this one machine to harvest approximately 2,400 acres a year,"’ says Al about his “best buy” Gleaner L2 combine. “Tt shows no concern for acres and just keeps right on rolling indefinitely, 1 wouldn't be afraid to tackle twice the acres. We just bought a new one — our third.” He's not happy, however, with his ‘Morris Magnum 35-ft. chisel plow. It wouldn't penetrate and pulled too heavy. The trip release mechanism was too complex to our liking. The dealer and manufacturer ignored our complaints.”
White + 1 more
Craig Sorgenfrie, Winnebago, Minn: ‘The heater hangs outside and blows air into the building — cold air, that is,” says Craig, disappointed with his “L.B. White model 407 barn dryer. The dealer gave so-so service but finally felt 1 could do the repair myself after so many calls. Was only too happy to get rid of it for a heater that works. “My Case 1830 has added enjoyment to my chores and I find new jobs for it every day,’’ continues Craig. “It has the power and ease of a much bigger tractor, Very pleased with Case dealers and look for years of work from my machine,”
W.G. Foote, Wenona, Ill: Heading his ‘‘best buy" list is his 179 grain stirring device from David Manufacturing Company. ‘'This machine has caused no trouble and has been a great time and energy saver in our corn drying."
Allis-Chalmers
Fred Phillips, Lucknow, Ontario: “My Gleaner M combine is a ‘best buy’. It's given me no trouble and is “The corn head isn’t worth the powder to blow it up. Plugs up and is hard to repair.” easy to work on, but the corn head isn't worth the powder to blow it up. Plugs up easy. Hard to repair. Chains always coming off."’ Fred says he’s also had trouble with his Allis Chalmers 770 Air Champ corn planter. “The frame is always breaking. Had to get a welder to the field every year. The seed disc opener plugs easy in sandy ground, causing seed to be buried at least 4 in. instead of 114 in. Needless to say, it has to go, but I can't get rid of it, Even our Allis Chalmers dealer wouldn't touch it.”
Ford + 1 more
Quinton Nelson, Stitzer, Wis: ‘'It's just like driving a Cadillac,’ says Quinton about his 8700 Ford tractor. “Lots of power and easy on fuel. Both the cab and hydraulics are super. No breakdowns in 18 months, ‘We're pleased, too, with our 6620 John Deere sidehill combine purchased last fall. Works great, with well-designed cab and controls. Runs smooth and comfortable. Also, our John Deere 7000 Max Emerge is the best planter we've ever used."
Lyle Abrams, Crookston, Minn: “This is the poorest auger I ever bought,”’ says Lyle, upset with his 67-ft. Versatile auger. ‘It has a bottom drive that has given us trouble from the start. We have also had trouble with flighting that breaks.”
Ted M. Schmidt, Jordan, Mont: ‘' find your magazine the most interesting farm paper have ever read, and read every word init," says Ted.
John Deere
Richard G. Spangler, Wilmington, IIL: “The combine we bought had to have been made from rejected parts,” says Richard, upset with his TR-70 new Holland combine, purchased new in 1978. ‘‘The main shaft was bad, the motor threw a rod, bearings broke, the hydraulics leaked like a sieve, belts broke, and chains snapped.” Richard likes his Deere 7000 12row planter. “It’s accurate, easy to fold when going from field to field.”